A27058:1209
The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended…
The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended vindicator of the primitive church, but indeed of the tympanite & tyranny of some prelates many hundred years after Christ, with a detection of the false history of Edward Lord Bishop of Cork and Ross in Ireland ... and a preface abbreviating much of Ludolphus's History of Habassta : written to show their dangerous error, who think that a general council, or college of bishops, is a supreme governor of all the Christian world ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; to which is added by another hand, a defence of a book, entitled, No evidence for diocesan churches ...The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended vindicator of the primitive church, but indeed of the tympanite & tyranny of some prelates many hundred years after Christ, with a detection of the false history of Edward Lord Bishop of Corke and Rosse in Ireland ... and a preface abbreviating much of Ludolphus's History of Habassta : written to shew their dangerous errour, who think that a general council, or colledge of bishops, is a supream governour of all the Christian world ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; to which is added by another hand, a defence of a book, entituled, No evidence for diocesan churches ...
London: printed for Tho. Parkhurst, 1682
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§ 4. If you think you have proved all those Impositions sinless which I have mentioned in my first Plea for Peace, I think you might as well have shortly said, [We Bishops are of so much Wisdom and Authority, that you must hold them lawful, because we say so.] And must all be ruined that would not be so convinced? But if any of those Impositions prove to be sin, and so great sin as we cannot choose but think they are, is it a greater fault to name them (when importuned) than to impose them? And a greater fault to feel, and say we feel, than to strike or wound men?
§ 4. If you think you have proved all those Impositions sinless which I have mentioned in my first Plea for Peace, I think you might as well have shortly said, [We Bishops are of so much Wisdom and Authority, that you must hold them lawful, because we say so.] And must all be ruined that would not be so convinced? But if any of those Impositions prove to be sin, and so great sin as we cannot chuse but think they are, is it a greater fault to name them (when importuned) than to impose them? And a greater fault to feel, and say we feel, than to strike or wound men?
If we had taken it to be our Duty to have called those Clergy-Men to Repentance, which we think are ignorantly undoing themselves and the Land, how should we do it without ⟨p. 221⟩naming their Sin? Yea, and the greatness of it? And if we think it our Duty to deprecate our Destruction, and beg of you to spare our Lives or Consciences, how can we do it without telling what we suffer? If it be well done of you, and be no persecution, but your Duty for the Churches good, (as no doubt the Executioners think) the History is your praise, and you need not extenuate the Fact: Valiant Soldiers glory in the multitudes they kill: Had you silenced the other 7000 that conformed, when you silenced but 2000, your Victory had been the more famous. Some think those that are here against your ways, are not half the Land; were it murdering of one man, that another is judged for, it were not unpeaceableness to say, that he deserveth to be hanged: But the judge deserveth praise if he condemn an hundred such. But when those men who should be the tenderest Peace-makers, and skilfullest therein, shall be the men that bring such a Land as this into the Case that we are in, and will not be entreated, nor by any Experience be persuaded to consent to its Relief, I know not how to show mercy to the Land or them, but by persuading them to repent. And if all sin were made a matter of Controversy, and many learned men were for it, this would not alter the Case with me. If I may compare great things with small, who sinned more? The Irish for murdering 200000, or Sir John Temple, Dr. Henry Jones, the E. of Orery, for recording and reporting what they did? Was it the sin of the Savoyards and others to kill and ruin the Protestants in Piedmont? Or of Perrin, and Sir Sam. Mooreland to write the story? Did Thuanus, Davilah, &c. sin in recording the French Massacre? Or the French in doing it? Is it the French Protestants now that are criminal for describing and complaining of their Sufferings? Was John Fox the Malefactor for writing the Sufferings of the Protestants under a lawful Queen? This day came out (