A27058:726
The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended…
The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended vindicator of the primitive church, but indeed of the tympanite & tyranny of some prelates many hundred years after Christ, with a detection of the false history of Edward Lord Bishop of Cork and Ross in Ireland ... and a preface abbreviating much of Ludolphus's History of Habassta : written to show their dangerous error, who think that a general council, or college of bishops, is a supreme governor of all the Christian world ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; to which is added by another hand, a defence of a book, entitled, No evidence for diocesan churches ...The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended vindicator of the primitive church, but indeed of the tympanite & tyranny of some prelates many hundred years after Christ, with a detection of the false history of Edward Lord Bishop of Corke and Rosse in Ireland ... and a preface abbreviating much of Ludolphus's History of Habassta : written to shew their dangerous errour, who think that a general council, or colledge of bishops, is a supream governour of all the Christian world ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; to which is added by another hand, a defence of a book, entituled, No evidence for diocesan churches ...
London: printed for Tho. Parkhurst, 1682
The particular Defence of the History of Councils and Schisms. › Chapter 18: Of his Second Chapter.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§ 8. But I somewhat marvel that he is again at it (reciting Dionysius's words which he thinks I mistook for Eusebius's) That he does not condemn the rebaptizing of Heretics which was a Tradition of so great antiquity: I judge more Candidly of him than he doth of me: Though he so oft repeat it, I will not believe that he knew not, that it was not the baptizing of Heretics as such, that was the question: but only of those that were baptized by Heretics. Yet I confess Eusebius phrasing it, might tempt one to think so that had not read Cyprian and others upon the questions. But when Eusebius and Dionysius mention [rebaptizing Heretics] they mean only those that were by Heretics baptism entered into the Societies and Profession of Heretics. If the worst Heretic, yea or Apostate, had been baptized, by the orthodox, Cyprian and all the rest were agreed against Rebaptizing such when they repented. This Dionysius telling Xystus Rom. of an ancient Minister that was greatly troubled in Conscience that he had been falsely Baptized by an Heretic (being himself no Heretic) and doubted whether he should not be Rebaptized, yet saith, He told him he durst not Rebaptize him that had so long been in the Church and Communicated, but bid him go on Comfortably in Communion (Much like a forementioned case put to me, by some that never were Baptized, but in our undisciplined Parish Churches had been without knowledge or question admitted long to Communion, whether yet they should be Baptized at all: And Dionysius's Reasons against it I cannot answer.
§ 8. But I somewhat marvel that he is again at it (reciting Dionysius's words which he thinks I mistook for Eusebius's) That he does not condemn the rebaptizing of Hereticks which was a Tradition of so great antiquity: I judge more Candidly of him than he doth of me: Though he so oft repeat it, I will not believe that he knew not, that it was not the baptizing of Hereticks as such, that was the question: but only of those that were baptized by Hereticks. Yet I confess Eusebius phrasing it, might tempt one to think so that had not read Cyprian and others upon the questions. But when Eusebius and Dionysius mention [rebaptizing Hereticks] they mean only those that were by Hereticks baptism entered into the Societies and Profession of Hereticks. If the worst Heretick, yea or Apostate, had been baptized, by the orthodox, Cyprian and all the rest were agreed against Rebaptizing such when they repented. This Dionysius telling Xystus Rom. of an ancient Minister that was greatly troubled in Conscience that he had been falsly Baptized by an Heretick (being himself no Heretick) and doubted whether he should not be Rebaptized, yet saith, He told him he durst not Rebaptize him that had so long been in the Church and Communicated, but bid him go on Comfortably in Communion (Much like a forementioned case put to me, by some that never were Baptized, but in our undisciplined Parish Churches had been without knowledge or question admitted long to Communion, whether yet they should be Baptized at all: And Dionysius's Reasons against it I cannot answer.