A27059:280
Two disputations of original sin I. of original sin as from Adam, II. of…
Two disputations of original sin I. of original sin as from Adam, II. of original sin as from our nearer parents : written long ago for a more private use, and now published (with a preface) upon the invitation of Dr. T. Tully / by Richard Baxter.Two disputations of original sin I. of original sin as from Adam, II. of original sin as from our neerer parents : written long ago for a more private use, and now published (with a preface) upon the invitation of Dr. T. Tullie / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Robert Gibbs, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Prop. 5. If it should prove true, which some of the Reformed Divines maintain, that original sin doth consist only in the real qualitative corruption of our nature, and not directly in any imputation of Adam's actual sin to us; and that there is no such direct imputation of his sin to us, but that it is only the cause of our proper Original sin, and not our sin formally: then must it needs follow that the like must be said for the negative, of the sins of our immediate Parents: for they can be no more our sins, than Adam's was. If this opinion therefore stand good, then our controversy is at an end; and we are not guilty either of Adam's sin, or of our next Parents, nor of death for them. I will not presume to make my self judge between the Learned Divines that disagree upon this point: Camero and his followers go this way, against the imputation of Adam's sin to us: of which see the sum of their Arguments in Jos. Placaeus his Disputat. de statu hominis lapsi ante Gratiam in lib. 1. Thesium Salmuriens. pag. 206, 207. And Chamier is not only of the same mind, but confuteth the contrary among ⟨p. 149⟩the Popish errors, as you may see in Tom. 3. lib. 1. cap. 7. against Pighius sect. 20, 21. but specially throughout chap. 8. contra Salmeronem. So also Peter Martyr on Rom. 5. But yet the far greater number of our Writers go the other way, and so do the Papists too.
Prop. 6. It seems not to be a guilt so plenary and perfect, which we lie under for any Parents sin, (if such a thing be proved), as that is which a man is under for his own personal sin. The difference will appear, if we consider that it is not a punishment in so full and perfect a sense, which we are obliged to: for the suffering is but the matter of the punishment; its form lieth in the relation of that suffering to the fault: if the malum naturale be not propter malum morale, it is not punishment: and the punishment is his in the fullest sense, who suffereth for his own sin: now the sin of Adam, or any Parent, is not so fully our own as that is which we personally commit; seeing as we were but seminally, causally, and potentially in our Parents, and not by existence personally; so it is not so much to be esteemed the son of a sinner, as to be esteemed the actual sinner himself. So that it seems our guilt of, and punishment for the actual sin of any Parent, is so called by analogy of attribution