A27059:359
Two disputations of original sin I. of original sin as from Adam, II. of…
Two disputations of original sin I. of original sin as from Adam, II. of original sin as from our nearer parents : written long ago for a more private use, and now published (with a preface) upon the invitation of Dr. T. Tully / by Richard Baxter.Two disputations of original sin I. of original sin as from Adam, II. of original sin as from our neerer parents : written long ago for a more private use, and now published (with a preface) upon the invitation of Dr. T. Tullie / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Robert Gibbs, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Having given this explication, I suppose little more need to be said for the proof of the premises. For the major, it seems now clear, that a person who hath lost his right totally to life, or any blessing, cannot convey to another person, of whom he is the root, a nature that hath right to that life or blessing. For nemo dat quod non habet. 2. And this seems plainly to be no mere negation of right, (in the derived nature,) but a privation. Because if our progenitors had none of them sinned, we should have been born with that right which now we want; and so we had seminally and virtually a right our selves: which being lost, it is a privation to us, and not a mere negation; and so a punishment, and not a mere affliction: Yet as the right of our Parents themselves, (as Adam) who were personally existent, was a more full and proper right than ours who were but seminally in them; so our privation is not in so plenary and proper a sense called a privation, nor a punishment, as theirs is, or as our own is for our actual sins: And so our guilt is not so full and proper a guilt; but analogically so called, as Accidens is called Ens. And this seems to me to be the true difference between our guilt of our Parents sins, and of our own: and our punishment for theirs, (original from Adam, ⟨p. 193⟩or others,) and of our own actual sin. And perhaps Zuinglius meant thus, when he denied Original sin to be properly called sin. So far as such a seminal right or possibility which the seed hath through the Parent, doth differ from the Parents own right; so far there is a difference in the formal nature of penalty and guilt, upon the loss of that right. It is doubtless some more loss that the Son of a Traitor hath, by his Fathers forfeiture of his Lands, than a stranger may be said to have by that forfeiture, who never was in a possibility of enjoying them. It is therefore no mere negation, but a privation, and consequently participateth of the nature of penalty, and the obligation thereto of the nature of guilt. And thus in the major proposition of this Argument I place the very reason of original guilt, from Adam, or any Parents.
Having given this explication, I suppose little more need to be said for the proof of the premises. For the major, it seems now clear, that a person who hath lost his right totally to life, or any blessing, cannot convey to another person, of whom he is the root, a nature that hath right to that life or blessing. For nemo dat quod non habet. 2. And this seems plainly to be no meer negation of right, (in the derived nature,) but a privation. Because if our progenitors had none of them sinned, we should have been born with that right which now we want; and so we had seminally and virtually a right our selves: which being lost, it is a privation to us, and not a meer negation; and so a punishment, and not a meer affliction: Yet as the right of our Parents themselves, (as Adam) who were personally existent, was a more full and proper right than ours who were but seminally in them; so our privation is not in so plenary and proper a sense called a privation, nor a punishment, as theirs is, or as our own is for our actual sins: And so our guilt is not so full and proper a guilt; but analogically so called, as Accidens is called Ens. And this seems to me to be the true difference between our guilt of our Parents sins, and of our own: and our punishment for theirs, (original from Adam,