A27068:106
Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly…
Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly their pastors, or bishops over their flocks ... : written by Richard Baxter as an explication of some passages in his former writings, especially his Treatise of episcopacy, misunderstood and misapplied by some, and answering the strongest objections of some of them, especially a book called, Mr. Baxters judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish assemblies, as by law required, and another called, A theological dialogue, or, Catholic communion once more defended, upon mens necessitating importunity / by Richard Baxter.Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly their pastors, or bishops over their flocks ... : written by Richard Baxter as an explication of some passages in his former writings, especially his Treatise of episcopacy, misunderstood and misapplied by some, and answering the strongest objections of some of them, especially a book called, Mr. Baxters judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish assemblies, as by law required, and another called, A theological dialogue, or, Catholick communion once more defended, upon mens necessitating importunity / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1684
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
XXXV. But then (say the Objectors) such Churches are Dissenters; as such you join with them, and not as settled by Law, and so it is but a Conventicle, and is excommunicated by the Canon, or you excommunicated for saying it is a Church, and joining with it.
XXXV. But then (say the Objectors) such Churches are Dissenters; as such you joyn with them, and not as setled by Law, and so it is but a Conventicle, and is excommunicated by the Canon, or you excommunicated for saying it is a Church, and joyning with it.
Ans. 1. What if all this be true? Doth it follow, that I must separate from it? Are not your private Churches more unquestionably Excommunicate, &c. by the Canon, and yet you separate not from them? Can you see but on one side?
2. But your Affirmation proveth not that the Law nulleth such Ministers, or Churches, as use the Liturgy, and subscribe in the favourable sense, tho it should prove a mistake. It must first be tried and judged to be a mistaken sense, and even where they (strangely) Excommunicate, ipso facto, the fact must be proved and declared by the Judg, before Priest and people are bound to Execution, (tho the Law be loco sententiae; ⟨p. 18⟩the […] being proved and declared), no man is bound to do Execution on himself.
2. But your Affirmation proveth not that the Law nulleth such Ministers, or Churches, as use the Liturgy, and subscribe in the favourable sence, tho it should prove a mistake. It must first be tryed and judged to be a mistaken sense, and even where they (strangely) Excommunicate, ipso facto, the fact must be proved and declared by the Judg, before Priest and people are bound to Execution, (tho the Law be loco sententiae;