A27068:302
Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly…
Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly their pastors, or bishops over their flocks ... : written by Richard Baxter as an explication of some passages in his former writings, especially his Treatise of episcopacy, misunderstood and misapplied by some, and answering the strongest objections of some of them, especially a book called, Mr. Baxters judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish assemblies, as by law required, and another called, A theological dialogue, or, Catholic communion once more defended, upon mens necessitating importunity / by Richard Baxter.Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly their pastors, or bishops over their flocks ... : written by Richard Baxter as an explication of some passages in his former writings, especially his Treatise of episcopacy, misunderstood and misapplied by some, and answering the strongest objections of some of them, especially a book called, Mr. Baxters judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish assemblies, as by law required, and another called, A theological dialogue, or, Catholick communion once more defended, upon mens necessitating importunity / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1684
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. All human actions have their faults: must we therefore do nothing, or converse with no men? England is one Kingdom; If there be one or many faults in its Laws or officers, may we therefore obey none that are faultless? The Laws are the Rule of National Justice; may a Judg, Justice, Officer or subject use none of them, because some are faulty? Doth that make him guilty of all? Bonum est ex causis integris: The fault of a part may indeed denominate the whole faulty so far. But the whole Law or Liturgy may be called faulty for a part, and yet he that useth either, not be guilty of any of the bad part, for using the good. The Law and Liturgy are one thing, and the use is another: Its faults are no further his, than he owneth them; your Bread or Meat may be called bad, if part only be bad, and yet if you eat none but the good part, it will not hurt you.
2. But if it must be otherwise, no man may hear you, or join with your Churches: And do you think (as aforesaid) that Mr. Faldo, and all his Church at Barnet, lived not in a sinful communion very many years, that omitted at least an integral part of public worship, the singing of Gods praise? Christ with his Disciples sung a Hymn after the Sacrament. The Jews Church made it the chief part of their Worship. James prescribeth it us in all our Holy Mirth, such as the Lords Day is appointed for, 1 Cor. 14.26. Every one had a Psalm, and with them no one had a Psalm, ⟨p. 5⟩tho his Judgment was for it; the question was, Whether he should forsake them for refusing it: I thought not, because it was better that they had something that was good, than nothing. But your argument would not only unchurch them, but make all sinners that communicated with them: for omissions of great duties are faults, and greater faults than tolerable failings in performance: He that prayeth not at all, doth worse than he that prayeth by a Book; and he that preacheth or teacheth not at all, doth worse than he that readeth a Sermon; so that their total stated omission and opposition to singing, by your false rule, denominated them no worshippers of God, if the whole must be denominated from a part.