A27068:328
Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly…
Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly their pastors, or bishops over their flocks ... : written by Richard Baxter as an explication of some passages in his former writings, especially his Treatise of episcopacy, misunderstood and misapplied by some, and answering the strongest objections of some of them, especially a book called, Mr. Baxters judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish assemblies, as by law required, and another called, A theological dialogue, or, Catholic communion once more defended, upon mens necessitating importunity / by Richard Baxter.Whether parish congregations be true Christian churches and the capable consenting incumbents, be truly their pastors, or bishops over their flocks ... : written by Richard Baxter as an explication of some passages in his former writings, especially his Treatise of episcopacy, misunderstood and misapplied by some, and answering the strongest objections of some of them, especially a book called, Mr. Baxters judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish assemblies, as by law required, and another called, A theological dialogue, or, Catholick communion once more defended, upon mens necessitating importunity / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1684
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans. 1. This is the great strength of all his Book, That we sin by a false rule, but they sin only against a true rule; but I think nothing is sin indeed, but that which is against a true rule, even Gods word; making and using a false rule, is therefore sin, because it is against the true rule. Most hypocrites are supposed to own a true rule while they are false to it, and sin against it. To sin against knowledge, and an acknowledged rule, is an aggravation of the sin, and such shall be beaten with many stripes: Paul opens it to the Jews, Rom. 2. at large, therefore this will not excuse our communion with such.
2. This Reason crosseth the business of the opponent; for whereas the greatest reason against Communion with Parish Churches is the badness of the Communicants, and Ministers lives; these are not the obeying of the Law or Canons, but disobeying them: The Law, called the Rule, bids no man swear rashly, lye, be drunk, unclean, slander, rail, &c. Nay it commandeth the Minister to deny the Sacrament to such: Ignorance, unbelief, hypocrisy, are not commanded, but forbidden by that Rule: Ministers break the rule, i• they preach error, or heresy, or against Love and Peace, and promote not Godliness, and mens salvation, with all holy diligence, by Doctrine and Life; so that no sins against this is cause of separation, if it be only using a false rule that is, just cause.
2. This Reason crosseth the business of the opponent; for whereas the greatest reason against Communion with Parish Churches is the badness of the Communicants, and Ministers lives; these are not the obeying of the Law or Canons, but disobeying them: The Law, called the Rule, bids no man swear rashly, lye, be drunk, unclean, slander, rail, &c. Nay it commandeth the Minister to deny the Sacrament to such: Ignorance, unbelief, hypocrisie, are not commanded, but forbidden by that Rule: Ministers break the rule, i• they preach error, or heresie, or against Love and Peace, and promote not Godliness, and mens salvation, with all holy diligence, by Doctrine and Life; so that no sins against this is cause of separation, if it be only using a false rule that is, just cause.