A27069:102
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But now, pag. 11. he proceeds to assault me, with such reasoning as this: No man knoweth all that God hath revealed, to wit, with an actual understanding of every particular: 1Ergo say I, No man believes all that God hath revealed. Now I proceed, If no man believe all that God hath revealed, then you believe not all that God hath revealed. Then further, Whoever believeth not all that God hath revealed, is no good Christian, nor in state of salvation: But you believe not all that God hath revealed, Ergo, you are no good Christian, nor in a state of salvation. See you not how fair a thread you have spun? Or will you say, that he that believes not all that God hath revealed is a good Christian? If you will, you may; but no good Christian will believe you.
But now, pag. 11. he proceeds to assault me, with such reasoning as this: No man knoweth all that God hath revealed, to wit, with an actual understanding of every particular: 1Ergo say I, No man believes all that God hath revealed. Now I proceed, If no man believe all that God hath revealed, then you believe not all that God hath revealed. Then further, Whoever believeth not all that God hath revealed, is no good Christian, nor in state of salvation: But you believe not all that God hath revealed, Ergo, you are no good Christian, nor in a state of salvation. See you not how fair a thred you have spun? Or will you say, that he that believes not all that God hath revealed is a good Christian? If you will, you may; but no good Christian will believe you.
- 1Sect. 8.
Answ. The man seemeth in good sadness in all this Childish Play; And must Rome be thus upheld? And must poor mens Faith and Consciences be thus laid upon a game at Cheating Words? No wonder that this Hector would have nothing said in dispute but syllogism, &c. Few Lads and Women would unmask his pitiful deceits; whether the great disputer saw their vanity himself I know not: But men at age, that can speak and try sense, will see, that all this Cant is but the sporting-equivocation of one syllable ALL: This ALL is either a term of a mere general proposition: e. g. All Gods word is true. Here I believe what is predicated of this general word ALL, and take this for a true proposition, ALL Gods word is true: Or it signifieth the very things, species, or parts, as in themselves known; and so if the very things, species, or parts generally expressed by the word ALL, be not themselves known as such things, species, or parts, it is no actual knowledge of them at all, to know that truth of the said general proposition. And doth not every novice in Logic know this? The same I say of Beliefs as of Knowledge; He is no good Christian, who believeth not that all Divine Revelations are true (which Heretics and Heathens believe) But neither I, nor any Christian known to him or me, knoweth or believeth ALL the particular verities which God hath revealed: And he believeth not one of them (beside that proposition it self which is found among the rest) who believeth but that general.