3. Where shall we find any Commentary that the Fathers agreed in, though the Trent-Oath is that you will not exp•nd the Scripture but according to the Fathers consent. Your writers tell us that most whose works be come to us, for the first 300 years▪ were Millenaries, Dionys. Petavius hath gathered the words of Arian doctrine from most of them (lib. de Trinit.) till after the Council of Nice; yea that the chief of the Anti-Arians, even Athanasius himself. †was for three Gods, telling us that as Peter, Paul, and John were three names, but ⟨p. 147⟩one in Essence, that is in Specie, so is the Father, Son and Holy Ghost: when your Doctors tell us, that Justin, Clem. Alexander, Dionysius Alexand. Talianus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Origen, Eusebius, and I know not how many more taught Heresy: and Chrysostom, Basil, and many others that we hoped had been Christians, are noted as fautors of Origen: and even many of the Martyrs were Heretics, when through the reign of Theodosius, Senior; Arcadius and Honorius, Theodosius, Junior; Valentinian, (to say nothing of Constantius and Valens, &c. of the Arians) yea and of Marcian, Leo, Zeno, Anastaslus, Justine, almost all the Churches of the Empire continued charging each others with Heresy: and Councils charging and condemning Councils; Bishops deposing, and cursing Bishops; and Monks as their Soldiers fighting it out to blood; when the obeying or cursing the Council of Calcedon divided the Bishops for many Princes reigns: and when one part called the other Nestorians, and the other called them Eutychians, almost every where, and when after that the Monothelites cause was in many Emperors Reign uppermost one while, and down another; and navicula Petri that alone scaped before, was thus drowned by Honorius (if Councils belie him not and Popes) with the rest. When the very same Bishops (as at Ephesus and Calcedon) went one way in one Council and another way in the next, and subscribed to one Edict e. g. of Basiliscus, and quickly to the contrary of another, and cried […], we did it through fear. How should we then know by Fathers, Bishops and Councils, what was their concordant Commentary of the Scripture?
3. Where shall we find any Commentary that the Fathers agreed in, though the Trent-Oath is that you will not exp•nd the Scripture but according to the Fathers consent. Your writers tell us that most whose works be come to us, for the first 300 years▪ were Millenaries, Dionys. Petavius hath gathered the words of Arrian doctrine from most of them (lib. de Trinit.) till after the Council of Nice; yea that the chief of the Anti-Arrians, even Athanassus himself. †was for three Gods, telling us that as Peter, Paul, and Iohn were three names, but ⟨p. 147⟩one in Essence, that is in Specie, so is the Father, Son and Holy Ghost: when your Doctors tell us, that Iustin, Clem. Alexander, Dionysius Alexand. Talianus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Origen, Eysebius, and I know not how many more taught Heresie: and Chrysostom, Basil, and many others that we hoped had been Christians, are noted as fautors of Origen: and even many of the Martyrs were Hereticks, when through the reign of Theodosius, Senior; Arcadius and Honorius, Theodosius, Junior; Valentinian, (to say nothing of Constantius and Valens, &c. of the Arrians) yea and of Marcian, Leo, Zeno, Anastaslus, Iustine, almost all the Churches of the Empire continued charging each others with Heresie: and Councils charging and condemning Councils; Bishops deposing, and cursing Bishops; and Monks as their Souldiers fighting it out to blood; when the obeying or cursing the Council of Calcedon divided the Bishops for many Princes reigns: and when one part called the other Nestorians, and the other called them Eutychians, almost every where, and when after that the Monothelites cause was in many Emperors Reign uppermost one while, and down another; and navicula Petri that alone scaped before, was thus drowned by Honorius (if Councils belie him not and Popes) with the rest. When the very same Bishops (as at Ephesus and Calcedon) went one way in one Council and another way in the next, and subscribed to one Edict e. g. of Basiliscus, and quickly to the contrary of another, and cryed 〈…〉, we did it through fear. How should we then know by Fathers, Bishops and Councils, what was their concordant Commentary of the Scripture?
- †Of which see also Derod•n de supposit•.