A27069:1172
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§. 14. Next I thus Argued, If sincere Protestants are Members of the True Church, as intrinsically informed (or as Bellarmine speaketh, Living Members) then professed Protestants are Members of the true Church, as extrinsically denominated (or as it is Visible) consisting of Professors: But the Antecedent is true; Ergo, so is the Consequent.
§. 14. Next I thus Argued, If sincere Protestants are Members of the True Church, as intrinsecally informed (or as Bellarmine speaketh, Living Members) then professed Protestants are Members of the true Church, as extrinsecally denominated (or as it is Visible) consisting of Professours: But the Antecedent is true; Ergo, so is the Consequent.
To this (when I had given the Reason of the Consequence undeniable) and said, I prove the Antecedent or Minor, he saith, You prove, say you, your Antecedent or Minor, which is a Syntax in Logic, and deserves a Ferula, for no Minor can be an Antecedent.
To this (when I had given the Reason of the Consequence undenyable) and said, I prove the Antecedent or Minor, he saith, You prove, say you, your Antecedent or Minor, which is a Syntax in Logick, and deserves a Ferula, for no Minor can be an Antecedent.
Answ. For this Mans sake, I will know a Man better than by his Hectoring, before I will go to School to a boaster. Reader, 1. What is that Error in Logic that is called a Syntax? I thought Order or Concord had been no Error: I confess my self not wise enough to understand this great Logician. And his Ferula is too ready, which must be used for Syntaxes, when it is more used for violation of Syntax. 2. Risum teneatis: Can no Antecedent be a Minor (so did Dr. Peter Heylin tell me before him, in his Certamen Epistolare:) I suppose I shall never hear a third say so. What's the matter, that the Boys Laugh at this, and say, that to deny the Antecedent of an hypothetical Proposition, and to deny the minor is all one? Is it that Boys have made all our usual Logics, and now these two Logic Doctors have Reformed them? Or hath this Man pretended to be a Champion in that Art, in which he is below the Novices? He had hit it if he had held to his offer to Dispute before a Lady (a Girl) only in Syllogism by the Pen; for this with her might have past for currant and invincible Logic.