A27069:1279
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Reader, see here what an Issue our Dispute is brought to: Can you wish a plainer? I proved that our Religion, being nothing else but Christianity, our Church hath been still Visible. because it is confessed, that the Christian Church hath been still Visible. But the Papists must have us prove also, that our Church-hath been still Visible, as without Popery. I now prove Popery a Novelty; and doth not that then fully prove my Consequence, that the Christian Church was Visible without it? And I prove, that this Novelty of Popery is yet received but by the third part of Christians (of whom I am persuaded ten to one are either compelled to profess what they believe not, or understand it not:) Therefore the Christian Church was once wholly, and is yet mostly without Popery. I know not when a Cause is given up, if here he give not up his Cause.
Answ. Reader, see here what an Issue our Dispute is brought to: Can you wish a plainer? I proved that our Religion, being nothing else but Christianity, our Church hath been still Visible. because it is confessed, that the Christian Church hath been still Visible. But the Papists must have us prove also, that our Church-hath been still Visible, as without Popery. I now prove Popery a Novelty; and doth not that then fully prove my Consequence, that the Christian Church was Visible without it? And I prove, that this Novelty of Popery is yet received but by the third part of Christians (of whom I am perswaded ten to one are either compelled to profess what they believe not, or understand it not:) Therefore the Christian Church was once wholly, and is yet mostly without Popery. I know not when a Cause is given up, if here he give not up his Cause.
§. 41. Twelve new Articles of the Papal Faith I named: 1. That the Pope is above a• ⟨p. 160⟩General Council; Decreed at Later. and Florence. 2. Contrarily, That the Council is above the Pope, and may Judge him, &c. Decreed at Basil and Constance: True before, as a point of Humane Order, but not made ever an Article of Faith. 3. That the Pope may Depose Princes, and give their Dominions to others, if they exterminate not all their Subjects that deny Transubstantiation; Decreed at Later. sub. Innoc. 3. 4. That the Body and Blood, together with the Soul and Divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ, is truly, and really, and substantially in the Eucharist; and that there is a change of the whole substance of Bread, into the Body, and of the whole substance of Wine, into the Blood, which they call Transubstantiation: Decreed at Trent, and proved new by Ed. Albertinus, Bishop Cousin's History of Trans. and by my self. 5. That the Eucharist is rightly given and taken under one kind (without the Cup:) Decreed at Constance and Trent. 6. That we must never take and Interpret Scripture, but according to the unanimous consent of the Fathers. See the Trent-Oath; whereas, 1. We have no certainty whom to take for Fathers (a great part being called both Fathers and Heretics by the Papists.) 2. And they greatly disagree among themselves. 3. And have not unanimously given us any sense at all of a quarter of the Bible (if of the hundredth part.) 7. That there is a Purgatory, and that the Souls there detained, are holpen by the Suffrages of the Faithful. 8. That the Holy Catholic Church of Rome is the Mother and Mistress of all Churches, (and yet it is the Catholic, that is, the whole it self.) 9. That Traditions are to be received with equal pious Affection and Reverence as the Holy Scripture. 10. That the Virgin Mary was conceived without Original sin: Decreed at Basil. 11. That the people may not read the Scripture Translated into a known Tongue, without a special License. 12. That the Books of Maccabees, and other such, are part of the Canon of Faith; (against which, see Bishop Cousins, and Dr. Jo. Reignolds.)