A27069:1305
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I wrote him so plain and full an Answer to this, that I shall only refer the Reader to the perusal of it, instead of any defence.
To this he concludeth with such a Discourse, that would make a Man lament that such distracted stuff should be thought sufficient to deceive poor Souls. He rants at me for distinguishing: He must have had me directly Answer his Question with Yea or Nay; and instead of Answering, ad rem, to have entered an Idle controversy with him, which of all the sorts commonly called Heretics, are properly so called. And when no Man can resolve us, whether [properly so called] must be expounded by Etymology, or by the Canon; and by what Canon? Or by the Fathers Catalogues, and by which Fathers (Epiphanius, Philastrius, Augustine, &c.) or by common custom, or by the Pope? How should ever this idle controversy of [properly so called] have ever come to any Resolution, unless by making himself the Judge.
To this he concludeth with such a Discourse, that would make a Man lament that such distracted stuff should be thought sufficient to deceive poor Souls. He rants at me for distinguishing: He must have had me directly Answer his Question with Yea or Nay; and instead of Answering, ad rem, to have entred an Idle controversie with him, which of all the sorts commonly called Hereticks, are properly so called. And when no Man can resolve us, whether [properly so called] must be expounded by Etymology, or by the Canou; and by what Canon? Or by the Fathers Catalogues, and by which Fathers (Epiphanius, Philastrius, Augustine, &c.) or by common custom, or by the Pope? How should ever this idle controversie of [properly so called] have ever come to any Resolution, unless by making himself the Judge.
Yet doth the Man absurdly say to me, We are not agreed what the Universal Visible Church is: What of that? Are we not agreed there is such a thing? Think you or I what we will of the definition of it, 'tis sufficient to give an Answer, pro or con, to my Question, whether Heretics be true Members of the Church: And it will be time enough to explicate what you mean by the Universal Church, when your Answer is impugned—See you not again, that whatsoever you or I understand by [Heretic properly so called] we both agree that there are Heretics properly so called; and that's enough to Answer my Question, &c.