A27069:1387
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
7. But it is the fate of rash condemners to condemn themselves most notoriously; If the plain words of Scripture, in the institution of the Cup in the Eucharist, against praying in an unknown tongue, &c. If the sensible evidence of Bread and Wine to all sound Senses that are near, be not a sufficient proposal, what is? Surely not such self-contradicting disputes as this of W. I. and others like him; nor the Cant of [the Church and all the world] by a partial Sect: but if Scripture, the Tradition and Judgment of the most of Christians, Reason and Sense, can make up a sufficient proposal; out of their own mouths are these men condemned as Heretics, to be avoided by all good Christians. But I have more Charity for some of them, then herein they exercise to themselves, (or others.)
7. But it is the fate of rash condemners to condemn themselves most notoriously; If the plain words of Scripture, in the institution of the Cup in the Eucharist, against praying in an unknown tongue, &c. If the sensible evidence of Bread and Wine to all sound Senses that are neer, be not a sufficient proposal, what is? Surely not such self-contradicting disputes as this of W. I. and others like him; nor the Cant of [the Church and all the world] by a partial Sect: but if Scripture, the Tradition and Judgment of the most of Christians, Reason and Sense, can make up a sufficient proposal; out of their own mouths are these men condemned as Hereticks, to be avoided by all good Christians. But I have more Charity for some of them, then herein they exercise to themselves, (or others.)
And in particular I will be so far from partiality, as to profess that though Pope Honorius was an anathematized Heretic in the judgment of the 6th. and other General Councils, and of his Successors Popes, I am not one of those that take him really for such, in W. I's. sense; as held a Doctrine that did unchristen him. Nay I take his Epistles to Sergius read in the 6th. General Council, to be two of the honestest peaceable Epistles that I have read from a Pope, except some of Leo's, and few more; and I think that his counsel for to avoid contention, to forbear both the name of [two operations] and of [one operation] and leave it to Grammarians, and hold to plain Scripture-words, was honest counsel. And the hereticating of him and the rest by that Council increaseth not my veneration, but my great dislike of Hereticating Councils and the factions of the Bishops: it was not long after (under the Emperor Philipicus) when another General Council so great, as it's said it consisted of Innumerable Bishops at Constantinople, revoked, undid, and destroyed all this that was done against Honorius and the Monothelites at the said 6th. Council; so ordinarily did General Councils condemn each other.