A27069:558
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Part 1 › Chapter 7: What mean you by [SCHISM.]Part 1 › Chapter 7: What mean you by [SCHISME.]
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. Reader, do but read their Councils, Church-Histories, (Baronius, Genebrard, Plati•, Wernerus, to whom I may add above one hundred,) and if thou dost not find them, (and also their polemical and practical Divines) commonly mentioning [Schisms in the Church of Rome it self,] then believe these deceivers and call me the deceiver. Do they not lament their Schisms? Were not the Councils of Constance, Basil, Pisa, &c. called to heal them? Do they not number the Schisms that fell out in 40 or 50 years time and continued? Dare any man deny it?
Were these then Proper Schisms or not? No, it's like this man would say that none of these Writers speak properly when they call it Schism. I would he would tell in the next what proper word to use.
But either these Schisms were within the Church or without it. (Reader, see whither falsehood will run at last) If they were within the Church, then W. I. doth but abuse you by his falsehoods, If without the Church then one half the Roman Church was Unchurched for 40 or 50 years when they followed one Pope, while the other half followed another. And who knoweth which of these parts was the Church? It seems whoever adhered to the wrong Pope was none of the Church. But, saith Wernerus and other Historians, sometimes the wisest were at their Wits end, and knew not which was the true Pope, nor is it known to this day. Nay the matter is yet worse: A great General Council deposed Euginius the Fourth as no Pope, but an uncapable wicked Heretic, and yet he kept in, and became the only Head of their Church, whom the rest succeed. And so all that Church by this rule was unchurched. Sure necessity must make you recant, and say, that yet both Parties in your ⟨p. 61⟩long and odious Schisms were within the Church, or else what a Wound will ye inflict on it? But an ill Cause will admit of no defence: If you come to this, mark what will follow: Even that millions are in the Church that are no Subjects of the Pope, but do reject him. If there were two real Popes, there were two real Churches, and therefore neither of them was Universal; and consequently neither of the two were Popes, because not Universal Bishops, so ill do such Forgeries cohere: But if only one of them was a true Pope, then all that followed the other, rejected the Pope. Either these were saved or damned. If saved, then men that reject the Pope may be saved: And then why ask you us where was a Church that rejected the Pope before Luther? when you tell us where, at home. If damned, what a happiness befell one Kingdom, and what a misery the other, by the Title or No-Title of the Popes? Was it all France and that Party, or Germany and that Party that were damned all those times? Hell had a great Harvest by it, which soever it was: and it's pity that one Man should be able to damn so many Nations by pretending that he was the true Pope: And methinks such a division as this should be called a proper Schism; unless he will be so jocular as to say, that it was a proper division and rent, but no proper Schism.