2. You that boast so greatly of your Logic faculty should not so absurdly err, as you do in your major. Do you not hereby deny all proper accidents which agree as omni & soli, ita & semper? Is not Risibilis an accident of man and yet inseparable? 2. Is not quantity inseparable from a Body or natural substance? 3. What the Porphyrians speak of an Intellectual separation, you ignorantly or deceitfully 1apply to an actual eventual separation. If Christ had been otherwise put to death than by crucifying, or else-where than at Jerusalem; if his Bones had been broken, if he had not had the same integral parts and accidents of Body as he ever had, he had been Christ still: But yet it was Logically impossible that any of these should have been otherwise than they were, they being fore-decreed of God. If the Sun should cease moving, illuminating, heating, you may say it would be still the Sun: But yet it is certain, that these accidents are eventually inseparable from it. If you will cause Humidity to cease from Water, or separate Gravity from Earth of Stone, &c. I shall think you have made them other things. 4. But to instance as you do in such a being as [the CHURCH,] dishonoureth your boasted Logic greatly: The ratio formalis of a Church is Relative; and Relation is an accident; and to say, that accidents may all be separated from the Church without destroying it, is to say, that Relation may be separated; that is, the Church from it self, or formal Essence without destroying it. Do you conquer by such disputing as this? was it by such that you had your boasted printed victory over such great Logicians as Bishop Gunning and Bishop Pierson? Can you also prove that all accidents, that is, Relation, may be separable from Families, Schools, Kingdoms, without destroying them? I hope you will not say that you mean that the separation destroyeth not the humanity of the Members, and that this is the subject you mean: for no more would Apostasy or Unchurching them destroy Humanity.
2. You that boast so greatly of your Logick faculty should not so absurdly erre, as you do in your major. Do you not hereby deny all proper accidents which agree as omni & soli, ita & semper? Is not Risibilis an accident of man and yet inseparable? 2. Is not quantity inseparable from a Body or natural substance? 3. What the Porphyrians speak of an Intellectual separation, you ignorantly or deceitfully 1apply to an actual eventual separation. If Christ had been otherwise put to death than by crucifying, or else-where than at Ierusalem; if his Bones had been broken, if he had not had the same integral parts and accidents of Body as he ever had, he had been Christ still: But yet it was Logically impossible that any of these should have been otherwise than they were, they being fore-decreed of God. If the Sun should cease moving, illuminating, heating, you may say it would be still the Sun: But yet it is certain, that these accidents are eventually inseparable from it. If you will cause Humidity to cease from Water, or separate Gravity from Earth of Stone, &c. I shall think you have made them other things. 4. But to instance as you do in such a being as [the CHURCH,] dishonoureth your boasted Logick greatly: The ratio formalis of a Church is Relative; and Relation is an accident; and to say, that accidents may all be separated from the Church without destroying it, is to say, that Relation may be separated; that is, the Church from it self, or formal Essence without destroying it. Do you conquer by such disputing as this? was it by such that you had your boasted printed victory over such great Logicians as Bishop Gunning and Bishop Pierson? Can you also prove that all accidents, that is, Relation, may be separable from Families, Schools, Kingdoms, without destroying them? I hope you will not say that you mean that the separation destroyeth not the humanity of the Members, and that this is the subject you mean: for no more would Apostasie or Unchurching them destroy Humanity.
- 1Smiglecii Log. p. 1. disp. 5• qu. 9. pag. 201. Resp. Illam definitionem Accidentis (potest abesse, &c.) non intelligi de separatione reali accidentis (etiam quinti praedicabilis) a subjecto, sed de separatione per intellectum. Quare potest esse accidens realiter inseparabile a subjecto, & necessario convenire subjecto, & tamen per intellectum erit separabile, & poterit abbess a subjecto salva subjecti essentia, &c. vid. caetera.Smiglecii Log. p. 1. disp. 5• qu. 9. pag. 201. Resp. Illam definitionem Accidentis (potest abesse, &c.) non intelligi de separatione reali accidentis (etiam quinti praedicabilis) a subjecto, sed de separatione per intellectum. Quare potest esse accidens realiter inseparabile a subjecto, & necessario convenire subjecto, & tamen per intellectum erit separabile, & poterit abesse a subjecto salva subjecti essentia, &c. vid. caetera.