A27069:635
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. Why then doth he accuse us for separating from Rome, if it be as certainly unchurched, as it is certain that they have had Sin and Error; it is certain that the Popes were such as aforesaid, or the Councils sinned that condemned them as such: and it is certain that either the Councils of Constance, Basil, and Pisa, erred and sinned, which decreed that Councils are above the Pope, and may condemn and depose him; and that this is de fide, and the contrary Heresy; or else the Councils of Lateran and Florence erred and sinned that said the contrary. And so of other Instances.
2. Why then doth he accuse us for separating from Rome, if it be as certainly unchurched, as it is certain that they have had Sin and Errour; it is certain that the Popes were such as aforesaid, or the Councils sinned that condemned them as such: and it is certain that either the Councils of Constance, Basil, and Pisa, erred and sinned, which decreed that Councils are above the Pope, and may condemn and depose him; and that this is de fide, and the contrary Heresie; or else the Councils of Laterane and Florence erred and sinned that said the contrary. And so of other Instances.
3. But as I have proved the Antecedent of his Argument false already, so his consequence (that the Churches holding any thing to be instituted for perpetuity, is essential, and the denying, destructive of the essence) would not follow but on two suppositions. 1. That such institutions are not only no Accidents, but no Integrals. 2. That every commanded truth is essential, which are both false: For else the institution might be essential, and yet not the believing it such be essential: And he confesseth that such belief is not essential to every Member; nor can he tell to how many, nor to whom ad esse Ecclesiae; If he say, To as many as have a sufficient proposal. 1. Then if none had a sufficient proposal, it would cease to be essential to the Church. 2. Then if any one sin be committed by the Church against a sufficient proposal, the Church is nullified. If he said, It is not known how many must believe it ad esse Ecclesiae, then no man can know whether the Church be nullified or not.