A27069:681
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
So W. I's demand upon his Plea of present possession, is as if he should say, The man of seventy years of Age which is now grey-headed and lame was ever so: Or the Church which now honoureth St. Martin, St. Thomas Aquinas, as Saints, is the true Church of Christ: And if you cannot show, us that your Church hath in all Ages so honoured St. Martin, &c. you are not the true Church of Christ. What if it had been [The Church that keepeth Easter-day as now we do, and Christmas-day on the 25th of December is the true Church of Christ; therefore you must prove that your Church hath ever done so. Could they prove their Papacy in the Empire as old, it would have the same answer, viz. It was but a part of the Church, and not the whole, that kept Easter and Christmas as we do now; for one part kept Easter on another day, till the Nicene Council ended that Controversy in the East, and Christmas-day on the 6th of January till after the middle of Chrysostom's time; and so in the present case, had it been as ancient as they pretend, it was not Universal.
So W. I's demand upon his Plea of present possession, is as if he should say, The man of seventy years of Age which is now gray-headed and lame was ever so: Or the Church which now honoureth St. Martin, St. Thomas Aquinas, as Saints, is the true Church of Christ: And if you cannot shew, us that your Church hath in all Ages so honoured St. Martin, &c. you are not the true Church of Christ. What if it had been [The Church that keepeth Easter-day as now we do, and Christmas-day on the 25th of December is the true Church of Christ; therefore you must prove that your Church hath ever done so. Could they prove their Papacy in the Empire as old, it would have the same answer, viz. It was but a part of the Church, and not the whole, that kept Easter and Christmas as we do now; for one part kept Easter on another day, till the Nicene Council ended that Controversie in the East, and Christmas-day on the 6th of Ianuary till after the middle of Chrysostom's time; and so in the present case, had it been as ancient as they pretend, it was not Universal.
2. But he saith that [at least, as Patriarch of the West by the Churches grant, they were in full quiet possession of that Right or Power which we confess was lawful.]