A27069:735
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And let it be still remembered to acquit the Eastern and Southern Churches from the Papists charge of Heresy, (as being Nestorians and Eutychians,) 1. That the Accusers are to be taken for Calumniators, till they prove it, by all the rules of common Justice.
And let it be still remembred to acquit the Eastern and Southern Churches from the Papists charge of Heresie, (as being Nestorians and Eutychians,) 1. That the Accusers are to be taken for Calumniators, till they prove it, by all the rules of common Justice.
2. That if they could prove Dioscorus e. g. an Eutychian, that's no proof that all the Bishops that adhered to him were such: for it's apparent by the Acts of the Councils that Multitudes adhered to him because they thought him no Eutychian: [and Derodon de supposit• hath undeniably proved, that Dioscorus said but what his Predecessor Cyril hath oft said, whom you approved.] and many because they thought the Judgment unjust that judged him so, and cast him out, and many for the honour of the Seat, yea many for fear of death by the people that were affected to him as their Patriarch, though they understood not the cause in question. He that readeth the Bishops at the Council of Calcedon, part crying out prostrate on the Earth, miseremini, miseremini, non dissentimus; else, kill us here, we dare not go home, if we desert and rail against our Patriarch before another be chosen, the people will kill us; and another part of them confessing that fear made them subscribe at the Council at Ephes. 2. and some crying out, Away with them they are Heretics, who cryed non dissentimus; may well judge that all were not Heretics that clamour called so. 3. If they could prove those few Bishops that were openly accused and noted to be Eutychians, that's no proof that the rest were so. 4. If they could prove that many then were so, that will not prove that those that now there inhabit are so. 5. And of Nestorianism there is less public show of proof. 6. And indeed the main Body of the Common People, yea and Clergy, it's most probable never understood the Controversies. 7. Yea he that with judgment readeth the Acts, History, and Debates of those times, may well doubt whether Nestorius, Eutyches, or Dioscorus understood them themselves: and whether the Heresy lay not mostly in an unskilfulness of interpreting of words and expressions. Dioscorus solemnly professed that he held neither division of Natures, nor confusion of them, nor transmutation, and that antecedent to their Union they were two: These are unskilful expressions: But one would think that he that held that Union did neither change nor confound them, must needs mean that they were distinct though not divided: and the Orthodox denied division as well as he.