Aus. It's no wonder that you desire to be the expositors of the Scriptures (and all other Books;) for that is the only device to make them speak what you would have them. If Gregory the Seventh be the Expositor of St. Paul, no doubt but St. Paul shall be for the power of Popes to depose Kings and Emperors: If Innocent the Third be his Expositor, no doubt but by [Bread] 1 Cor. 11. he meaneth [no Bread] and by [this Cup] [no Wine.] And I confess there is greater reason that you should be the infallible Expositors of Reynerius than of Christ or Paul; for he was more your own and under your Government. But this Reynerius was an unhappy speaker, and if he were here I would ask him, 1. Why do you speak in such a manner as any ordinary Reader would think that you speak de jure & de facto, and yet mean de facto only? 2. Why speak you so as an ordinary Reader would think that you spake d• statu statuto, when you mean but de praeente & statu inordinato? 3. Why speak you of so great a sin as Rebellion against the Vice-Christ, and Schism from the Universal Church, without any note of reprehension? 4. Why name you the old extra imperial Churches only, and not those that since renounced Rome, (as all the Greek Church,) if you meant but what you charge the Greek Church with? Had you not more easily fastened a charge of Rebellion on all those Eastern Churches that sometimes acknowledged some primacy of Rome, than on those that the World knoweth were never under him? 5. And why do you say also in general, [and the rest which the Apostles converted are not under the Church of Rome,] if there were not some special reason for it? We took your meaning to be [Though those in the Empire, and many without it that were turned from Infidelity by the Popes Subjects, be under the Church of Rome, the first by the Laws of the Empire and Councils, and the latter by voluntary subjection; yet so are not the Churches which the rest of the Apostles planted without the Empire, a• those Apostles were not subject to St. Peter.] 6. And why do you so arrogantly accuse such vast Churches as Armenia, Ethiopia, India, and all the rest of the Apostles planted, (besides Peter and Paul) and take them all for Rebels and Schismatics, and yet bring no word of proof for your Accusations?
Aus. It's no wonder that you desire to be the expositors of the Scriptures (and all other Books;) for that is the only device to make them speak what you would have them. If Gregory the Seventh be the Expositor of St. Paul, no doubt but St. Paul shall be for the power of Popes to depose Kings and Emperours: If Innocent the Third be his Expositor, no doubt but by [Bread] 1 Cor. 11. he meaneth [no Bread] and by [this Cup] [no Wine.] And I confess there is greater reason that you should be the infallible Expositors of Reynerius than of Christ or Paul; for he was more your own and under your Government. But this Reynerius was an unhappy speaker, and if he were here I would ask him, 1. Why do you speak in such a manner as any ordinary Reader would think that you speak de jure & de facto, and yet mean de facto only? 2. Why speak you so as an ordinary Reader would think that you spake d• statu statuto, when you mean but de praeente & statu inordinato? 3. Why speak you of so great a sin as Rebellion against the Vice-Christ, and Schism from the Universal Church, without any note of reprehension? 4. Why name you the old extra imperial Churches only, and not those that since renounced Rome, (as all the Greek Church,) if you meant but what you charge the Greek Church with? Had you not more easily fastened a charge of Rebellion on all those Eustern Churches that sometimes acknowledged some primacy of Rome, than on those that the World knoweth were never under him? 5. And why do you say also in general, [and the rest which the Apostles converted are not under the Church of Rome,] if there were not some special reason for it? We took your meaning to be [Though those in the Empire, and many without it that were turned from Infidelity by the Popes Subjects, be under the Church of Rome, the first by the Laws of the Empire and Councils, and the latter by voluntary subjection; yet so are not the Churches which the rest of the Apostles planted without the Empire, a• those Apostles were not subject to St. Peter.] 6. And why do you so arrogantly accuse such vast Churches as Arm•nia, Ethiopia, India, and all the rest of the Apostles planted, (besides Peter and Paul) and take them all for Rebels and Schismaticks, and yet bring no word of proof for your Accusations?