A27069:938
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
An Answer to W. J's Seventh CHAPTER.
§. 1. TO his Question, Why we separated from them? I Answered, that as they are Christians we separate not from them: As Papists we were never of them, but our Fore-fathers thought Repentance of Sin to be no Sin. If by Popery they separate from Christianity, they are damnable Separatists; if they do not, we are of the same Church, whether they will or not.
[…] To this he saith, That We separate from them as much as the Pelagians, Donatists, Acacians, Luciferians, Nestorians, and Eutychians did from the Church.
〈…〉 To this he saith, That We separate from them as much as the Pelagians, Donatists, Acacians, Luciferians, Nestorians, and Eutychians did from the Church.
Answ. 1. The Doctrinal Errors and the Separation are of different consideration. The Pelagians Erred as some Dominicans say the Jesuits do. The Donatists, like the Papists, appropriated the Church to their own Bishops and Party; we do none of this. Lucifer Calaritanus was too Zealous against the Arians, not communicating with them upon so short Repentance as others did: But they went not so far, as Crab saith the Roman Council in Sylvester's day did, that Received no Repentance before forty Years: Nor so far as the honest Elebertine Council in the number of Years of Mens exclusion from the Communion. I take Lucifer for Erroneous and Schismatical, but not comparable to the Papists, who err far more, and yet separate from most of the Christian World. These Schismatics named by you Sinned by unjust separation from the Imperial Churches near them, but they did not separate from all the World save themselves, as the Papists do. And if you believe History, you will find that some of them did not separate themselves, till they were Anathematized and cast out by others. Nestorius retired and Lived four Years in great repute in his Old Monastery near Antioch. The Novatians were too scrupulous of joining with Wicked Priests and People: And your Writers say, that Pope Nicholas forbade hearing Mass from a Fornicator Priest. I had rather be in this of the Pope and the Novatians mind than of those Catholic Priests.