A27069:942
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. But I think this is a considerable Difference: The Erroneous Schismatics of those times, much more the proper Heretics, did sinfully withdraw from the Communion of most of the Universal Church, to profess some Error of their own in singular Conventicles. But we, who take mere Christianity for our Religion, do own Communion with the far greatest part of the Church on Earth; yea, with all as Christian, and separate not for Error, but only from Error and Sin: We separate from Pelagians as Pelagians, from Novatians as Novatians, and from Papists as Papists, but not as Christians.
2. But I think this is a considerable Difference: The Erroneous Schismaticks of those times, much more the proper Hereticks, did sinfully withdraw from the Communion of most of the Universal Church, to profess some Error of their own in singular Conventicles. But we, who take meer Christianity for our Religion, do own Communion with the far greatest part of the Church on Earth; yea, with all as Christian, and sepa•ate not for Error, but only from Error and Sin: We separate from Pelagians as Pelagians, from Novatians as Novatians, and from Papists as Papists, but not as Christians.
You say, No more did they then. I Answer, 1. They separated from Truth, and we from Error, as the Council that condemned him did from Pope Honorius. 2. The Luciferians and Novatians separated Voluntarily; we are cast out by you from Christian Communion, and are counted Separatists unless we will Sin with you, or be burnt as Heretics, 3. Let the Reader still note the cheating ambiguity of your word [Separation.] The Schismatics named, separated from Brotherly Communion, but we separate from Tyrannical Usurped Domination; and are called Schismatics (not because we will not have such Communion with you in all Christian Truth and Duty, but) because we will not be your Vassals or Subjects, and Sin as oft as you command us.
You say, No more did they then. I Answer, 1. They separated from Truth, and we from Error, as the Council that condemned him did from Pope Honorius. 2. The Luciferians and Novatians separated Voluntarily; we are cast out by you from Christian Communion, and are counted Separatists unless we will Sin with you, or be burnt as Hereticks, 3. Let the Reader still note the cheating ambiguity of your word [Separation.] The Schismaticks named, separated from Brotherly Communion, but we separate from Tyrannical Usurped Domination; and are called Schismaticks (not because we will not have such Communion with you in all Christian Truth and Duty, but) because we will not be your Vassals or Subjects, and Sin as oft as you command us.