A27069:952
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To this he saith, That 1. He speaks of Parts of the Church, as I understand parts: Answ. Who would have thought till now but he had spoken as he thought himself.
2. He saith, That I hold that some Heretics, properly so called, are parts of the Church of Christ, and united to Christ their Head, believing the Essentials of Christianity, and so are Christians, though Erring in some Accidents; and this is contrary to all Christianity, and a Novelty never held before by any Christian.
2. He saith, That I hold that some Hereticks, properly so called, are parts of the Church of Christ, and united to Christ their Head, believing the Essentials of Christianity, and so are Christians, though Erring in some Accidents; and this is contrary to all Christianity, and a Nov•lty never held before by any Christian.
Answ. But such gross Falsehoods as yours, and such deceits have been used before by many Papists. 1. Where did I say that such as err only in some Accidents, are properly called Heretics? I distinguished De re & ratione nominis, but undertook not to tell from the Etymology of the word, which is the only proper sense of Heresy; but according to the vulgar use of the word among us, it is taken for one that denieth some Essential: But with such as you I see it is taken more largely; and I am not sure that at first it was not taken for any Separation or Schism into distinct Sects. All that I say (you may be ashamed to call me▪ so oft to repeat it) is, That 1. Many are called Heretics by Papists, yea• by Philastrius and Epiphanius, that were true Christians, for ought is said against them (yea, Philastrius numbereth some certain Truths with Heresies, when his contrary Errors are liker such.) 2. That they that err in some Accidents may be true Christians, or else I think there is none at Age in the World. 3. That there is much lamentable Schism, which is no Separation from the whole Church. 4. That he shall be saved that holdeth all the Essentials of Christianity truly and practically. 5. I have proved that your Definitions absolve more from […] and Schism than I do.