A27069:971
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ…
Which is the true church? the whole Christian world, as headed only by Christ ... or, the Pope of Rome and his subjects as such? : in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London : Printed, and are to be sold by Richard Janeway ..., 1679
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. This is because I said, that some make divisions in the Church, that divide not from it, much less from the whole. I proved before that in this sense Paul usually speaketh against Schism or Divisions, As when he tells the Corinthians of the divisions among them, &c. But this man would make Scripture and common sense and reason to be grand novelties; may there not be divisions in a House, in a Kingdom, in an Army, in a particular Congregation, as that at Corinth; and that after which Clement wrote his Epistle to heal? Have there not been abundance of such at Alexandria, Antioch, Constantinople? was there no Division in the Church of Rome, when part cleaved to one Pope, and part to another for above forty years? Did the Councils of Constance and Basil meet to heal their Schisms, upon mistake when there was no such thing? And do all their Historians erroneously number their Schisms? Reader pardon my oft answering such bold abuses; These are their arguers that hope to subvert England.
Answ. This is because I said, that some make divisions in the Church, that divide not from it, much less from the whole. I proved before that in this sense Paul usually speaketh against Schisme or Divisions, As when he tells the Corinthians of the divisions among them, &c. But this man would make Scripture and common sense and reason to be grand novelties; may there not be divisions in a House, in a Kingdom, in an Army, in a particular Congregation, as that at Corinth; and that after which Clement wrote his Epistle to heal? Have there not been abundance of such at Alexandria, Antioch, Constantinople? was there no Division in the Church of Rome, when part cleaved to one Pope, and part to another for above forty years? Did the Councils of Constance and Basil meet to heal their Schismes, upon mistake when there was no such thing? And do all their Historians erroneously number their Schisms? Reader pardon my oft answering such bold abuses; These are their arguers that hope to subvert England.
§. 11. And his reason is such as would show him a Catharist, viz. The Church is a most perfect Unity; If so, than all grace is perfect which is necessary to perfect unity. Then the Popes and Anti-Popes, the warring Papalines and Imperialists, the Jesuits, Dominicans, and Jansenists are all at perfect Unity; Then there is no disagreement, of Judgement Will or Practice among any Papists in the world; no Volumes written against other; Alas, how far are such words from proving it, or from ending their present Controversies or Wars. Watson and Preston had scarce perfect unity with Father Parsons and the Jesuits. Doth perfect unity draw all the blood between France and the house of Austria, or in France, between King Hen. d. and the Leaguers. It is enough for me to believe that all true Christians have a true unity in Christ, with each as his members, but that this Unity among themselves is sadly imperfect, and so was when they had all the contentions in many General Councils, and when the people have oft fought it out to blood about Religion, and the choice of Bishops, at Alexandria, Rome, &c. Is this perfection? It is in heaven that we hope for perfect unity, where all is perfect.