the death that was not due 1to him he underwent, that we might not undergo that death which was due to us: saith Gregory, he made himself 2a debtor for us, who were debtors; and therefore the Creditor exacts it from him, saith Arnoldus. Now, God's justice being satisfied for our offences, it cannot but remit ⟨p. 324⟩those offences to us: As the Creditor cannot demand that of the debtor, which the surety hath already paid; so neither can God exact the punishment of us, which Christ hath suffered; and therefore, it is just with God, to forgive us our sins. It will be altogether needless to enquire, whether it had been injustice in God, to forgive without satisfaction: St. Austin's determination is very solid, there 3wanted not to God another possible way (and if it were unjust, it were impossible) but this of satisfaction was most agreeable to divine wisdom; before God did decree this way, it might be free to have used it or not; but in decreeing, this seemed most convenient, and after it became 4necessary, so that there can be no remission without it; and however, it might not have been unjust with God, to have forgiven without it: yet we are sure it is most just with him to forgive upon satisfaction. Indeed the debt being paid by Christ, God's very justice (as I may say with reverence) would trouble him, if he should not give in the bond, and give out an acquittance. The believing penitent sinner may, in an humble confidence, sue out his pardon, not only at the throne of grace, but at the bar of justice, in these or the like expressions; Lord, thou hast punished my sins in thy son, wilt thou punish them in me? thou hast accepted that suffering of thy son, as the punishment of my sin, therefore thou canst not, in justice, exact it of me, for this were to punish twice for one offence, which thy justice cannot but abhor. Oh sirs, God doth not pronounce men righteous when they are not; but first he makes them so, and then he pronounces them to be such: so that if a man will be justified, he must be able to produce such a complete righteousness, wherewith he may stand before the justice of God: ah sinners! the Lord is infinitely just, as well as merciful; and if ever your sins be pardoned, it must be by an admirable contemperament, or mixture of mercy and justice together:
the death that was not due 1to him he underwent, that we might not undergo that death which was due to us: saith Gregory, he made himself 2a debter for us, who were debtors; and therefore the Creditor exacts it from him, saith Arnoldus. Now, God's justice being satisfied for our offences, it cannot but remit ⟨p. 324⟩those offences to us: As the Creditor cannot demand that of the debtor, which the surety hath already paid; so neither can God exact the punishment of us, which Christ hath suffered; and therefore, it is just with God, to forgive us our sins. It will be altogether needless to enquire, whether it had been injustice in God, to forgive without satisfaction: St. Austin's determination is very solid, there 3wanted not to God another possible way (and if it were unjust, it were impossible) but this of satisfaction was most agreeable to divine wisdom; before God did decree this way, it might be free to have used it or not; but in decreeing, this seemed most convenient, and after it became 4necessary, so that there can be no remission without it; and however, it might not have been unjust with God, to have forgiven without it: yet we are sure it is most just with him to forgive upon satisfaction. Indeed the debt being paid by Christ, God's very justice (as I may say with reverence) would trouble him, if he should not give in the bond, and give out an acquittance. The believing penitent sinner may, in an humble confidence, sue out his pardon, not only at the throne of grace, but at the bar of justice, in these or the like expressions; Lord, thou hast punished my sins in thy son, wilt thou punish them in me? thou hast accepted that suffering of thy son, as the punishment of my sin, therefore thou canst not, in justice, exact it of me, for this were to punish twice for one offence, which thy justice cannot but abhor. Oh sirs, God doth not pronounce men righteous when they are not; but first he makes them so, and then he pronounces them to be such: so that if a man will be justified, he must be able to produce such a compleat righteousness, wherewith he may stand before the justice of God: ah sinners! the Lord is infinitely just, as well as merciful; and if ever your sins be pardoned, it must be by an admirable contemperament, or mixture of mercy and justice together:
- 1Gr. mer. l. 3. c. 13.
- 2Arnol. de sep. verb Tr. 1.
- 3Aug. de Trinit. l. 13. c. 10.
- 4When you are forgiven, you are then released, and for ever acquitted from any after reckonings with the justice of God; divine Justice hath no more to say or do against you, for remissa culpa, remi•ttur paena; if the fault be forgiven, then also is the punishment forgiven; nay, let me speak with an holy and humble reverence, God cannot in his justice punish, when he hath pardoned.