A30138:122
Differences in judgment about water-baptism, no bar to communion, or, To communicate with saints,…Differences in judgment about vvater-baptism, no bar to communion, or, To communicate with saints,…
Differences in judgment about water-baptism, no bar to communion, or, To communicate with saints, as saints, proved lawful in answer to a book written by the Baptists, and published by Mr. T.P. and Mr. W.K. entitled, Some serious reflections on that part of Mr. Bunyan's confession of faith, touching church-communion with unbaptized believers : wherein, their objections and arguments are answered, and the doctrine of communion still asserted and vindicated : here is also Mr. Henry's Jesse's judgment in the case, fully declaring the doctrine I have asserted / by John Bunyan.Differences in judgment about vvater-baptism, no bar to communion, or, To communicate with saints, as saints, proved lawful in answer to a book written by the Baptists, and published by Mr. T.P. and Mr. W.K. entituled, Some serious reflections on that part of Mr. Bunyan's confession of faith, touching church-communion with unbaptized believers : wherein, their objections and arguments are answered, and the doctrine of communion still asserted and vindicated : here is also Mr. Henry's Jesse's judgment in the case, fully declaring the doctrine I have asserted / by John Bunyan.
London: printed for John Wilkins, 1673
Differences in Judgment about Water-Baptism no Bar to Communion.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. First, That the Brethren which refuse to be baptized, as you and I would have them, refuse it for want of pretended Light, becomes you not to imagine, unless your boldness will lead you to judge, that all men want sincerity, that come not up to our judgment. Their Conscience may be better than either yours or mine; yet God, for purposes best known to himself, may forbear to give them conviction of their Duty in this particular. But what? Because they are not baptized; have they not Jesus Christ? Or, must we now be afraid to say Christ is better than Water-baptism? Yea, God himself for the sake of this better thing, hath suffered in his Church a suspension of some of his Ordinances, yet owned them for his truly Constituted Congregation. What say you to the Church in the Wilderness? I touched you with it in my first, but perceive you listed not to meddle therewith. That Church received Members, the way which was not prescribed by, but directly against the revealed Mind of God; yet stood a true Church, their Members true Members; also that Church in that state, was such before whom, among whom, and to whom God continually made known himself ⟨p. 36⟩to be their God, and owned them for his peculiar treasure.
And now I am fallen upon it, let me a little enlarge: This Church, according to the then Instituted Worship of God, had Circumcision for their entering-Ordinance, Gen. 17. 13, 14. without which it was unlawful to receive any into Fellowship with them: yea, he that without it was received, was to be cut off, and cast out again. Further; As to the Passover, the Uncircumcised was utterly forbidden to eat it, Exod. 12. Now if our Brethren had as express prohibition to justify their groundless Opinion, as here is to exclude the Uncircumcised from the Communion of the Church and the Passover; (I say) if they could find it written, No Unbaptized Person shall enter, no Unbaptized Person shall eat of the Supper; what a noise would they make about it? But yet let the Reader observe, that although Circumcision was the entering-Ordinance, and our Author saith Baptism is not; yea, though this Church was expressly forbidden to receive the Uncircumcised (and we have not a syllable now to forbid the Unbaptized) yet this Church received Members without, and otherwise than by this entering-Ordinance. They also admitted them to the Passover; yea, entertained, retained, and held Communion with them so long as forty years without it. I say, again, That the number of this sort of Communicants was not so few as six hundred thousand. Moreover, to these Uncircumcised was the Land of Canaan given,