And first, It must be acknowledged, that in this point it is hard to sail between 1the Scylla and Charybdis of the Arminian error on one hand, and Antinomian on the other side. For the Arminians they indeed make Christ to be the atonement for our sins, but so that we must believe and repent, all which is true. But then if it be asked, how come we to believe, and to repent? here they fly, in part at least; to our own free will, for they deny that faith is purchased by Christs death; so that by their doctrine the whole fruit of Christs death standeth suspense and indeterminate, till it be determined by our faith. Christs death is made effectual to us by our believing; and this believing is not wrought in us by Christs Spirit, nor is it bestowed on us as the fruit of his death, but only we joining with the grace of God do make the redimibility which was before faith, by faith to be actual redemption. And the Papist he erreth more grossly herein, for he addeth further, that our faith and repentance, yea, all holy works are causal conditions, such as are meritorious, and have an inward condignity and proportion to the reward. Thus generally the Papists, though some of them deny this merit and causality; But the Antinomian falleth into another extremity, for he doth so offer Christ and his promises to a man, as if nothing at all were required on mans part, and therefore tells a sinner that it is his duty while a sinner, and abiding in that state, to receive the promise; yea, one goeth so far *as to say, that Christ did believe for us, Christ did repent for us, and therefore that we are not bound to believe or repent, but only to rest on Christ that he hath done these things for us. Thus you see, here are two extreme opinions, and it is very hard for the soul in its first troubles and pangs to be guided out of this wilderness: how many have been seduced by Antinomian errors, under the specious pretence of free grace? and how many again have fallen into Arminian and Popish principles, thinking that way to assuage their bleeding hearts? but the Scripture truth doth lie between these two; for Christ, and so the promises, are not applicable to sinners as sinners, whether they believe or not believe, whether they repent or not repent, but do require indispensably of all grown persons faith and repentance;
And first, It must be acknowledged, that in this point it is hard to sail between 1the Scylla and Charybdis of the Arminian errour on one hand, and Antinomian on the other side. For the Arminians they indeed make Christ to be the atonement for our sins, but so that we must beleeve and repent, all which is true. But then if it be asked, how come we to beleeve, and to repent? here they fly, in part at least; to our own free will, for they deny that faith is purchased by Christs death; so that by their doctrine the whole fruit of Christs death standeth suspense and indeterminate, till it be determined by our faith. Christs death is made effectuall to us by our beleeving; and this beleeving is not wrought in us by Christs Spirit, nor is it bestowed on us as the fruit of his death, but only we joyning with the grace of God do make the redimibility which was before faith, by faith to be actual redemption. And the Papist he erreth more grosly herein, for he addeth further, that our faith and repentance, yea, all holy works are causal conditions, such as are meritorious, and have an inward condignity and proportion to the reward. Thus generally the Papists, though some of them deny this merit and causality; But the Antinomian falleth into another extremity, for he doth so offer Christ and his promises to a man, as if nothing at all were required on mans part, and therefore tels a sinner that it is his duty while a sinner, and abiding in that state, to receive the promise; yea, one goeth so far *as to say, that Christ did beleeve for us, Christ did repent for us, and therefore that we are not bound to beleeve or repent, but only to rest on Christ that he hath done these things for us. Thus you see, here are two extreme opinions, and it is very hard for the soul in its first troubles and pangs to be guided out of this wildernesse: how many have been seduced by Antinomian errours, under the specious pretence of free grace? and how many again have fallen into Armintan and Popish principles, thinking that way to asswage their bleeding hearts? but the Scripture truth doth lie between these two; for Christ, and so the promises, are not applicable to sinners as sinners, whether they beleeve or not beleeve, whether they repent or not repent, but do require indispensably of all grown persons faith and repentance;
- 1Ans. 1. It is hard to sail between the Arminian and Antinomian rock.
- *Saltmarsh.