1. No Creature can be capable of immutability by Nature. Mutability is so essential to a Creature, that a Creature cannot be supposed without it: You must suppose it a Creator, not a Creature, if you allow it to be of an Immutable Nature. Immutability is the property of the Supreme Being. God only hath immortality, 1 Tim. 6.16. Immortality, as opposed not only to a natural, but to a sinful death; the word only appropriates every sort of Immortality to God, and excludes every Creature, whether Angel or Man, from a Partnership with God in this by Nature. Every Creature therefore is capable of a Death in sin. None is good but God, and none is naturally free from change but God; which excludes every Creature from the same Prerogative; and certainly if one Angel sinned, all might have sinned, because there was the same root of Mutability in one as well ⟨p. 518⟩as another. 'Tis as possible for a Creature to be Creator, as for a Creature to have naturally an incommunicable property of the Creator. All things, whether Angels or Men, are made of nothing, and therefore capable of defection*; because a Creature being made of nothing, cannot be good per essentiam, or essentially good, but by participation from another. Again, every Rational Creature, being made of nothing, hath a Superior which created him and governs him, and is capable of a Precept; and consequently capable of Disobedience as well as Obedience to the Precept, to transgress it as well as obey it. God cannot sin, because he can have no Superior to impose a Precept on him. A Rational Creature, with a liberty of Will and power of Choice, cannot be made by Nature of such a mould and temper, but he must be as well capable of choosing wrong, as of choosing right; and therefore the standing Angels, and glorified Saints, though they are Immutable, 'tis not by Nature that they are so, but by Grace, and the good pleasure of God; for though they are in Heaven, they have still in their Nature a remote power of sinning, but it shall never be brought into act, because God will always incline their Wills to love him, and never concur with their Wills to any evil act. Since therefore Mutability is essential to a Creature, as a Creature, this changeableness cannot properly be charged upon God as the Author of it;
1. No Creature can be capable of immutability by Nature. Mutability is so essential to a Creature, that a Creature cannot be supposed without it: You must suppose it a Creator, not a Creature, if you allow it to be of an Immutable Nature. Immutability is the property of the Supream Being. God only hath immortality, 1 Tim. 6.16. Immortality, as opposed not only to a natural, but to a sinful death; the word only appropriates every sort of Immortality to God, and excludes every Creature, whether Angel or Man, from a Partnership with God in this by Nature. Every Creature therefore is capable of a Death in sin. None is good but God, and none is naturally free from change but God; which excludes every Creature from the same Prerogative; and certainly if one Angel sinned, all might have sinned, because there was the same root of Mutability in one as well ⟨p. 518⟩as another. 'Tis as possible for a Creature to be Creator, as for a Creature to have naturally an incommunicable property of the Creator. All things, whether Angels or Men, are made of nothing, and therefore capable of defection*; because a Creature be•ng made of nothing, cannot be good per essentiam, or essentially good, but by participation from another. Aga•n, every Rational Creature, being made of nothing, hath a Superior which created him and governs him, and is capable of a Precept; and consequently capable of Disobedience as well as Obedience to the Precept, to transgress it as well as obey it. God cannot sin, because he can have no Superior to impose a Precept on him. A Rational Creature, with a liberty of Will and power of Choice, cannot be made by Nature of such a mould and temper, but he must be as well capable of chusing wrong, as of chusing right; and therefore the standing Angels, and glorified Saints, though they are Immutable, 'tis not by Nature that they are so, but by Grace, and the good pleasure of God; for though they are in Heaven, they have still in their Nature a remote power of sinning, but it shall never be brought into act, because God will always incline their Wills to love him, and never concur with their Wills to any evil act. Since therefore Mutability is essential to a Creature, as a Creature, this changeableness cannot properly be charged upon God as the Author of it;
- *Suarez. V•l. 2. p. 5.8.