A32723:2483
Discourses upon the Existence and Attributes of God
Several discourses upon the existence and attributes of God by that late eminent minister in Christ, Mr. Stephen Charnocke ...
London: printed for D. Newman, 1682
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
'tis the use of an excellent Power God hath given, and which God preserves in the use of it. But the estimation of the Moral Goodness or Evil is not from the act it self, but from the disposition of the Mind. Once more, Killing as an act is good, nor is it unlawful as an Act: For if so, God would never have commanded his People Israel to wage any War, and Justice could not be done upon Malefactors by the Magistrate. A Man were bound to sacrifice his life to the fury of an Invader, rather than secure it by dispatching that of an Enemy. But killing an Innocent, or killing without Authority, or out of revenge, is bad. 'Tis not the Material part of the act, but the Object, Manner, and Circumstance, that makes it good or evil. 'Tis no blemish to Gods Holiness to concur to the substance of an Action, without having any hand in the Immorality of it, because whatsoever is real in the substance of the Action might be done without Evil. 'Tis not Evil as it is an act, as it is a motion of the Tongue or Hand, for then every motion of the Tongue or Hand would be Evil.
2. Hence it follows, that an Act as an Act is one thing, and the Viciousness another. †The Action is the efficacy of the Faculty, extending it self to some outward Object; but the Sinfulness of an act consists in a privation of that Comeliness and Righteousness, which ought to be in an Action; in a want of conformity of the act with the Law of God, either written in Nature, or revealed in the Word. Now the Sinfulness of an Action is not the act it self, but is considered in it as it is related to the Law, and is a deviation from it; and so it is something cleaving to the Action, and therefore to be distinguished from the act it self, which is the Subject of the Sinfulness. When we say, such an Action is sinful, the Action is the Subject, and the Sinfulness of the Action is that which adheres to it. The Action is not the Sinfulness, nor the Sinfulness the Action; they are distinguished as the Member, and a disease in the Member, the Arm and the Palsy in it: The Arm is not the Palsy, nor is the Palsy the Arm; but the Palsy is a Disease that cleaves to the Arm: So Sinfulness is a deformity that cleaves to an Action.