A33359:213
Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times
Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times, or, A defence of the answer to Dr. Stillingfleets allegations out of antiquity for such churches against the exceptions offered in the preface to a late treatise called A vindication of the primitive church, where what is further produced out of Scripture and ancient authors for diocesan churches is also discussed.Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times, or, A defence of the answer to Dr. Stillingfleets allegations out of antiquity for such churches against the exceptions offered in the preface to a late treatise called A vindication of the primitive church, where what is further produced out of Scripture and antient authors for diocesan churches is also discussed.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1682
Diocesan Churches not yet discovered in the Primitive times.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I intended to conclude this discourse here, without giving the Reader further trouble; but considering there are misapprehensions about the Subject in question, ⟨p. 60⟩those being taken by diverse, for Diocesan Churches which indeed are not such, and arguments used to prove them so which are not competent for that purpose, (of which there are many instances, as elsewhere so particularly in the latter end of this Authors discourse): I thought it requisite for the rectifying of these mistakes, and to show the insufficiency or impertinency of such reasonings, to give an account what mediums cannot in reason be esteemed, to afford competent proof of Diocesan Churches.
I intended to conclude this discourse here, without giving the Reader further trouble; but considering there are misapprehensions about the Subject in question, ⟨p. 60⟩those being taken by diverse, for Diocesan Churches which indeed are not such, and arguments used to prove them so which are not competent for that purpose, (of which there are many instances, as elsewhere so particularly in the latter end of this Authors discourse): I thought it requisite for the rectifying of these mistakes, and to shew the insufficiency or impertinency of such reasonings, to give an account what mediums cannot in reason be esteemed, to afford competent proof of Diocesan Churches.
In general, Those who will satisfy us that any Churches, in the first Ages of Christianity, were Diocesan, should prove them to be such Diocesans as ours are, as large or near as large; otherwise what they offer, will scarce appear to be pertinent. For the rise of this debate is the question between us, whether the Bishops of these times be such as those in the primitive Church. This we deny, because modern Bishops will have another sort of Churches or Dioceses, than were known in the best Ages. Not that we reject all Dioceses or Diocesan Churches, for both [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] are used by the Ancients for such Churches as we allow. It is those of a later Model, that we approve not, as vastly differing from the ancient Episcopal Churches. The modern Dioceses, and Churches thence denominated are exceeding great and extensive, consisting of many scores, or many hundred particular Churches, whereas for the three first Ages we cannot find 3 Bishops that had two particular Churches in his Diocese, nor in the 4th. one in 50 (if I may not say one in a hundred) that had more. So that the difference is exceeding great, and more considerable in the consequence thereof, which I had rather give an account of in the words of the very learned D. St. than mine own. Dioceses generally, says he, in the primitive, and Eastern Churches were very small