A33359:276
Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times
Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times, or, A defence of the answer to Dr. Stillingfleets allegations out of antiquity for such churches against the exceptions offered in the preface to a late treatise called A vindication of the primitive church, where what is further produced out of Scripture and ancient authors for diocesan churches is also discussed.Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times, or, A defence of the answer to Dr. Stillingfleets allegations out of antiquity for such churches against the exceptions offered in the preface to a late treatise called A vindication of the primitive church, where what is further produced out of Scripture and antient authors for diocesan churches is also discussed.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1682
Diocesan Churches not yet discovered in the Primitive times.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Damasus, the supposed Author of the Pope's lives, says, Evaristus Titulos Presbyteris divisit, divided the Titles in Rome to the Presbyters, and by Titles some will have us to understand Parish Churches. But it is incredible that the Christians in Trajan's time when Evaristus was Bishop, could erect any structures in form of Churches, or had any distinguishable from other houses, so as the Heathen might take notice of them, as used or designed for the religious exercises of Christians. Who can imagine that when it was death for any one to be known to be a Christian, they should frequent any known places for Christian Worship? It is far more reasonable which Platina says of Calistus's time, more than an hundred years after, that then the meeting of Christians were all secret, and rather in Chapels, and those hidden, and for the most part underground; than in open and public places Cum eâ tempestate ob crebras persecutiones occulta essent omnia, & sacella potius, atque eadem abdita & plerumque subterranea; quam apertis in locis ac publicis fierent. Dr. St. says, I confess it seems not probable to me that those Tituli were so soon divided as the 1time of Evaristus, who lived in the time of Trajan, when the Persecution was hot against the Christians; but Damasus ⟨p. 89⟩seems not to believe himself, for in the life of Dionysius he saith, Hic Presbyteris Ecclesias divisit. His reason concludes as much or more against the Titles under this notion ascribed to Marcellus 200 years after (which some will have to be 25, but Onuphrius shows they could not be more than 15n) for Marcellus was Bishop of Rome for six years of the tenth Persecution begun by Diocletian, which was the longest and fiercest that ever befell the Church; when the Christians were so far from erecting any Churches, that all before erected were by severe Edicts to be quite demolished. But what is said of Titles divided by Evaristus may be true in this sense, that since they could not safely meet together in the Persecution under Trajan, they dispersed themselves into distinct meetings, and had Presbyters assigned to officiate in each of them. And yet the Christians at Rome were then no more, nor long after, than might all meet together for Worship, and did so when it could be done in safety.