A33359:81
Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times
Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times, or, A defence of the answer to Dr. Stillingfleets allegations out of antiquity for such churches against the exceptions offered in the preface to a late treatise called A vindication of the primitive church, where what is further produced out of Scripture and ancient authors for diocesan churches is also discussed.Diocesan churches not yet discovered in the primitive times, or, A defence of the answer to Dr. Stillingfleets allegations out of antiquity for such churches against the exceptions offered in the preface to a late treatise called A vindication of the primitive church, where what is further produced out of Scripture and antient authors for diocesan churches is also discussed.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1682
Diocesan Churches not yet discovered in the Primitive times.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
He answers however I do not see why that learned Antiquary's opinion may not be maintained against this Gentleman's objections, he says that Alexandria was divided before Epiphanius his time between several Bishops (I said in Epiphanius's time) it cannot be denied. But that is not the thing Epiphanius speaks of, but that before the Election of Theonas against Athanasius, there were never two opposite Bishops as in other Churches.
He answers however I do not see why that learned Antiquarie's opinion may not be maintained against this Gentleman's objections, he sayes that Alexandria was divided before Epiphanius his time between several Bishops (I said in Epiphanius's time) it cannot be denied. But that is not the thing Epiphanius speaks of, but that before the Election of Theonas against Athanasius, there were never two opposite Bishops as in other Churches.
But this doth neither agree with the one nor defend the other; it agrees not with Epiphanius, but makes him contradict himself, for he tells us there were two opposite Bishops at Alexandria before Theonas was chosen. ⟨p. 24⟩For this was not till Alexander's death, but he says Pistus was made Bishop there by the Arians while Alexander was livingo. And he could not be ignorant of what Eusebius declaresp, that upon the division in Egypt occasioned by Arius, in every City, [Greek or Hebrew], there was Bishop against Bishop, and People against People. Nor doth it defend the Antiquary, for he speaks universally without limiting himself to the Election of Theonas, Ecclesiam Alexandrinam nunquam in parts scissam quarum singulae Episcopum suum habebant, that Church was never divided so as to have opposite Bishops.
But this doth neither agree with the one nor defend the other; it agrees not with Epiphanius, but makes him contradict himself, for he tells us there were two opposite Bishops at Alexandria before Theonas was chosen.