A33360:299
A discourse concerning liturgies
A discourse concerning liturgies by ... David Clarkson.
London: printed for Tho. Parkhurst, 1689
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And so I leave them, stuffed so full with the corruptions of later times, that none but those who are fond of such corruptions, and would fain have them, right or wrong, of Ancient generous extract, can believe them to be the issue of those Fathers; only let me interpose my conjecture, how it came to pass, that Basil, Chrysostom, and Ambrose too, were accounted the Authors of Liturgies, tho' neither themselves, nor any that lived with them, or near the time in which they flourished, mention any such thing. It is recorded of each of these persons, signally and peculiarly, that they introduced a new mode and order of Singing, into the respective Churches, where they presided, never there used before. Basil's new Psalmody, brought in by him to Caesarea, was made more remarkable, by the offence taken thereat by the Clergy of Neocaesarea, as an innovation in the Worship of God: He defends it, and gives an account what it was, Epist. 63. [Greek or Hebrew]: If the cause be asked of this implacable and perpetual quarrel, they say, It is the Psalms, and the mode of singing, altering the custom, which hath been retained amongst us. And afterwards, [Greek or Hebrew], There was none of this (say they) in the time of Gregory the Great. Now Basil denies not, but he had begun another way of singing, than they had been accustomed to; but that it might appear, how little reason there was to quarrel with him for it, he declares what it was, [Greek or Hebrew], &c. finally, rising from Prayer, they betake ⟨p. 167⟩themselves to singing, and sometimes the Company being distributed into two parts, they answer one another in singing. The First who brought up this mode of singing, mwas Flavianus and Diodorus at Antioch, using it in their Conventicles, when the Arians had possest themselves of the public Churches, as Theodoret relates it l. From thence it past to other places, and was first at Caesarea, practised by Basil.
And so I leave them, stufft so full with the corruptions of later times, that none but those who are fond of such corruptions, and would fain have them, right or wrong, of Antient generous extract, can believe them to be the issue of those Fathers; only let me interpose my conjecture, how it came to pass, that Basil, Chrysostom, and Ambrose too, were accounted the Authors of Liturgies, tho' neither themselves, nor any that lived with them, or near the time in which they flourished, mention any such thing. It is recorded of each of these persons, signally and peculiarly, that they introduced a new mode and order of Singing, into the respective Churches, where they presided, never there used before. Basil's new Psalmody, brought in by him to Caesarea, was made more remarkable, by the offence taken thereat by the Clergy of Neocaesarea, as an innovation in the Worship of God: He defends it, and gives an account what it was, Epist. 63. : If the cause be asked of this implacable and perpetual quarrel, they say, It is the Psalms, and the mode of singing, altering the custom, which hath been retained amongst us. And afterwards, , There was none of this (say they) in the time of Gregory the Great. Now Basil denies not, but he had begun another way of singing, than they had been accustomed to; but that it might appear, how little reason there was to quarrel with him for it, he declares what it was, , &c. finally, rising from Prayer, they betake