A34675:110
A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of self contradiction, charged on…A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of selfe contradiction, charged on…
A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of self contradiction, charged on him by Mr. Dan. Cawdrey written by himself not long before his death ; whereunto is prefixed, an answer to a late treatise of the said Mr. Cawdrey about the nature of schism, by John Owen ...A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of selfe contradiction, charged on him by Mr. Dan. Cavvdrey written by himselfe not long before his death ; whereunto is prefixed, an answer to a late treatise of the said Mr. Cavvdrey about the nature of schisme, by John Owen ...
Oxford: printed by H. Hall for T. Robinson, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. The Keys were given to Peter at an Apostle as an Elder, as a Believer. So the Sense is most full. The keys, Pag. 4. | 1. The power of the keys is given to Peter, not at an Apostle nor as Elder, but as a Profest Believer The way, P. 27. | 1 Peter Received not the keys, merely as a Believer, but as a Believer publicly professing his Faith, &c. The way cleared Part. 2 p. 39. To like Purpose M. Hooker Surv. Part. 1. p. 203
1. The Keyes were given to Peter at an Apostle as an Elder, as a Believer. So the Sense is most full. The keyes, Pag. 4. | 1. The power of the keyes is given to Peter, not at an Apostle nor as Elder, but as a Profest Believer The way, P. 27. | 1 Peter Received not the keyes, meerely as a Believer, but as a Believer publickly professing his Faith, &c. The way cleared Part. 2 p. 39. To like Purpose M. Hooker Surv. Part. 1. p. 203
The Reconciliation of this Seeming Contradiction were obvious and easy; take the words as they stand in the Scheme; for so it might be said, Brethren, are sometimes put for private members of the Church, and Contradistinguished from such as bear office in the Church. As when it is said in the Synodical Letter (Act. ⟨p. 5⟩15. 23.) The Apostles, Elders, and Brethren. Sometimes Brethren are put more generally, as Comprehending all the members of the Church, both officers and private members as Gal. 6. 1: and frequently else where: In the former Sense, the Passage in the Keys speaketh, when it saith, the sense of the words will be most full, if Peter be conceived as Receiving the Keys in the Name both of the officers, and private members, to wit, in the Name of the Apostles, Elders, and Brethren. In the latter sense, the words of the Scheme might be taken to Run, That the Power of the keys was given to Peter, not as an Apostle (for then it had been Given only to the Apostles:) nor as an Elder (for then it had been only to Elders) but as a Profest Believer. And under the General Name of Profest Believers, not only private Brethren, but Apostles, and Elders may be comprehended. For all the Apostles & all the Elders are profest Believers: ⟨p. 6⟩And so all of them may claim their Interest in the Power of the keys, according to the several measure and latitude of Power assigned to them in the Scriptures. But I will not so answer; because in the Way the context speaketh of such Brethren, as have not power to exercise the Pastoral Ministry of the word & Sacraments. But notwithstanding that the Assoilment of the contradiction is no less fair and clear. For Mr Cawdrey well knoweth (and so doth any Logician:) That to a contradiction, It is a necessary Requisite (amongst others:) That both speak ad Idem. But here it is otherwise. In the keys I spake of such a power of the keys, as Peter Received Formally, standing in the room both of an Apostle and of an Elder, and of a Profest Believer: that is, such a Power as Peter having Received might exercise in his own person, and each one of them respectively. In the Way, I spake of such a power, as the Brethren of the Church ⟨p. 7⟩have Received not formally (farther than concerneth their own liberty) but virtually only.
The Reconciliation of this Seeming Contradiction were obvious and easy; take the words as they stand in the Scheme; for so it might be said, Brethren, are sometimes put for private members of the Church, and Contradistinguished from such as beare office in the Church. As when it is said in the Synodicall Letter (Act. ⟨p. 5⟩15. 23.) The Apostles, Elders, and Brethren. Sometimes Brethren are put more generally, as Comprehending all the members of the Church, both officers and private members as Gal. 6. 1: and frequently else where: In the former Sence, the Passage in the Keyes speaketh, when it saith, the sense of the words will be most full, if Peter be conceived as Receiving the Keyes in the Name both of the officers, and private members, to wit, in the Name of the Apostles, Elders, and Brethren. In the latter sense, the words of the Scheme might be taken to Runne, That the Power of the keyes was given to Peter, not as an Apostle (for then it had been Given only to the Apostles:) nor as an Elder (for then it had been only to Elders) but as a Profest Believer. And under the Generall Name of Profest Believers, not only private Brethren, but Apostles, and Elders may be comprehended. For all the Apostles & all the Elders are profest Believers: ⟨p. 6⟩And so all of them may claime their Interest in the Power of the keyes, according to the severall measure and latitude of Power assigned to them in the Scriptures. But I will not so answer; because in the Way the context speaketh of such Brethren, as have not power to exercise the Pastoral Ministry of the word & Sacraments. But notwithstanding that the Assoylment of the contradiction is no lesse faire and cleare. For Mr Cawdrey well knoweth (and so doth any Logician:) That to a contradiction, It is a necessary Requisite (amongst others:) That both speake ad Idem. But here it is otherwise. In the keyes I spake of such a power of the keyes, as Peter Received Formally, standing in the roome both of an Apostle and of an Elder, and of a Profest Believer: that is, such a Power as Peter having Received might exercise in his own person, and each one of them respectively. In the Way, I spake of such a power, as the Brethren of the Church ⟨p. 7⟩have Received not formally (farther than concerneth their own liberty) but virtually only.
For though the Brethren have not a formal Power to exercise the Pastoral ministry of the word and Sacraments, yet they have a virtual Power to exercise them by choosing and calling forth such Officers as have a formal Power to exercise the same. And there is nothing in the keys, or in the way, or in the Defence, that contradicteth this. So that both these two Passages (in the keys, and in the way) are so far from making a Contradiction (and that so flat as never any more) as that they do not indeed amount to an Opposition. In an Opposition both parts cannot be true: here both are true. Peter considered as standing in the Room of an Apostle, Elder, and Profest Believer, did receive Formally all the Power of the keys: The Body of the Brethren have received, though the power of their liberty Formally; ⟨p. 8⟩yet all other Parts of Church Power which belongeth to Officers, they have Received only virtually and this very distinction is expressed in terminis, in the very same Page (27. of the way) whence this [Greek or Hebrew] is fetched. As for his Exaggeration of the Contradiction, That is was as flat, as never any more, though he to make this Comparative Speech seem less hyperbolical, do tell us in a Parenthesis, That Contradictions do not Recipere magis & minùs (and therefore if they make any Contradiction at all It must needs be as slat, as ever any was:) He may be pleased to Consider, That such a Parenthesis, though it make his Speech, less hyperbolical, yet it maketh it the more irrational; If I should say Nero was as wicked a man as ever any was, and yet presuppose all men were equally wicked (wickedness in men did not Recipere magis & minùs) there were very little Reason in Such Exaggeration. In my former Answer to this Contradiction ⟨p. 9⟩(entitled, The way of the Congregational Churches cleared) I said the words whereon the Assertour grounded this Contradiction, were his own not mine. For He reporteth me to say (in the keys pag. 4.) That the keys were delivered to Peter as an Apostle, as an Elder, as a Believer. But in his Preface (Sect. 5. Num. 1.) He confesseth;
For though the Brethren have not a formall Power to excercise the Pastorall ministry of the word and Sacraments, yet they have a virtuall Power to exercise them by choosing and calling forth such Officers as have a formall Power to exercise the same. And there is nothing in the keyes, or in the way, or in the Defence, that contradicteth this. So that both these two Passages (in the keyes, and in the way) are so farre from making a Contradiction (and that so flat as never any more) as that they doe not indeed amount to an Opposition. In an Opposition both parts cannot be true: here both are true. Peter considered as standing in the Roome of an Apostle, Elder, and Profest Believer, did receive Formally all the Power of the keyes: The Body of the Brethren have received, though the power of their liberty Formally; ⟨p. 8⟩yet all other Parts of Church Power which belongeth to Officers, they have Received only virtually and this very distinction is expressed in terminis, in the very same Page (27. of the way) whence this 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 is fetched. As for his Exageration of the Contradiction, That is was as flat, as never any more, though he to make this Comparative Speech seem lesse hyperbolicall, doe tell us in a Parenthesis, That Contradictions doe not Recipere magis & minùs (and therefore if they make any Contradiction at all It must needs be as slat, as ever any was:) He may be pleased to Consider, That such a Parenthesis, though it make his Speech, lesse hyperbolicall, yet it maketh it the more irrationall; If I should say Nero was as wicked a man as ever any was, and yet presuppose all men were equally wicked (wickednesse in men did not Recipere magis & minùs) there were very little Reason in Such Exaggeration. In my former Answer to this Contradiction ⟨p. 9⟩(intituled, The way of the Congregationall Churches cleared) I said the words whereon the Assertour grounded this Contradiction, were his own not mine. For He reporteth me to say (in the keyes pag. 4.) That the keyes were delivered to Peter as an Apostle, as an Elder, as a Believer. But in his Preface (Sect. 5. Num. 1.) He confesseth;
That the words are not mine in terminis: but in sense, (he saith) they be. For I said take Peter not as an Apostle Only, but as an Elder also, and a Believer too, all may well stand together.
Whereupon he Inferreth; Doth not this discourse clearly hold forth this Proposition, as the sense of that Text, The keys were delivered to Peter as an Apostle, as an Elder, as a Believer too? all may well stand together.
Whereupon he Inferreth; Doth not this discourse clearly hold forth this Proposition, as the sense of that Text, The keyes were delivered to Peter as an Apostle, as an Elder, as a Believer too? all may well stand together.
Ans. That discourse of mine is so far from clearly holding forth that Proposition, that it clearly holdeth forth the contrary in express terms: ⟨p. 14⟩my express terms be, Take Peter considered not only as an Apostle &c. now if not only as an Apostle, than not as an Apostle, For if they were delivered to him as an Apostle, then to all the Apostles, and only to the Apostles: which my words in Terminis do expressly Deny.
Ans. That discourse of mine is so farre from clearly holding forth that Proposition, that it clearly holdeth forth the contrary in expresse termes: ⟨p. 14⟩my expresse termes be, Take Peter considered not only as an Apostle &c. now if not only as an Apostle, than not as an Apostle, For if they were delivered to him as an Apostle, then to all the Apostles, and only to the Apostles: which my words in Terminis doe expresly Deny.
But saith he, This Apology maketh it worse, For if it be so that whatsoever is Attributed to any as such, is given to all such universally, reciprocally, and only to such: Now Assume.
But the keys were given to Peter as an Apostle, Therefore they were given only to the Apostles, and not to the Believers as such.
But the keyes were given to Peter as an Apostle, Therefore they were given only to the Apostles, and not to the Believers as such.
But here the Assumption is Palpably false, not at all delivered by me, but dragged out of my words against the letter and against the sense of them. I say the keys were not given to Peter as an Apostle only: why then not to him as an Apostle, but as He is jointly considered with other Officers and Brethren. When therefore ⟨p. 15⟩he Appealeth to the Judgment of any Logician, whether to say Peter Received the keys not as an Apostle only, but an Elder also, and a Believer, be not as much as to say, Peter had the Power of the keys given Him, as an Apostle, as an Elder, and as a Believer: Verily if that were the Judgment of all Logicians I should conclude, either that Logic had forsaken the world, or at least that my self were forsaken of Logic.
But here the Assumption is Palpably false, not at all delivered by me, but dragged out of my words against the letter and against the sence of them. I say the keyes were not given to Peter as an Apostle only: why then not to him as an Apostle, but as He is joyntly considered with other Officers and Brethren. When therefore ⟨p. 15⟩he Appealeth to the Judgment of any Logician, whether to say Peter Received the keyes not as an Apostle only, but an Elder also, and a Believer, be not as much as to say, Peter had the Power of the keyes given Him, as an Apostle, as an Elder, and as a Believer: Verily if that were the Judgment of all Logicians I should conclude, either that Logick had forsaken the world, or at least that my selfe were forsaken of Logick.
When Christ Promised the keys to Peter, though he spake Indefinitely, keys, yet he meaneth universally all the keys of the kingdom of Heaven. And to put all the keys into Peter's hand as an Apostle, though it would communicate them indeed to all the Apostles, yet since the Death of all the Apostles, all the Churches and all the Elders, have been left destitute of the Power of the keys.
When Christ Promised the keyes to Peter, though he spake Indefinitely, keyes, yet he meaneth universally all the keyes of the kingdome of Heaven. And to put all the keyes into Peter's hand as an Apostle, though it would communicate them indeed to all the Apostles, yet since the Death of all the Apostles, all the Churches and all the Elders, have been left destitute of the Power of the keyes.
And if so, then why do we blame the Seekers who have cast off all Churches, ⟨p. 12⟩and all Ordinances, 'till new Apostles come?
And if so, then why doe we blame the Seekers who have cast off all Churches, ⟨p. 12⟩and all Ordinances, 'till new Apostles come?
Again the Replyer Argueth thus on the contrary (from that Passage in the way pag. 27:) If the keys were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then to all Believers, and only to Believers. But (saith the Way) the keys were given to Peter not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, therefore they were given to all Believers (Women and all) and only to Believers.
Againe the Replyer Argueth thus on the contrary (from that Passage in the way pag. 27:) If the keyes were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then to all Believers, and only to Believers. But (saith the Way) the keyes were given to Peter not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, therefore they were given to all Believers (Women and all) and only to Believers.
Ans. It hath been showed above, That in that Place in the Way, I speak expressly of Profest Believers, to have received all the power of the keys not Formally, but virtually. So that if there be some Power of the keys which they cannot exercise Formally as Brethren, yet they may exercise the same virtually, by choosing and calling forth such, as may formally exercise the same for them: which presupposed I answer to the Major, If the Power of the keys (which was to continue ⟨p. 13⟩in the Church) were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then it was Given to all Believers, and only to believers, & to such whom Believers shall orderly choose, and call forth to execute the same. As to instance in a like example, If heat be Given to Fire, as such, then to all Fire, and only to Fire, & to such other things, as Fire communicateth his virtue to. When therefore the Publishers of the keys say, The Power of the keys may be Disposed in a due Allotment into divers hands. The Replyer had no cause to say, Herein they neither Agree with me, nor with them. They say it is put into diverse hands, And he saith it is Given only to Believers: And is not this a Contradiction?
Ans. It hath been shewed above, That in that Place in the Way, I speak expresly of Profest Believers, to have received all the power of the keyes not Formally, but virtually. So that if there be some Power of the keyes which they cannot exercise Formally as Brethren, yet they may exercise the same virtually, by choosing and calling forth such, as may formally exercise the same for them: which presupposed I answer to the Major, If the Power of the keyes (which was to continue ⟨p. 13⟩in the Church) were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then it was Given to all Believers, and only to believers, & to such whom Believers shall orderly choose, and call forth to execute the same. As to instance in a like example, If heate be Given to Fire, as such, then to all Fire, and only to Fire, & to such other things, as Fire communicateth his virtue to. When therefore the Publishers of the keyes say, The Power of the keyes may be Disposed in a due Allotment into divers hands. The Replyer had no cause to say, Herein they neither Agree with me, nor with them. They say it is put into diverse hands, And he saith it is Given only to Believers: And is not this a Contradiction?
Ans: No verily; For when I say It is given to Believers as such, and express virtually, as well as Formally, The meaning is clear, It is given to all Believers, and only to Believers, and by them Communicated to such, as ⟨p. 10⟩they do orderly choose and call forth, to the exercise of the same. And the publishers of the keys I doubt not, will say as much. When I said (in the way) That the brethren might not administer Sacraments in Defect of all Officers, And therefore made it appear that one sort of men (the brethren) had not Received all the Power of the keys Formally. The Replyer returneth, Truly this is to Discover the Contradiction the more. For if the Power of the keys be Delivered to Believers as such, then the Power of Administering the Sacraments is Given to them: for that is a Part of the Power of the keys.
Ans: No verily; For when I say It is given to Believers as such, and expresse virtually, as well as Formally, The meaning is cleare, It is given to all Believers, and only to Believers, and by them Communicated to such, as ⟨p. 10⟩they doe orderly choose and call forth, to the exercise of the same. And the publishers of the keyes I doubt not, will say as much. When I said (in the way) That the brethren might not administer Sacraments in Defect of all Officers, And therefore made it appeare that one sort of men (the brethren) had not Received all the Power of the keyes Formally. The Replyer returneth, Truly this is to Discover the Contradiction the more. For if the Power of the keyes be Delivered to Believers as such, then the Power of Administring the Sacraments is Given to them: for that is a Part of the Power of the keyes.
Ans. It is wearisome to repeat so often the same Answer; yet let me say it once more, and leave it; He that saith, Believers Receive all the Power of the keys as Profest Believers, He saith all of them have Received the Power, and they only, and such as Receive their Power from them. And this is the force of quatevus ⟨p. 11⟩Tale; That whosoever Receive any thing as such, all such do Receive it, & none but such as Derive it from them.
Ans. It is wearysome to repeat so often the same Answer; yet let me say it once more, and leave it; He that saith, Believers Receive all the Power of the keyes as Profest Believers, He saith all of them have Received the Power, and they only, and such as Receive their Power from them. And this is the force of quateuus ⟨p. 11⟩Tale; That whosoever Receive any thing as such, all such doe Receive it, & none but such as Derive it from them.
But saith the Replyer, In the Way, he giveth the greater part of Church power to the Body of the Church (pag. 45.) to wit, to Ordain, and in some cases) to excommunicate all their Church Officers: which are the highest Acts of Rule (as else where he speaketh:) Therefore he may not Deny them the lesser, which is to Administer the Sacraments.
But saith the Replyer, In the Way, he giveth the greater part of Church power to the Body of the Church (pag. 45.) to wit, to Ordaine, and in some cases) to excommunicate all their Church Officers: which are the highest Acts of Rule (as else where he speaketh:) Therefore he may not Deny them the lesser, which is to Administer the Sacraments.