A34675:121
A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of self contradiction, charged on…A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of selfe contradiction, charged on…
A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of self contradiction, charged on him by Mr. Dan. Cawdrey written by himself not long before his death ; whereunto is prefixed, an answer to a late treatise of the said Mr. Cawdrey about the nature of schism, by John Owen ...A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of selfe contradiction, charged on him by Mr. Dan. Cavvdrey written by himselfe not long before his death ; whereunto is prefixed, an answer to a late treatise of the said Mr. Cavvdrey about the nature of schisme, by John Owen ...
Oxford: printed by H. Hall for T. Robinson, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Again the Replyer Argueth thus on the contrary (from that Passage in the way pag. 27:) If the keys were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then to all Believers, and only to Believers. But (saith the Way) the keys were given to Peter not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, therefore they were given to all Believers (Women and all) and only to Believers.
Againe the Replyer Argueth thus on the contrary (from that Passage in the way pag. 27:) If the keyes were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then to all Believers, and only to Believers. But (saith the Way) the keyes were given to Peter not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, therefore they were given to all Believers (Women and all) and only to Believers.
Ans. It hath been showed above, That in that Place in the Way, I speak expressly of Profest Believers, to have received all the power of the keys not Formally, but virtually. So that if there be some Power of the keys which they cannot exercise Formally as Brethren, yet they may exercise the same virtually, by choosing and calling forth such, as may formally exercise the same for them: which presupposed I answer to the Major, If the Power of the keys (which was to continue ⟨p. 13⟩in the Church) were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then it was Given to all Believers, and only to believers, & to such whom Believers shall orderly choose, and call forth to execute the same. As to instance in a like example, If heat be Given to Fire, as such, then to all Fire, and only to Fire, & to such other things, as Fire communicateth his virtue to. When therefore the Publishers of the keys say, The Power of the keys may be Disposed in a due Allotment into divers hands. The Replyer had no cause to say, Herein they neither Agree with me, nor with them. They say it is put into diverse hands, And he saith it is Given only to Believers: And is not this a Contradiction?
Ans. It hath been shewed above, That in that Place in the Way, I speak expresly of Profest Believers, to have received all the power of the keyes not Formally, but virtually. So that if there be some Power of the keyes which they cannot exercise Formally as Brethren, yet they may exercise the same virtually, by choosing and calling forth such, as may formally exercise the same for them: which presupposed I answer to the Major, If the Power of the keyes (which was to continue ⟨p. 13⟩in the Church) were given to Peter, not as an Apostle, nor as an Elder, but as a Believer, then it was Given to all Believers, and only to believers, & to such whom Believers shall orderly choose, and call forth to execute the same. As to instance in a like example, If heate be Given to Fire, as such, then to all Fire, and only to Fire, & to such other things, as Fire communicateth his virtue to. When therefore the Publishers of the keyes say, The Power of the keyes may be Disposed in a due Allotment into divers hands. The Replyer had no cause to say, Herein they neither Agree with me, nor with them. They say it is put into diverse hands, And he saith it is Given only to Believers: And is not this a Contradiction?
Ans: No verily; For when I say It is given to Believers as such, and express virtually, as well as Formally, The meaning is clear, It is given to all Believers, and only to Believers, and by them Communicated to such, as ⟨p. 10⟩they do orderly choose and call forth, to the exercise of the same. And the publishers of the keys I doubt not, will say as much. When I said (in the way) That the brethren might not administer Sacraments in Defect of all Officers, And therefore made it appear that one sort of men (the brethren) had not Received all the Power of the keys Formally. The Replyer returneth, Truly this is to Discover the Contradiction the more. For if the Power of the keys be Delivered to Believers as such, then the Power of Administering the Sacraments is Given to them: for that is a Part of the Power of the keys.
Ans: No verily; For when I say It is given to Believers as such, and expresse virtually, as well as Formally, The meaning is cleare, It is given to all Believers, and only to Believers, and by them Communicated to such, as ⟨p. 10⟩they doe orderly choose and call forth, to the exercise of the same. And the publishers of the keyes I doubt not, will say as much. When I said (in the way) That the brethren might not administer Sacraments in Defect of all Officers, And therefore made it appeare that one sort of men (the brethren) had not Received all the Power of the keyes Formally. The Replyer returneth, Truly this is to Discover the Contradiction the more. For if the Power of the keyes be Delivered to Believers as such, then the Power of Administring the Sacraments is Given to them: for that is a Part of the Power of the keyes.
Ans. It is wearisome to repeat so often the same Answer; yet let me say it once more, and leave it; He that saith, Believers Receive all the Power of the keys as Profest Believers, He saith all of them have Received the Power, and they only, and such as Receive their Power from them. And this is the force of quatevus ⟨p. 11⟩Tale; That whosoever Receive any thing as such, all such do Receive it, & none but such as Derive it from them.
Ans. It is wearysome to repeat so often the same Answer; yet let me say it once more, and leave it; He that saith, Believers Receive all the Power of the keyes as Profest Believers, He saith all of them have Received the Power, and they only, and such as Receive their Power from them. And this is the force of quateuus ⟨p. 11⟩Tale; That whosoever Receive any thing as such, all such doe Receive it, & none but such as Derive it from them.
But saith the Replyer, In the Way, he giveth the greater part of Church power to the Body of the Church (pag. 45.) to wit, to Ordain, and in some cases) to excommunicate all their Church Officers: which are the highest Acts of Rule (as else where he speaketh:) Therefore he may not Deny them the lesser, which is to Administer the Sacraments.
But saith the Replyer, In the Way, he giveth the greater part of Church power to the Body of the Church (pag. 45.) to wit, to Ordaine, and in some cases) to excommunicate all their Church Officers: which are the highest Acts of Rule (as else where he speaketh:) Therefore he may not Deny them the lesser, which is to Administer the Sacraments.
Ans. The answer is ready at hand, and was ready at his hand (in Part 2: of the Congregational way cleared pag. 29.) where I Distinguish Potestas into officiariam and honorariam. Excommunication by the Brethren is the highest Act of Honoraria Potestas: but not of Officiaria Potestas. To Preach the word with Authority, and to Administer the Seals of it, are acts of the highest office-Power in the Church. Popish Divines would take ⟨p. 16⟩it very ill, if any Act of Church Power were said to be higher than Conficere corpus Domini. But excommunication largely taken is an Act of a Power proper to a Community. Any community hath power ex Natura rei, to Receive into their Communion, & to cast not of their Communion. Every sound Body hath a power to cast out his own superfluous humours, and to cut off his own Putrid members: As for ordination, though we look at it (with Dr Ames) as Adjunctum consummans of the Peoples Election, and vocation of their Officers (and therefore not utterly Eccentrical from the Peoples power;) yet our Churches do not Practise it ordinarily, where they have Elders of their own, or can Procure other Elders to Join with them.
Ans. The answer is ready at hand, and was ready at his hand (in Part 2: of the Congregationall way cleared pag. 29.) where I Distinguish Potestas into officiariam and honorariam. Excommunication by the Brethren is the highest Act of Honoraria Potestas: but not of Officiaria Potestas. To Preach the word with Authority, and to Administer the Seales of it, are acts of the highest office-Power in the Church. Popish Divines would take ⟨p. 16⟩it very ill, if any Act of Church Power were said to be higher than Conficere corpus Domini. But excommunication largly taken is an Act of a Power proper to a Community. Any community hath power ex Natura rei, to Receive into their Communion, & to cast not of their Communion. Every sound Body hath a power to cast out his own superfluous humours, and to cut off his own Putrid members: As for ordination, though we looke at it (with Dr Ames) as Adjunctum consummans of the Peoples Election, and vocation of their Officers (and therefore not utterly Excentrical from the Peoples power;) yet our Churches doe not Practise it ordinarily, where they have Elders of their own, or can Procure other Elders to Joyne with them.
As for that last words in the Scheme of the first Contradiction, I know not whether the Replyer put any weight, or stress, in that, in the first Column, the keys are said to be given (to ⟨p. 17⟩wit, partly) to Believers, and in the same Column again to the Fraternity, with the Presbytery, in the second Column to Profest Believers, In the third to Believers Publicly Professing their Faith: And (in Mr Hookers Judgment) Not to Believers as Believers, but as Believers Covenanting.
As for that last words in the Scheme of the first Contradiction, I know not whether the Replyer put any weight, or stresse, in that, in the first Columne, the keyes are said to be given (to ⟨p. 17⟩wit, partly) to Believers, and in the same Columne againe to the Fraternity, with the Presbytery, in the second Columne to Profest Believers, In the third to Believers Publickly Professing their Faith: And (in Mr Hookers Judgment) Not to Believers as Believers, but as Believers Covenanting.
But if it be requisite to say any thing to this, I would say. 1. That the Fraternity, and Profest Believers, and Believers Publicly Professing their Faith, are all one. And the common Name of Believers is often put for all the rest, They that were Added to the Church (Acts 2. 47: and 41:) are called by the common name of Believers Acts 2. 44. and 4. 32. when Mr Hooker saith the Power is not Given to Believers as Believers, but as Believers Covenanting, He meaneth the same that I do, by Profest Believers.
But if it be requisite to say any thing to this, I would say. 1. That the Fraternity, and Profest Believers, and Believers Publickly Professing their Faith, are all one. And the common Name of Believers is often put for all the rest, They that were Added to the Church (Acts 2. 47: and 41:) are called by the common name of Believers Acts 2. 44. and 4. 32. when Mr Hooker saith the Power is not Given to Believers as Believers, but as Believers Covenanting, He meaneth the same that I do, by Profest Believers.
As for women (whom the Replyer cast in our way before) though they be Believers and so partake in the same common Salvation, as also in the word ⟨p. 18⟩and seals: yet because of the frailty of their sex, they are expressly exempted by the Apostle from any Act of Power in the Church. 1 Cor. 14. 34, 35. and 1 Tim: 2. 11, 12. Yet that Impeacheth not the Generality of the Proposition; That all the Fraternity of Believers have Part in the Power of the Keys: That all men once Dye is the general Proposition of the Apostle Heb: 9. 27. which is not Impeached by the Translation of Enoch and Elijah.
As for women (whom the Replyer cast in our way before) though they be Believers and so partake in the same common Salvation, as also in the word ⟨p. 18⟩and seales: yet because of the frailty of their sex, they are expresly exempted by the Apostle from any Act of Power in the Church. 1 Cor. 14. 34, 35. and 1 Tim: 2. 11, 12. Yet that Impeacheth not the Generality of the Proposition; That all the Fraternity of Believers have Part in the Power of the Keyes: That all men once Dye is the generall Proposition of the Apostle Heb: 9. 27. which is not Impeached by the Translation of Enoch and Elias.
Having thus cleared the first Answer to this contradiction, Let us weigh next what he saith to the second Answer, which saith he is given to help out the former, for I had said.
2. If there had been some Difference between the Keys and the Way, in some expressions: yet it lay rather in Logical Terms, then in the Doctrine of Divinity, or Church Practise, and such is this, about the first subject of the Power of the Keys.
2. If there had been some Difference between the Keyes and the Way, in some expressions: yet it lay rather in Logicall Termes, then in the Doctrine of Divinity, or Church Practise, and such is this, about the first subject of the Power of the Keyes.
What saith the Replyer to this? He Returneth a double exception.
1. Saith He, Had it been only a lesser ⟨p. 19⟩Difference about a Logical Notion (as he minceth it) the Assertor had not Observed it. But a difference (of the highest magnitude) to Contradiction, in Delivering a New way is very Remarkable. How shall we be brought to Agree with them that contradict not only one another, but one man himself.
1. Saith He, Had it been only a lesser ⟨p. 19⟩Difference about a Logicall Notion (as he minceth it) the Assertor had not Observed it. But a difference (of the highest magnitude) to Contradiction, in Delivering a New way is very Remarkable. How shall we be brought to Agree with them that contradict not only one another, but one man himselfe.
Answer 1. It was not any weakness of the first Answer, that needed a second to Help it out, but variety of fit matter for a just Defence produced it: It needed no help, but to clear it self from groundless exceptions.
Answer 1. It was not any weaknesse of the first Answer, that needed a second to Help it out, but variety of fit matter for a just Defence produced it: It needed no help, but to cleare it selfe from groundlesse exceptions.
Answer 2. The seeming Difference between the way and the Keys (if any be in this point) it lieth rather in Logical expressions, then in the Doctrine of Divinity, or Church Practise. For what ever the Different Judgments of men of our way may be, touching the first subject of the Power of the Keys (some Placing it in the Body of the Church, others Dividing it between officers and Brethren:) yet in the Doctrine of Divinity we all Agree with one Accord, that ⟨p. 20⟩the Church (even the Body of Churchmembers) have power to choose their officers, to Admit members, and to censure offenders: And that the officers only have Power to Preach the word with office and Authority, and to Administer the Sacraments. And according to this unity of judgment is the uniform Practise of our Churches. And therefore let mincing be left to curious Cooks to prepare their shred meat for queasy stomachs: or let it be left to such as would make the best of a bad cause: we neither Distrust our Cause to be of God, nor do fear any thing more then that it should be hid, and clouded with prejudices and calumnies from such as know it not, and yet seek the Truth in sincerity. And therefore let the Replyer be pleased to consider, whether the Difference be indeed any more then in a Logical Notion: and whether they be the words not only of an Assertour, but of an Avenger, to style it a Difference of the highest magnitude? Surely if there were not some more then ⟨p. 21⟩common zeal and Indignation in the cause, A Contradiction in Logical Terms, would not be counted a Difference of the highest magnitude in Divinity: nor would such Difference in words so easy to be reconciled, be blown up to so high an opposition, as a Contradiction.
Answer 2. The seeming Difference between the way and the Keyes (if any be in this point) it lyeth rather in Logicall expressions, then in the Doctrine of Divinity, or Church Practise. For what ever the Different Judgments of men of our way may be, touching the first subject of the Power of the Keyes (some Placing it in the Body of the Church, others Dividing it between officers and Brethren:) yet in the Doctrine of Divinity we all Agree with one Accord, that ⟨p. 20⟩the Church (even the Body of Churchmembers) have power to choose their officers, to Admit members, and to censure offenders: And that the officers only have Power to Preach the word with office and Authority, and to Administer the Sacraments. And according to this unity of judgment is the uniforme Practise of our Churches. And therefore let mincing be left to curious Cookes to prepare their shread meat for queazy stomackes: or let it be left to such as would make the best of a bad cause: we neither Distrust our Cause to be of God, nor do feare any thing more then that it should be hid, and clouded with prejudices and calumnies from such as know it not, and yet seek the Truth in sincerity. And therefore let the Replyer be pleased to consider, whether the Difference be indeed any more then in a Logicall Notion: and whether they be the words not only of an Assertour, but of an Avenger, to style it a Difference of the highest magnitude? Surely if there were not some more then ⟨p. 21⟩common zeale and Indignation in the cause, A Contradiction in Logicall Termes, would not be counted a Difference of the highest magnitude in Divinity: nor vvould such Difference in vvords so easy to be reconciled, be blovven up to so high an opposition, as a Contradiction.
2. His second exception is, That Howsoever the first Subject is indeed a Logical Term, yet the matter Discoursed is Doctrinal Divinity: And whatsoever the Practise be, It is a Contradiction in Divinity as well as in Logic.
2. His second exception is, That Howsoever the first Subject is indeed a Logicall Terme, yet the matter Discoursed is Doctrinall Divinity: And whatsoever the Practise be, It is a Contradiction in Divinity as well as in Logick.