A34675:90
A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of self contradiction, charged on…A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of selfe contradiction, charged on…
A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of self contradiction, charged on him by Mr. Dan. Cawdrey written by himself not long before his death ; whereunto is prefixed, an answer to a late treatise of the said Mr. Cawdrey about the nature of schism, by John Owen ...A defence of Mr. John Cotton from the imputation of selfe contradiction, charged on him by Mr. Dan. Cavvdrey written by himselfe not long before his death ; whereunto is prefixed, an answer to a late treatise of the said Mr. Cavvdrey about the nature of schisme, by John Owen ...
Oxford: printed by H. Hall for T. Robinson, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Neither shall I at present, (allotting very few hours to the dispatch of this business, which yet I judge more then it deserves) consider the scattered ensuing passages about Ordination, Church Government, number of Elders, and the like, which all men know, not at all to belong unto the main controversy which was by me undertaken; and that they were against all laws of disputation, plucked violently into this contest, by our Reverend Author. One thing I cannot pass by, and it will upon the matter put a close to what I shall at present offer to this Treatise; having said that Christ hath given no direction for the performance of any duty of worship of sovereign institution, but only in them and by them (meaning particular Churches) he answers that, if I would imply that a Minister in or of a ⟨p. 86⟩Particular Church, may perform those ordinances without those congregations, he contradicts himself for saying a particular Church is the seat of all ordinances, but why so, I pray? may not a particular Church be the seat of all ordinances subjectively, and yet others be the object of them, or of some of them? but saith he, if he mean those ordinances of worship are to be performed only by a minister of a particular congregation, what shall become of the people? I suppose they shall be instructed and built up according to the mind of Christ, and what would people desire more. But whereas he had before said, that I denied a Minister to be a Minister to more then his own Church: and I had asked him who told him so; adding that explication of my judgment, that for so much as men are appointed the objects of the dispensation of the word, I grant a Minister in the dispensation of it to act ministerially, towards not only the members of the Catholic Church, but the visible members of the world also in contradistinction thereunto; he now tells ⟨p. 87⟩me a story of passages between the learned Dr Wallis and my self about his question in the Vespers 1654. namely that as to that question An potestas ministri Evangelici ad unius tantum ecclesiae particularis membra extendatur? I said that, Dr Wallis had brought me a challenge, and that If I did dispute on that question, I must dispute ex animo;
Neither shall I at present, (alloting very few houres to the dispatch of this businesse, which yet I judge more then it deserves) consider the scattered ensuing passages about Ordination, Church Government, number of Elders, and the like, which all men know, not at all to belong unto the maine controversy which was by me undertaken; and that they were against all lawes of disputation, plucked violently into this contest, by our Reverend Author. One thing I cannot passe by, and it will upon the matter put a close to what I shall at present offer to this Treatise; having said that Christ hath given no direction for the performance of any duty of worship of soveraigne institution, but only in them and by them (meaning particular Churches) he answers that, if I would imply that a Minister in or of a ⟨p. 86⟩Particular Church, may performe those ordinances without those congregations, he contradicts himselfe for saying a particular Church is the seate of all ordinances, but why so, I pray? may not a particular Church be the seat of all ordinances subjectively, and yet others be the object of them, or of some of them? but saith he, if he meane those ordinances of worship are to be performed only by a minister of a particular congregation, what shall become of the people? I suppose they shall be instructed and built up according to the mind of Christ, and what would people desire more. But whereas he had before said, that I denyed a Minister to be a Minister to more then his own Church: and I had asked him who told him so; adding that explication of my judgment, that for so much as men are appointed the objects of the dispensation of the word, I grant a Minister in the dispensation of it to act ministerially, towards not only the members of the Catholick Church, but the visible members of the world also in contradistinction thereunto; he now tells ⟨p. 87⟩me a story of passages between the learned Dr Wallis and my selfe about his question in the Vespers 1654. namely that as to that question An potestas ministri Evangelici ad unius tantum ecclesiae particularis membra extendatur? I said that, Dr Wallis had brought me a challenge, and that If I did dispute on that question, I must dispute ex animo;
although I grant that a Minister as a Minister may preach the word, to more then those of his own congregation, yet knowing the sense wherein the learned Dr Wallis maintained that question, it is not impossible, but I might say, if I did dispute I must do it ex animo; for his bringing me a challenge, I do not know that either he did so, or that I put that interpretation on what he did; but I shall crave leave to say, that if the learned Dr Wallis do find any ground, or occasion to bring a challenge unto me, to debate any point of difference between us, I shall not wave answering his desire, although he should bring Mr Cawdry for his second; for the present I shall only ⟨p. 88⟩say, that as it is no commendation to the moderation or ingenuity of any one whatever, thus to publish to the world private hearsays, and what he hath been told of private conferences; so if I would insist on the same course, to make publication of what I have been told hath been the private discourse of some men, it is not unlikely that I should occasion their shame and trouble: yet in this course of proceeding a progress is made in the ensuing words; and Mr Stubs (who is now called my Amanuensis, who some five years ago, transcribed about a sheet of paper for me, and not one line, before or since;) is said to be employed or at least encouraged by me to write against the learned Dr Wallis his Thesis being published; this is as true as much of that that went before, and as somewhat of that, that follows after; and whereas it is added that I said what he had written on that subject, was a scurrilous ridiculous piece, it is of the same nature with the rest of the like reports. I knew that Mr ⟨p. 89⟩Stubs was writing on that subject; but not until he had proceeded far in it; I neither employed him, nor encouraged him in it, any otherwise then the consideration of his papers, after he had written them, may be so interpreted; and the reason why I was not willing he should proceed, next to my desire of continuance of peace in this place, was his using such expressions of me, and somethings of mine, in sundry places of his discourse, as I could not modestly allow to be divulged; the following words to the same purpose with them before mentioned, I remember not;
although I grant that a Minister as a Minister may preach the word, to more then those of his owne congregation, yet knowing the sense wherein the learned Dr VVallis maintained that question, it is not impossible, but I might say, if I did dispute I must do it ex animo; for his bringing me a challenge, I do not know that either he did so, or that I put that interpretation on what he did; but I shall crave leave to say, that if the learned Dr VVallis do find any ground, or occasion to bring a challenge unto me, to debate any point of difference between us, I shall not wave answering his desire, although he should bring Mr Cawdry for his second; for the present I shall only ⟨p. 88⟩say, that as it is no commendation to the moderation or ingenuity of any one whatever, thus to publish to the world private hearesaies, and what he hath been told of private conferences; so if I would insist on the same course, to make publication of what I have been told hath been the private discourse of some men, it is not unlikely that I should occasion their shame and trouble: yet in this course of proceeding a progres is made in the ensuing words; and Mr Stubbes (who is now called my Amanuensis, who some five yeares ago, transcribed about a sheete of paper for me, and not one line, before or since;) is said to be employed or at least encouraged by me to write against the learned Dr Wallis his Thesis being published; this is as true as much of that that went before, and as somewhat of that, that followes after; and whereas it is added that I said what he had written on that subject, was a scurrilous rididulous piece, it is of the same nature with the rest of the like reports. I knew that Mr ⟨p. 89⟩Stubbes was writing on that subject; but not untill he had proceeded farre in it; I neither imployed him, nor encouraged him in it, any otherwise then the consideration of his papers, after he had written them, may be so interpreted; and the reason why I was not willing he should proceed, next to my desire of continuance of peace in this place, was his using such expressions of me, and somethings of mine, in sundry places of his discourse, as I could not modestly allow to be divulged; the following words to the same purpose with them before mentioned, I remember not;
nor did ever think to be engaged in the consideration of such transgressions of the common rules of humane society as those now passed through; Reports, hearsays, talks, private discourse between friends, allegations countenanced by none of these, nor any thing else, are the weapons wherewith I am assaulted. I have heard, I am told, if reports be true, twas vox populi at Oxford, is it not so, I presume ⟨p. 90⟩he will not deny it, are the ornaments of this discourse: strange! that men of experience and gravity should be carried by the power of these temptations not only to the forgetfulness of the royal law of Christ, and all Gospel rule of deportment towards his professed Disciples: but also be engaged into ways and practises, contrary to the dictates of the law of nature, and such as sundry heathens would have abhorred. For my own part, had not God by his providence placed me in that station, wherein others also that fear him are concerned in me, I should not once turn aside to look upon such heaps as that which I have now passed over: my judgment in most heads and articles of Christian Religion is long since published to the world, and I continue through the grace and patience of God preaching in public answerably to the principles I do profess; and if any man shall oppose what I have delivered, or shall so deliver, in print or in the pulpit, or in divinity lectures, as my ⟨p. 91⟩judgment, I shall consider his opposition, and do therein, as God shall guide: with evil surmises, charges upon hearsays, and reports, attended with perpetual excursions from the Argument in hand, I shall no more contend.
nor did ever think to be engaged in the consideration of such transgressions of the common rules of humane society as those now passed through; Reports, heresayes, talkes, private discourse between friends, allegations countenanced by none of these, nor any thing else, are the weapons wherewith I am assaulted. I have heard, I am told, if reports be true, twas vox populi at Oxford, is it not so, I presume ⟨p. 90⟩he will not deny it, are the ornaments of this discourse: strange! that men of experience and gravity should be carried by the power of these temptations not only to the forgetfulnesse of the royall law of Christ, and all Gospell rule of deportment towards his professed Disciples: but also be ingaged into wayes and practises, contrary to the dictates of the law of nature, and such as sundry heathens would have abhorred. For my owne part, had not God by his providence placed me in that station, wherein others also that feare him are concern'd in me, I should not once turne aside to looke upon such heapes as that which I have now passed over: my judgment in most heads and articles of Christian Religion is long since published to the world, and I continue through the grace and patience of God preaching in publick answerably to the principles I doe professe; and if any man shall oppose what I have delivered, or shall so deliver, in print or in the pulpit, or in divinity lectures, as my ⟨p. 91⟩judgment, I shall consider his opposition, and doe therein, as God shall guide: with evill surmises, charges upon hearesayes, and reports, attended with perpetuall excursions from the Argument in hand, I shall no more contend.
Some few observations on scattered passages, will now speedily issue this discourse. Pag. 112. To that Assertion of mine, that if Rome be no particular Church, it is no Church at all, for the Catholic Church it is not, he replies that though it be not such a particular Congregation as I intend, yet it may be a particular Patriarchal Church: but, 1: then it seems it is a particular Church, which grants my inference.
Some few observations on scattered passages, will now speedily issue this discourse. Pag. 112. To that Assertion of mine, that if Rome be no particular Church, it is no Church at all, for the Catholicke Church it is not, he replyes that though it be not such a particular Congregation as I intend, yet it may be a particular Patriarchall Church: but, 1: then it seemes it is a particular Church, which grants my inference.
2. It was a particular Church of Christ's institution, that I inquired after; doth our Author think that Christ hath appointed any Patriarchal Church? a Patriarchal Church, as such, is such from it's Relation to a Patriarch: and he can scarce be thought to judge Patriarchs to be of Divine institution, ⟨p. 92⟩who hath cast off and abjured Episcopacy.
2. It was a particular Church of Christ's institution, that I inquired after; doth our Authour think that Christ hath appointed any Patriarchall Church? a Patriarchall Church, as such, is such from it's Relation to a Patriarch: and he can scarce be thought to judge Patriarches to be of Divine institution, ⟨p. 92⟩who hath cast off and abjured Episcopacy.
The Donatists are mentioned again, p. 113. And I am again Charged with an attempt to vindicate them from schism; my thoughts of them I have before declared to the full; & have no reason to retract any thing from what was then spoken, or to add any thing thereunto; if it may satisfy our Author, I here grant they were Schismatics, with what aggravations he pleaseth; & wherein their schism consisted, I have also declared: but he says, I undertake to exempt some others from schism (I know whom) that suffer with them in former and after ages, under the same imputation; I do so indeed, and I suppose our Author may guess at whom I intend: himself amongst others; I hope he is not so taken up in his thoughts, with charging schism on others, as to forget, that many, the greatest part and number of the true Churches of Christ do condemn him for a Schismatic; a Donatistical Schismatic: ⟨p. 93⟩I suppose he acknowledges the Church of Rome to be a true Church; the Lutheran I am persuaded he will not deny, nor perhaps the Grecian, to be so: The Episcopal Church of England, he contends for; and yet all these with one voice cry out upon him for a Schismatic: and as to the plea of the last, how he can satisfy his conscience, as to the rejection of his lawful superiors, upon his own principles, without pretending any such crime against them, as the Donatists did against Caecilianus, I profess I do not understand: new mention is made of Episcopal ordination, p. 120, And they are said to have had their successive ordination from Rome who ordained therein; so indeed some say, and some otherwise; whether they had or no, is nothing to me, I lay no weight upon it; they held I am sure, that place in England, that without their approbation no man could publicly, preach the Gospel; to say they were Presbyters, and ordained as Presbyters, I know not what satisfaction can arise ⟨p. 94⟩unto Conscience thereby. Party and argument, may be countenanced by it; they profess they ordained as Bishops, that for their lives and souls they durst not ordain but as such; so they told those whom they ordained, and affirm they have open injury done them, by any ones denial of it: As it was, the best is to be made of it; this shift is not handsome;
The Donatists are mentioned againe, p. 113. And I am againe Charged with an attempt to vindicate them from schisme; my thoughts of them I have before declared to the full; & have no reason to retract any thing from what was then spoken, or to adde any thing thereunto; if it may satisfie our Authour, I here grant they were Schismatickes, with what aggravations he pleaseth; & wherein their schisme consisted, I have also declared: but he sayes, I undertake to exempt some others from schisme (I know whom) that suffer with them in former and after ages, under the same imputation; I doe so indeed, and I suppose our Authour may ghesse at whom I intend: himselfe amongst others; I hope he is not so taken up in his thoughts, with charging schisme on others, as to forget, that many, the greatest part and number of the true Churchs of Christ doe condemne him for a Schismatick; a Donatisticall Schismatick: ⟨p. 93⟩I suppose he acknowledges the Church of Rome to be a true Church; the Lutheran I am perswaded he will not deny, nor perhaps the Grecian, to be so: The Episcopall Church of England, he contends for; and yet all these with one voice cry out upon him for a Schismaticke: and as to the plea of the last, how he can satisfie his conscience, as to the rejection of his lawfull superiors, upon his owne principles, without pretending any such crime against them, as the Donatists did against Caecilianus, I professe I do not understand: new mention is made of Episcopall ordination, p. 120, And they are said to have had their successive ordination from Rome who ordained therein; so indeed some say, and some otherwise; whether they had or no, is nothing to me, I lay no weight upon it; they held I am sure, that place in England, that without their approbation no man could publickly, preach the Gospell; to say they were Presbyters, and ordained as Presbyters, I know not what satisfaction can arise ⟨p. 94⟩unto Conscience thereby. Party and argument, may be countenanced by it; they professe they ordained as Bishops, that for their lives and soules they durst not ordaine but as such; so they told those whom they ordained, and affirme they have open injury done them, by any ones deniall of it: As it was, the best is to be made of it; this shift is not handsome;
nor is it ingenious, for any one, that hath looked into Antiquity, to charge me with departing from their sense in the notion of schism, declared about the 3d & 4th Ages, & at the same time to maintain an equality between Bishops and Presbyters; or to say that Bishops ordained as Presbyters, not as Bishops: nor do I understand the excellency of that order which we see in some Churches, where they have two sorts of Elders; the one made so, by ordination without Election, and the other by Election without ordination; those who are ordained, casting off all power and Authority of them that ordained them; and those who are elected, immediately ⟨p. 95⟩rejecting the greatest part of those that chose them.
nor is it ingenious, for any one, that hath looked into Antiquity, to charge me with departing from their sense in the notion of schisme, declared about the 3d & 4th Ages, & at the same time to maintaine an equality between Bishops and Presbyters; or to say that Bishops ordained as Presbyters, not as Bishops: nor doe I understand the excellency of that order which we see in some Churches, where they have two sorts of Elders; the one made so, by ordination without Election, and the other by Election without ordination; those who are ordained, casting off all power and Authority of them that ordained them; and those who are elected, immediately ⟨p. 95⟩rejecting the greatest part of those that chose them.
Nor did I, as is pretend, plead for their Presbyterian way in the year 46; all the ministers (almost) in the county of Essex, know the contrary; one especially, who being a man of great ability, and moderation of spirit, and for his knowledge in those things, not behind any man, I know, in England of his way, with whom in that year, and the next following, I had sundry conferences at public meetings of ministers, as to the several ways of Reformation, then under proposal. But the frivolousness of these imputations, hath been spoken of before, as also the falseness of the Calumny, which our Author is pleased to repeat again, about my turning from ways in Religion.
Nor did I, as is pretend, plead for their Presbyterian way in the yeare 46; all the ministers (almost) in the county of Essex, know the contrary; one especially, who being a man of great ability, and moderation of spirit, and for his knowledge in those things, not behind any man, I know, in England of his way, with whome in that yeare, and the next following, I had sundry conferences at publicke meetings of ministers, as to the severall wayes of Reformation, then under proposall. But the frivolousnesse of these imputations, hath been spoken of before, as also the falsnesse of the Calumny, which our Authour is pleased to repeat againe, about my turning from wayes in Religion.
My description of a particular Church he once more blames as applicable to the Catholic Church invisible, and to the visible Catholic Church (I suppose he means as such) when a participation in the same ordinances numerically, is assigned ⟨p. 96⟩as its difference; He asks, whether it becomes my ingenuity, to interpret the capability of a Churches reduction to it's primitive constitution, by its own fitness and capacity to be so reduced, rather then by its external hinderances or furtherances; But with what ingenuity or modesty, that question is asked, I profess I understand not; and pag. 134, he hath this passage: (only I take notice of his introduction, to his answer, with thanks for the civility of the inquiry in the manner of its expression; my words were these: whether our Reverend Author do not in his conscience think there was no true Church in England 'till, &c, which puts me into suspicion, that the Reverend Doctor was offended, that I did not always (for oft I do) give him that title, of the Reverend Author, or the Doctor, which made him cry out he was never so dealt withal by any party as by me; though upon review, I do not find, that I gave him any uncivil language, unbeseeming me to give or him to receive; and I hear that ⟨p. 97⟩somebody hath dealt more uncivilly with him in that respect, which he took very ill.
My description of a particular Church he once more blames as applicable to the Catholicke Church invisible, and to the visible Catholick Church (I suppose he meanes as such) when a participation in the same ordinances numerically, is assigned ⟨p. 96⟩as its difference; He askes, whether it becomes my ingenuity, to interpret the capability of a Churches reduction to it's primitive constitution, by its owne fitnesse and capacity to be so reduced, rather then by its externall hinderances or furtherances; But with what ingenuity or modesty, that question is asked, I professe I understand not; and pag. 134, he hath this passage: (only I take notice of his introduction, to his answer, with thankes for the civility of the inquiry in the manner of its expresion; my words were these: whether our Reverend Authour doe not in his conscience thinke there was no true Church in England 'till, &c, which puts me into suspition, that the Reverend Doctour was offended, that I did not alwaies (for oft I doe) give him that title, of the Reverend Authour, or the Doctor, which made him cry out he was never so dealt withall by any party as by me; though upon review, I doe not find, that I gave him any uncivill language, unbeseeming me to give or him to receive; and I heare that ⟨p. 97⟩somebody hath dealt more uncivilly with him in that respect, which he took very ill.
Let this Reverend Author, make what use of it he please, I cannot but again tell him, that these things become neither him, nor any man professing the Religion of Jesus Christ, or that hath any respect to truth or sobriety; can any man think, that in his conscience, he gives any credit to the insinuation which here he makes, that I should thank him for calling me Reverend Author, or Reverend Doctor, or be troubled for his not using those expressions? Can the mind of an honest man be thought to be conversant with such mean and low thoughts? for the Title of Reverend, I do give him notice that I have very little valued it, ever since I have considered the saying of Luther; Nunquam periclitatur Religio nisi inter Reverendissimos. So that he may as to me forbear it for the future, and call me, as the Quakers do, and it shall suffice. And for that of Doctor; it was conferred on me by the University in my absence, ⟨p. 98⟩and against my consent, as they have expressed it under their public seal: nor doth any thing but gratitude, and respect unto them, make me once own it; and freed from that obligation, I should never use it more, nor did I use it, until some were offended with me, & blamed me for my neglect of them. And for that other, whom he mentions, who before this, gave so far place to indignation, as to insinuate some such thing, I doubt not but by this time he hath been convinced of his mistake therein, being a Person of another manner of ability and worth, then some others, with whom I have to do; and the truth is, my manner of dealing with him in my last reply, which I have since my self not so well approved of, requires the passing by such returns. But you will say then why do I preface this discourse, with that Expression; with thanks for the civility of the enquiry in the manner of it's expression? I say! this will discover the iniquity of this Author's procedure, in this particular: His enquiry ⟨p. 99⟩was, whether I did not in my Conscience think that there were no true Churches in England, until the Brownists our Fathers, the Anabaptists our elder brothers, and our selves arose, and gathered new Churches; without once taking notice, or mentioning his titles that he says he gave me, I used the words, in a sense obvious to every man's first consideration, as a reproof of the expressions mentioned;
Let this Reverend Authour, make what use of it he please, I cannot but againe tell him, that these things become neither him, nor any man professing the Religion of Jesus Christ, or that hath any respect to truth or sobriety; can any man thinke, that in his conscience, he gives any credit to the insinuation which here he makes, that I should thanke him for calling me Reverend Authour, or Reverend Doctor, or be troubled for his not useing those expressions? Can the mind of an honest man be thought to be conversant with such meane and low thoughts? for the Title of Reverend, I doe give him notice that I have very little valued it, ever since I have considered the saying of Luther; Nunquam periclitatur Religio nisi inter Reverendissimos. So that he may as to me forbeare it for the future, and call me, as the Quakers doe, and it shall suffice. And for that of Doctor; it was conferred on me by the University in my absence, ⟨p. 98⟩and against my consent, as they have expressed it under their publicke seale: nor doth any thing but gratitude, and respect unto them, make me once own it; and freed from that obligation, I should never use it more, nor did I use it, untill some were offended with me, & blamed me for my neglect of them. And for that other, whom he mentions, who before this, gave so farre place to indignation, as to infinuate some such thing, I doubt not but by this time he hath beene convinced of his mistake therein, being a Person of another manner of ability and worth, then some others, with whom I have to doe; and the truth is, my manner of dealing with him in my last reply, which I have since my selfe not so well approved of, requires the passing by such returnes. But you will say then why doe I preface this discourse, with that Expression; with thankes for the civility of the enquiry in the manner of it's expression? I say! this will discover the iniquity of this Authour's procedure, in this particular: His enquiry ⟨p. 99⟩was, whether I did not in my Conscience think that there were no true Churches in England, untill the Brownists our Fathers, the Anabaptists our elder brothers, and our selves arose, and gathered new Churches; without once taking notice, or mentioning his titles that he sayes he gave me, I used the words, in a sense obvious to every man's first consideration, as a reproofe of the expressions mentioned;
that which was the true cause of my words our Author hides in an &c: that which was not by me once taken notice of, is by him expressed; to serve an end of drawing forth an evil surmise and suspicion, that hath not the least colour to give it countenance; Passing by all indifferent Readers, I refer the honesty of this dealing with me, to the judgment of his own conscience; setting down, what I neither expressed, nor took notice of, nor had any singular occasion in that place so to do, the words being often used by him, hiding, and concealing what I did take notice of, and express, and which to every man's ⟨p. 100⟩view was the occasion of that passage, that conclusion or unworthy insinuation is made, which a Good man ought to have abhorred.
that which was the true cause of my words our Authour hides in an &c: that which was not by me once taken notice of, is by him expressed; to serve an end of drawing forth an evill surmize and suspition, that hath not the least colour to give it countenance; Passing by all indifferent Readers, I referre the honesty of this dealing with me, to the judgment of his owne conscience; setting downe, what I neither expressed, nor tooke notice of, nor had any singular occasion in that place so to doe, the words being often used by him, hiding, and concealing what I did take notice of, and expresse, and which to every man's ⟨p. 100⟩view was the occasion of that passage, that conclusion or unworthy insinuation is made, which a Good man ought to have abhorred.
Sundry other particulars there are, partly false, and calumniating, partly impertinent, partly consisting in mistakes, that I thought at the first view, to have made mention of; but on several accounts, I am rather willing here to put an end to the Readers trouble, and my own.
Sundry other particulars there are, partly false, and calumniating, partly impertinent, partly consisting in mistakes, that I thought at the first view, to have made mention of; but on severall accounts, I am rather willing here to put an end to the Readers trouble, and my owne.
The Preface.
THE Servants of the Lord (saith Paul) must not strive, but be Gentile towards all men, 2 Tim. 2. 24. how much more towards their Brethren? But what if a Brother, should become an Adversary (whether Adversarius lit is, or Personae,) and speak hard words, yea and write a Book against his fellow Servants? Job telleth us, though he could, yet he would not speak as they do, Job. 16. 4, 5. And for the book against him, He would take it and bind it upon his shoulder, And yet I do not think he meant to cast it behind his Back, but that he would bear it as a light load, and in case ⟨p. 2⟩of his Innocency, He would we are it as his Crown: And for that end, would declare unto Him the Number of his steps, Job. 31. 35, 36, 37? Yea though such a Book might seem to Impartial and Judicious minds written with a Spirit of Bitterness, and contempt, and in a Style suitable, yet the Servants of the Lord have not so learned Christ, nor the Truth (as it is in Jesus) as to Return Evil for Evil, or Reviling for Reviling. Hard words are not Given, but as the Lord commandeth, if not in his Ordinances, yet in his Providence: And either they are Deserved, & then they are an excellent Balm which will not break the head: or undeserved, and then the Lord will Requite Good to him that suffereth evil. It is no new Thing for God's own Servants to be taken with Paroxysms (as Paul and Barnabas were, Act. 15.) that is, with Pangs of Passion, And that is the worst I conceive of the tartest Passages of Mr Cawdryes Reply. For I see by his ⟨p. 3⟩dealing with Mr Hooker, that he can write with more meekness, and moderation, when the Lord helpeth him: Let me therefore briefly give Account of such Passages of mine, as have seemed most offensive to Him: and that in such terms, as may not unbeseem either my self, or the cause.
THE Servants of the Lord (saith Paul) must not strive, but be Gentile towards all men, 2 Tim. 2. 24. how much more towards their Brethren? But what if a Brother, should become an Adversary (whether Adversarius lit is, or Personae,) and speak hard words, yea and write a Booke against his fellow Servants? Job telleth us, though he could, yet he would not speak as they doe, Job. 16. 4, 5. And for the book against him, He would take it and bind it upon his shoulder, And yet I doe not think he meant to cast it behind his Backe, but that he would bearé it as a light loade, and in case ⟨p. 2⟩of his Innocency, He would we are it as his Crowne: And for that end, would declare unto Him the Number of his steps, Job. 31. 35, 36, 37? Yea though such a Booke might seeme to Impartiall and Judicious mindes written with a Spirit of Bitternesse, and contempt, and in a Style suitable, yet the Servants of the Lord have not so learned Christ, nor the Truth (as it is in Jesus) as to Returne Evill for Evill, or Reviling for Reviling. Hard words are not Given, but as the Lord commandeth, if not in his Ordinances, yet in his Providence: And either they are Deserved, & then they are an excellent Balme which will not break the head: or undeserved, and then the Lord will Requite Good to him that suffereth evill. It is no new Thing for God's owne Servants to be taken with Paroxismes (as Paul and Barnabas were, Act. 15.) that is, with Pangs of Passion, And that is the worst I conceive of the tartest Passages of Mr Cawdryes Reply. For I see by his ⟨p. 3⟩dealing with Mr Hooker, that he can write with more meeknesse, and moderation, when the Lord helpeth him: Let me therefore briefly give Account of such Passages of mine, as have seemed most offensive to Him: and that in such termes, as may not unbeseeme either my selfe, or the cause.
CHAP. 1.
THE first offence he taketh, is against my Inconstancy, and (that which is the fruit of it) my manifest and manifold Contradictions to my self to the number of about 21: Inconstancy in the general He Intimateth in the Text of James in his Frontispiece, James 1. 8.
THE first offence he taketh, is against my Inconstancy, and (that which is the fruit of it) my manifest and manifold Contradictions to my selfe to the number of about 21: Inconstancy in the generall He Intimateth in the Text of James in his Frontispiece, James 1. 8.