I answer; First, a general confession may be a sound confession; It is one thing not to express particular sins, with the circumstances of those sins, and another thing purposely to conceal them. I grant, implicit confession may be as dangerous as implicit faith. And to dig in the earth, and hide our sins in the Napkin of our excuses, is worse than to hide our Talents in the Napkin of our idleness. And as it is most dangerous, knowingly to conceal sin from God, so it is very dangerous to do it through ignorance or inadvertency; Some confess sin in general terms only, because they know not what their sins are, or have quite forgot them; As Nebuchadnezzar called the Astrologers, and Sorcerers, and Chaldeans, and told them he had dreamed a dream, but he could not tell what it was, For the thing was gone from him, Dan. 2. 5. Some such there are, who can, or, will only say, They have sinned, they have sinned; but what, they cannot tell, or they do not remember, Those things are gone from them. That which is written of the learned Bellarmine, a great Cardinal, and a Champion for Auricular, particular Confession of sin to man, seems very strange, That when he lay upon his death-bed, and the Priest after the Popish manner, came to absolve him, he had nothing to confess: at last he thought of some sleight extravagances of his youth, which was all he had to say of his own miscarriages: We see a man may de a Scholar in all the knowledge of the world, of nature, and of Scripture, and yet not know his own heart, nor be studied or read in himself. He that is so, in a spiritual notion, can never want particular matter in his most innocent days to confess before the Lord, and to shame himself for. What though he hath escaped the pollutions of the world, and is cleansed from the filthiness of the flesh? yet he knows that still in his flesh there dwells no good thing, and that in his spirit, there are, at least touches of, many spiritual filthinesses, as pride, unbelief, &c. besides his great deficiencies in every duty, and in his love to Jesus Christ, which is the ground of all. So then, in any of these senses, to confess sin only in general, is a sinful confession. And yet Job made a holy confession here, and so did the Publican ⟨p. 680⟩(Luk. 18.) when he smote his breast and said only thus, God be merciful to me a sinner.
I answer; First, a general confession may be a sound confession; It is one thing not to express particular sins, with the circumstances of those sins, and another thing purposely to conceale them. I grant, implicit confession may be as dangerous as implicit faith. And to digg in the earth, and hide our sins in the Napkin of our excuses, is worse than to hide our Talents in the Napkin of our idleness. And as it is most dangerous, knowingly to conceale sin from God, so it is very dangerous to do it through ignorance or inadvertency; Some confess sin in general termes only, because they know not what their sins are, or have quite forgot them; As Nebuchadnezzar called the Astrologers, and Sorcerers, and Chaldeans, and told them he had dreamed a dreame, but he could not tell what it was, For the thing was gone from him, Dan. 2. 5. Some such there are, who can, or, will only say, They have sinned, they have sinned; but what, they cannot tell, or they doe not remember, Those things are gone from them. That which is written of the learned Bellarmine, a great Cardinal, and a Champion for Auricular, particular Confession of sinne to man, seemes very strange, That when he lay upon his death-bed, and the Priest after the Popish manner, came to absolve him, he had nothing to confess: at last he thought of some sleight extravagancies of his youth, which was all he had to say of his owne miscarriages: We see a man may de a Schollar in all the knowledg of the world, of nature, and of Scripture, and yet not know his own heart, nor be studied or read in himself. He that is so, in a spiritual notion, can never want particular matter in his most innocent daies to confesse before the Lord, and to shame himselfe for. What though he hath escaped the pollutions of the world, and is cleansed from the filthiness of the flesh? yet he knowes that still in his flesh there dwels no good thing, and that in his spirit, there are, at least touches of, many spiritual filthinesses, as pride, unbelief, &c. besides his great deficiencies in every duty, and in his love to Jesus Christ, which is the ground of all. So then, in any of these sences, to confesse sin only in general, is a sinful confession. And yet Job made a holy confession here, and so did the Publican ⟨p. 680⟩(Luk. 18.) when he smote his breast and said onely thus, God be merciful to me a sinner.