1Secondly, It is reported, that some Whales, or Whales in some parts of the world, have huge scales. There was seen cast up upon the sea-shore (saith one) a monstrous fish, of fifty cubits long, which had scales all over of a cubit thick. These were strong scales indeed: and though we have not known or heard of any such in these parts of the world, yet who can say knowingly there are none such in any part of the world, as literally answer the description of Leviathans scales. I grant, that the three exceptions, which Bochartus takes against the testimony of Nearchus are very considerable. First, That he stands alone, and is but a single witness. Secondly. That he doth not say he saw such a whale, but only heard it of certain Mariners, who said they saw such a one; which sort of men are not always to be credited. And he adds, Thirdly, That though Nearchus should have said, that himself had seen such a Whale, yet little credit were to be given him, he being an Author of no good credit. These considerations, I confess, may somewhat weaken the testimony of Nearchus; yet I see no reason, why they should utterly infringe and disable it. For, first, one man may speak truth in it self, as well as two or three, though the testimony of one be not so authentic to others, as the testimony of two or three. Secondly, though some Mariners over-reach in their reports, yet it doth not follow that they did so from whom that report came. And, Thirdly, Though Nearchus be justly charged with failing, and falseness in some things, yet none can say, his whole book is nothing else but a bundle of lies. And if there be any truths in his writings, as, I suppose, no man will deny, but there are many; then why this report of a Whale, or mighty fish, of that kind, with great scales, may not be reckoned among the truths contained in his writings, rather than among the lies, let the Reader judge.
1Secondly, It is reported, that some Whales, or Whales in some parts of the world, have huge scales. There was seen cast up upon the sea-shore (saith one) a monstrous fish, of fifty cubits long, which had scales all over of a cubit thick. These were strong scales indeed: and though we have not known or heard of any such in these parts of the world, yet who can say knowingly there are none such in any part of the world, as literally answer the description of Leviathans scales. I grant, that the three exceptions, which Bochartus takes against the testimony of Nearchus are very considerable. First, That he stands alone, and is but a single witness. Secondly. That he doth not say he saw such a whale, but only heard it of certain Mariners, who said they saw such a one; which sort of men are not always to be credited. And he adds, Thirdly, That though Nearchus should have said, that himself had seen such a Whale, yet little credit were to be given him, he being an Author of no good credit. These considerations, I confess, may somewhat weaken the testimony of Nearchus; yet I see no reason, why they should utterly infringe and disable it. For, first, one man may speak truth in it self, as well as two or three, though the testimony of one be not so authentick to others, as the testimony of two or three. Secondly, •hough some Mariners over-reach in their repo•ts, yet it doth not follow that they did so from whom that report came. And, Thirdly, Though Nearchus be justly charged with failing, and falseness in some things, yet none can say, his whole book is nothing else but a bundle of lies. And if there be any truths in his writings, as, I suppose, no man will deny, but there are many; then why this report of a Whale, or mighty fish, of that kind, with great scales, may not be reckoned among the truths contained in his writings, rather than among the lies, let the Reader judge.
- 1Quot ei squamae tot clypei quibus adversus omnem vim togitur. Arianus memorat ex Nearcho visum cetum in littus ejectum cubitorum quinquaginta corio squamoso tam crasso, ut cubitum aquaret.