Here was not only the reality of repentance, but the ceremony of it. There are many outward signs of repentance spoken of in Scripture: Such are, First, Smiting upon the thigh; thus Ephraim is described repenting (Jerem. 31.19.) Secondly, Smiting upon the breast; so the Publican is described repenting (Luke 18.13.) He smote upon his breast, and said, God be merciful to me a sinner. Thirdly, Laying aside our ornaments; thus the Lord commanded the Israelites (Exod. 33.5.) Put off thy ornaments from thee, that I may know to do unto thee; as if God had said, humble thy self openly and repent. Fourthly, The putting on of sack-cloth; this the Jews were called to do (Isa. 22.12.) Fifthly, Holding down the head. The Jews (Isa. 58.5.) were not reproved for doing that, but because they did it like a bull-rush, only when a storm was upon them: Sixthly, Renting the garment, and walking softly. So did Ahab (1 Kings 21.27.) Seventhly, as in the text Job saith he did, sitting in dust and ashes. I do not say these, or the like, are absolutely necessary to repentance, but they are lawful, and have their use. When ⟨p. 848⟩the Prophet (Joel 2.13.) said, Rent your hearts, not your garments, that is, rent your hearts, rather than your garments; it was not a prohibition, but a direction: or if rent your garments, be sure you rent your hearts also, else all your outward modes of repentance are in vain and insignificant.1 Some Popish Writers make the essence of repentance to consist in these or such like outward signs; but though we deny that, yet we grant these may be signs of true repentance: For as to bow the knee is not to pray, although he that prayeth usually boweth the knees, as a sign of an humble heart in prayer; so to sit in the dust and weep, is not to repent, although the truly penitent, usually do so. The essence of repentance consists in a broken heart for sin, and in breaking off the course and custom of sin, turning to God fully.
Here was not only the reallity of repentance, but the ceremony of it. There are many outward signs of repentance spoken of in Scripture: Such are, First, Smiting upon the thigh; thus Ephraim is described repenting (Jerem. 31.19.) Secondly, Smiting upon the breast; so the Publican is described repenting (Luke 18.13.) He smote upon his breast, and said, God be merciful to me a sinner. Thirdly, Laying aside our ornaments; thus the Lord commanded the Israelites (Exod. 33.5.) Put off thy ornaments from thee, that I may know to do unto thee; as if God had said, humble thy self openly and repent. F•urthly, The putting on of sack-cloth; this the Jews were called to do (Isa. 22.12.) Fifthly, Holding down the head. The Jews (Isa. 58.5.) were not reproved for doing that, but because they did it like a bull-rush, only when a storm was upon them: Sixthly, Renting the garment, and walking softly. So did Ahab (1 Kings 21.27.) Seventhly, as in the text Job saith he did, sitting in dust and ashes. I do not say these, or the like, are absolutely necessary to repentance, but they are lawful, and have their use. When ⟨p. 848⟩the Prophet (Joel 2.13.) said, Rent your hearts, not your garments, that is, rent your hearts, rather than your garments; it was not a prohibition, but a direction: or if rent your garments, be sure you rent your hearts also, else all your outward modes of repentance are in vain and insignificant.1 Some Popish Writers make the essence of repentance to consist in these or such like outward signs; but though we deny that, yet we grant these may be signs of true repentance: For as to bow the knee is not to pray, although he that prayeth usually boweth the knees, as a sign of an humble heart in prayer; so to sit in the dust and weep, is not to repent, although the truly penitent, usually do so. The essence of repentance consists in a broken heart for sin, and in breaking off the course and custome of sin, turning to God fully.
- 1Bellarminus l. 1. de poenitentio c. 7. SS. percurramus.