Secondly, Supposing, that men agree in that same supreme government, to wit, Councils and Synods, there1 may be some debate concerning the formal constitution thereof, what is to be accounted a rightly constitute Synod, and such as ought to be acknowledged so? It cannot be denied, but that there is a right and a wrong in this, and that there are rules to be kept, and that also de facto they may be broken, even where there is no failing in the matter. It is true also, that we will sometimes find worthy men quarrelling the constitution of Synods, and declining them, as was formerly hinted, refusing to appear before them, till some persons were removed from them, as Chrysostom and forty two Bishops with him, did in reference to that particular Synod at Chalcedon: and sometimes their Acts were declared void, because the meetings were not numerous, as Balsamon doth instance in the case of one Johannes Amathuntus, whose deposition was declared null, because all the Bishops of Cyprus were not convened to his trial, which might have been; and because, in strict reckoning, there was one fewer at his deposition than was allowed by the Canons. Yet concerning this we say, 1. That it will be found2 very difficult to pitch on such defects in the constitution of a Synod, as will make the same null without respect to the matter thereof▪ seeing there may be many defects that will not infer this. 2. It will be hard to gather from Church-history, or Writings of the Ancients, or Canons of Councils, what hath been a peremptory rule to them to walk by in such a case. Their3 practices in this are so various, that it appeareth, the matter hath ever been more headed by them▪ than the formality of the constitution. And therefore, 3. We will find their practice to be according to this; When the matter was sound and profitable, it was accepted, and the Synod was reverenced, although it hath had ⟨p. 374⟩less formality, and hath been of a fewer number; So the Council of Sardica, Laodicea, and some particular Provincial Synods, have ever been of great authority because of their matter, when more numerous Synods, with moe formalities, have never been so accounted of, nor reckoned amongst the General Councils, although their number hath been far greater than many of these other. 4.
Secondly, Supposing, that men agree in that same supream government, to wit, Councils and Synods, there1 may be some debate concerning the formal constitution thereof, what is to be accounted a rightly constitute Synod, and such as ought to be acknowledged so? It cannot be denied, but that there is a right and a wrong in this, and that there are rules to be keeped, and that also de facto they may be broken, even where there is no failing in the mater. It is true also, that we will sometimes find worthie men quarrelling the constitution of Synods, and declining them, as was formerly hinted, refusing to appear before them, till some persons were removed from them, as Chrysostom and fourty two Bishops with him, did in reference to that particular Synod at Chalcedon: and sometimes their Acts were declared void, because the meetings were not numerous, as Balsamon doth instance in the case of one Iohannes Amathuntus, whose deposition was declared null, because all the Bishops of Cyprus were not conveened to his tryall, which might have been; and because, in strict reckoning, there was one fewer at his deposition than was allowed by the Canons. Yet concerning this we say, 1. That it will be found2 very difficult to pitch on such defects in the constitution of a Synod, as will make the same null without respect to the matter thereof▪ seing there may be many defects that will not infer this. 2. It will be hard to gather from Church-history, or Writings of the Ancients, or Canons of Councils, what hath been a peremptory rule to them to walk by in such a case. Their3 practices in this are so various, that it appeareth, the matter hath ever been more headed by them▪ than the formality of the constitution. And therefore, 3. We will find their practice to be according to this; When the matter was sound and profitable, it was accepted, and the Synod was reverenced, although it hath had ⟨p. 374⟩lesse formality, and hath been of a fewer number; So the Council of Sardica, Laodicea, and some particular Provincial Synods, have ever been of great authority because of their matter, when more numerous Synods, with moe formalities, have never been so accounted of, nor reckoned amongst the General Councils, although their number hath been far greater than many of these other. 4.
- 1Debates about the constitution of Synods.
- 2Defects in constitution cannot easily annul without defect in the matter.Defects in constitution cannot easily annull without defect in the matter.
- 3In ancient Councels soundness of matter more regarded than formality or number.In ancient Councels soundnesse of matter more regarded than formality or number.