A37049:322
London: printed for Dorman Newman, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In answering this question, 1. We shall clear that there may be, and is Idolatry committed with Images, and means of Gods service, even in such worship wherein the Images which men worship are not accounted gods, but only representations of God, and although these means of worship, which they worship are made use of in serving the true God. 2. We shall clear, that all such service, as being Idolatry is forbidden by this command, however it be distinguished. If it be performed as religious service, though some such service be more gross, and other some more subtle and refined.
First then, That there is such a kind of Idolatry in worshipping of Images, when men rest not on the Images, but direct their worship to the God represented by them, we may clear it divers ways.
First then, That there is such a kind of Idolatry in worshipping of Images, when men rest not on the Images, but direct their worship to the God represented by them, we may clear it divers wayes.
And 1. From the Heathens, who though some did, yet all of them did not account their Images their gods, but only some representation of them, and first we may gather this from, Rom. 1.22, 23. where it is said of them, 1. That they knew God, and yet 2. That they turned the glory of that incorruptible God into the similitude of Beasts and men, corruptible creatures. Their fault is not that they accounted these representations or Images, which they made gods, but that they declined in their worship, in the worshipping of the true God by such Images.
And 1. From the Heathens, who though some did, yet all of them did not accotnt their Images their gods, but only some representation of them, and first we may gather this from, Rom. 1.22, 23. where it is said of them, 1. That they knew God, and yet 2. That they turned the glory of that incorruptible God into the similitude of Beasts and men, corruptible creatures. Their fault is not that they accounted these representations or Images, which they made gods, but that they declined in their worship, in the worshipping of the true God by such Images.
2. It may also appear by the frequent changes of their Images, while they retained their former gods, and by their multiplying Images of one sort, and divers sorts to one and the same god, and by their giving all these Images one name, and when it is said that Solomon and other Kings set up Images to Asht •roth, Baal, &c. It cannot be thought they supposed these Images to be the very gods themselves which they worshipped, but that they were only set up for their honour, Kings 23.13. And when Manasseh made Chariots to the Sun, he supposed them not to be to the Sun, 2 King. 23.11. Yea was not this commonly acknowledged that Jupiter was in heaven, as appeareth Acts 19.39. and that that Image came down from him, but was not he, nor yet the feigned Goddess Diana.
2. It may also appear by the frequent changes of their Images, while they retained their former gods, and by their multiplying Images of one sort, and divers sorts to one and the same god, and by their giving all these Images one name, and when it is said that Solomon and other Kings set up Images to Asht •roth, Baal, &c. It cannot be thought they supposed these Images to be the very gods themselves which they worshipped, but that they were only set up for their honour, Kings 23.13. And when Manasses made Chariots to the Sun, he supposed them not to be to the Sun, 2 King. 23.11. Yea was not this commonly acknowledged that Jupiter was in heaven, as appeareth Acts 19.39. and that that Image came down from him, but was not he, nor yet the feigned Goddess Diana.
3. It may appear by the Heathens own confession, and the shifts they used, when they were charged with the worshipping the works of their hands, as 1. They used to say they worshipped but the Numen or god which was in them, and which invisibly after their dedication of them (and not before) dwelt in them; yea, some of them would say, they neither worshipped that Image, nor any devil, but by a bodily sign they beheld what they should worship. 3. When Christians further urged them, that what was signified by their Images was not the true God, but a creature, as by Neptune, the Sea; by Vulcan, the Fire, &c. They reply •d it was not those bodies which they worshipped, but the gods which governed them. So Augustine, Psal. 113. nobis 115 concerning the Idols of the Gentiles, and Augustine de Civitat. Dei lib. 7. cap. 5. where he showeth that Varro giveth that reason, why the gods where rather portrayed in mans picture (though they were invisible) because, saith he, mans Soul is a spirit and cometh nearest them, and the body is the vessel of the Soul, and therefore is used to represent it. See Chrysost. 1. Eph. Hom. 18. Andrews on 2. Command. August. in Psal. 96 (nobis) 97.
3. It may appear by the Heathens own confession, and the shifts they used, when they were charged with the worshipping the works of their hands, as 1. They used to say they worshipped but the Numen or god which was in them, and which invisibly after their dedication of them (and not before) dwelt in them; yea, some of them would say, they neither worshipped that Image, nor any devil, but by a bodily sign they beheld what they should worship. 3. When Christians further urged them, that what was signified by their Images was not the true God, but a creature, as by Neptune, the Sea; by Vulcan, the Fire, &c. They reply •d it was not those bodies which they worshipped, but the gods which governed them. So Augustine, Psal. 113. nobis 115 concerning the Idols of the Gentiles, and Augustine de Civitat. Dei lib. 7. cap. 5. where he sheweth that Varro giveth that reason, why the gods where rather pourtrayed in mans picture (though they were invisible) because, saith he, mans Soul is a spirit and cometh nearest them, and the body is the vessel of the Soul, and therefore is used to represent it. See Chrysost. 1. Eph. Hom. 18. Andrews on 2. Command. August. in
And it may also 4. appear from this, That the Heathen gods for the most part (even those of them that were most commonly worshipped) were some famous men, after death supposed to be Deified, to whom they made statues and Images, and yet still the honour was intended to those to whom they appointed the Images, though they supposed that their gods in an especial manner dwelt in these Images, and answered from them.
In the second place this may be made to appear from the Command, Deut. 12.31. where the Lord forbiddeth not only the worshipping of Idols, but of himself by Images, Thou shalt not do so to the Lord thy God, that is thou shalt not worship me by Images as the Heathen do their gods, and therefore this is not only possible, but is also, and that most certainly, a grievous guilt, even though they pretended it was not Idols but God they worshipped; yet it was not so they worshipped not him but the Idol.
In the second place this may be made to appear from the Command, Deut. 12.31. where the Lord forbiddeth not onely the worshipping of Idols, but of himself by Images, Thou shalt not do so to the Lord thy God, that is thou shalt not worship me by Images as the Heathen do their gods, and therefore this is not only possible, but is also, and that most certainly, a grievious guilt, even though they pretended it was not Idols but God they worshipped; yet it was not so they worshipped not him but the Idol.
3. We shall clear it yet further, That the true God may be worshipped (by Idolaters) as they pretend, and yet in Gods account their worship is nothing but Idolatry committed with their Images.
We shall give four instances of this. The first is from Exodus 32. where it is clear, 1. That the image they set up was not it self acknowledged to be God, but as something to represent the true God, for 1. It cannot be thought their minds were so soon darkened as altogether to forget what God had done, and to imagine that the thing which was new made with hands was God, though they be charged with forgetting God, because they were practical forgetters of him, and their sin did speak it out indeed. 2. The image is called Jehovah that brought them out of Egypt, which was a mercy past before the Calf had a being, and therefore the reason why they gave it this name, must certainly be, because they aimed by it to represent Jehovah. 3. It is not likely that now they would have worshipped the gods of Egypt, or that they would have attributed their delivery from Egypt to them, seeing these gods were also plagued; also that Aaron should do so is incredible, who yet joined with them in this transgression. 4. Beside can it be thought, that so soon they thought it to be God, and yet so easily afterwards passed from it? certainly the words, That it may go before us, that is, not to Egypt, but Canaan, whether God called them, do clearly imply, that they looked on it only as a representation of Jehovah.
We shall give four instances of this. The first is from Exodus 32. where it is clear, 1. That the image they set up was not it self acknowledged to be God, but as something to represent the true God, for 1. It cannot be thought their minds were so soon darkened as altogether to forget what God had done, and to imagine that the thing which was new made with hands was God, though they be charged with forgetting God, because they were practical forgetters of him, and their sin did speak it out indeed. 2. The image is called Jehovah that brought them out of Egypt, which was a mercy past before the Calf had a being, and therefore the reason why they gave it this name, must certainly be, because they aimed by it to represent Jehovah. 3. It is not likely that now they would have worshipped the gods of Egypt, or that they would have attributed their delivery from Egypt to them, seeing these gods were also plagued; also that Aaron should do so is incredible, who yet joyned with them in this transgression. 4. Beside can it be thought, that so soon they thought it to be God, and yet so easily afterwards passed from it? certainly the words, That it may go before us, that is, not to Egypt, but Canaan, whether God called them, do clearly imply, that they looked on it only as a representation of Jehovah.
2. It is clear that they sacrificed burnt Offerings and peace Offerings before this image, and this was the same service which was due to the Lord, and so it was proclaimed, Exod. 32.5. and therefore it was to the Lord, and not to the image (for it self) that they sacrificed.
3. It is clear that they are charged for turning out of the way, and that because of their making a molten image, which seemeth to infer, that their guilt was rather in the manner of worship and making of that image for worship •, than in quitting God altogether; and thus they grossly failed in the manner of worshipping him, by occ •si •n of Moses his absence, for now they want that sign of Gods presence, which formerly they had, and have not such a visible commerce (as it were) with God, it is that they complain of. and this want of a visible sign (and not of God simply) do they intend to make up by this image.
3. It is clear that they are charged for turning out of the way, and that because of their making a molten image, which seemeth to infer, that their guilt was rather in the manner of worship and making of that image for worship •, than in quitting God altogether; and thus they grosly failed in the manner of worshipping him, by occ •si •n of Moses his absence, for now they want that sign of Gods presence, which formerly they had, and have not such a visible commerce (as it were) with God, it is that they complain of. and this want of a visible sign (and not of God simply) do they intend to make up by this image.
4. This may be further confirmed from Acts 7.40, 41, 42. where it is said, that because of this si • they were given up to gross idolatry which could not be, had this been idolatry of the grosses • sort.
The Second instance is from Judges 17. where you will find that that Idol, which Micah made is not by him or his Mother accounted God, but is made use of by them, as they think, for furthering them in Gods service, as appeareth, 1. From this, that it getteth not the name of any strange god. 2. That he seeketh a Levite for a Priest to it, and promiseth to himself Gods blessing from that, not that the Idol would bless him, but Jehovah, ver. 13. 3. That it is said, the Priest asked counsel of Jehovah for the Danites, Judges 18.6.
The Third instance is that of Jeroboam, who did sin and made Israel to sin, by the Calf he set up at Dan and Bethel, that they were not intended to be worshipped as Idols, for themselves, but as means, whereby they might be helped to worship the true God, may appear, 1. From Jeroboam's motive, which was not to divert the people from the true God, at least as he supposed, or to make them alter their God, but to alter their manner of worship, and to divert them from going up to Jerusalem to worship, from which his fear of their revolt to Rehoboam arose; hence the Calves are not provided to prevent worshipping of God, but are put in place of their going up to Jerusalem; as the colour of reason pretended by him for this alteration showeth; and so one service is ⟨p. 64⟩put for another, without changing their God, and all the reproofs that his sins meeteth with from the Prophets run at this, that he altered the manner of Gods worship in putting up new signs in new places, and appointing new sacrifices and Priests. 2. It appeareth from this, that as it was distinct from that way of serving God, which was in Judah, so was it from the way of the Heathens, yea from the way used by such idolatrous Kings as Ahab, who are said to do worse; because they did set up strange gods (which the Calves are not called) and Baalim; and Jehu when he destroyed the false Gods, yet he retained this manner of Worship; and there were no cause to discriminate Jeroboam's sin from Achabs, or to look upon it as any thing lesser, if all the difference had been only in the change of worshipping the image of one Idol into the worshipping of the image of another, but the difference was in this, that the one worshipped the true God in these images, the other Idols indeed. 3. Hence there was still some knowledge of God in that land, and Prophets sometimes sent them by the Lord, yea when they were led captive, and others sent into their place, it is said 2 Kings 17.26. &c. They learned the manner of the god of the land, that is th • true God though they corrupted themselves with serving their Idols also, and thus the Samaritans continued worshipping they knew not what, though they pretended to worship the true God, John 4.22.
The Third instance is that of Jeroboam, who did sin and made Israel to sin, by the Calf he set up at Dan and Bethel, that they were not intended to be worshipped as Idols, for themselves, but as means, whereby they might be helped to worship the true God, may appear, 1. From Jeroboams motive, which was not to divert the people from the true God, at least as he supposed, or to make them alter their God, but to alter their manner of worship, and to divert them from going up to Jerusalem to worship, from which his fear of their revolt to Rehoboam arose; hence the Calves are not provided to prevent worshipping of God, but are put in place of their going up to Jerusalem; as the colour of reason pretended by him for this alteration sheweth; and so one service is
The Fourth instance is that corrupt practice used sometimes in Judah of setting up high places and groves, when yet they did not th •reby intend to serve Idols, but the true God, and yet they are reproved for this as a gross Corrupting of the worship of God.
And it would seem clear sometimes in Judah and often in Israel, even when they are charged with idolatry, that yet the knowledge of the true God, was not obliterate among them, nor they so brutish in their worship as other Nations about them; we take it then for a clear truth, that they often did worship the true God, by images, when they did not worship the images directly.
And it would seem clear sometimes in Judah and often in Israel, even when they are charged with idolatry, that yet the knowledge of the true God, was not obliterate among them, nor they so bruitish in their worship as other Nations about them; we take it then for a clear truth, that they often did worship the true God, by images, when they did not worship the images directly.