Reply. This Proposition may not be granted. For, 1. It granteth the privilege of Church-membership to such as are not actually and regularly Church-members, which is contrary to Christs Ordinance, whereby Baptism, being a public Church-Ordinance, is due only to them who have a public state and Interest, such are only the Members of the public Ecclesiastical Body, the Church. Hence 1. An ordinary Minister cannot orderly perform an act proper to his Office, in reference to Church-communion, to any that are not regularly and actually Members of the visible Church, without great usurpation: as, if a man do a work proper to Magistracy, to one that is not under his Magistratical Power, he is an Usurper. So it is in this case of a Minister. To administer Baptism, is an act of his Office-power: If he administer Baptism to children, whose Parents are not regularly in Church-order; in so doing, why may not the Lord say, He is an Usurper? Suppose an unbaptized person, professing his Faith, and qualified according to the description in the sixth Proposition; yet deferring, for some probable causes, to adjoin himself to the Church, for the present, should desire Baptism of any of these Ministers who framed this Proposition; Should they administer ⟨p. 47⟩it to him, and so do a proper work of their Office upon him? If yea; if they admit him to Baptism, why not to the Lords Supper, and to the choice of Officers, and to the Censures of the Church, either actively or passively? for all these are Actions and Ordinances of one general nature: and it is merely his want of Church-order that debars him from them. 2. The Church may not receive into any privilege of Church-communion, such as Baptism is, (whatever cause they seem to have, in the judgement of charity, to think them fit for Church-membership, and such as had they been called, would have so acted) until they be actually in public Church-order; no more then the children of every good Subject of the King, may be admitted into the special Prerogatives of a Corporation, whereof themselves, or their next Parents are not regularly free. All things must be done in order, 1 Co•. 14.40. whereunto, what is more contrary, then that he, who is not regularly and personally of a public Society, should have Fellowship in a public Privilege, proper to that Society? Yet they say this, which the Proposition holds forth, is manifest:
Reply. This Proposition may not be granted. For, 1. It granteth the priviledge of Church-membership to such as are not actually and regularly Church-members, which is contrary to Christs Ordinance, whereby Baptism, being a publick Church-Ordinance, is due onely to them who have a publick state and Interest, such are onely the Members of the publick Ecclesiastical Body, the Church. Hence 1. An ordinary Minister cannot orderly perform an act proper to his Office, in reference to Church-communion, to any that are not regularly and actually Members of the visible Church, without great usurpation: as, if a man do a work proper to Magistracy, to one that is not under his Magistratical Power, he is an Usurper. So it is in this case of a Minister. To administer Baptism, is an act of his Office-power: If he administer Baptism to children, whose Parents are not regularly in Church-order; in so doing, why may not the Lord say, He is an Usurper? Suppose an unbaptized person, professing his Faith, and qualified according to the description in the sixth Proposition; yet deferring, for some probable causes, to adjoyn himself to the Church, for the present, should desire Baptism of any of these Ministers who framed this Proposition; Should they administer ⟨p. 47⟩it to him, and so do a proper work of their Office upon him? If yea; if they admit him to Baptism, why not to the Lords Supper, and to the choice of Officers, and to the Censures of the Church, either actively or passively? for all these are Actions and Ordinances of one general nature: and it is meerly his want of Church-order that debars him from them. 2. The Church may not receive into any priviledge of Church-communion, such as Baptism is, (whatever cause they seem to have, in the judgement of charity, to think them fit for Church-membership, and such as had they been called, would have so acted) until they be actually in publick Church-order; no more then the children of every good Subject of the King, may be admitted into the special Prerogatives of a Corporation, whereof themselves, or their next Parents are not regularly free. All things must be done in order, 1 Co•. 14.40. whereunto, what is more contrary, then that he, who is not regularly and personally of a publick Society, should have Fellowship in a publick Priviledge, proper to that Society? Yet they say this, which the Proposition holds forth, is manifest: