A37200:190
Another essay for investigation of the truth in answer to two questions concerning I.…
Another essay for investigation of the truth in answer to two questions concerning I. the subject of Baptism, II. the consociation of churches / by John Davenport ...
Cambridge: printed by Samuel Green and Marmaduke Johnson, 1663
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. Though Churches may withdraw from a Church that is obstinate and impenitent in some cases, (without any such solemn sentence of Non-communion declared by a Synod) yet, not for such causes as a delinquent Brother may be Excommunicated by a Church, according to Mat. 18. For there, though the Offence was in some lesser matter, and private between two at first; yet, by obstinacy against convincing light, held forth in those three steps of proceeding, it becomes a public and heinous Scandal, and so the Delinquent must be at last Excommunicated by the command of Christ, and the Sentence of the Church, in obedience to Christ, who hath for such ends given the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven unto them. But Neighbour-Churches may not withdraw from a true Church for every Error and Scandal, though persisted in, and, in their opinion, obstinately. For 1. It may be the Error of Neighbour-Churches, to think that to be light from Scripture, which they hold forth for their conviction, when it is not from Scripture, rightly understood, and rightly applied If the Synod, by whom this Book is published, should conclude any Church to walk in Error, and Scandal, and Obstinately, which shall not be convinced from what light they have here held forth, nor practise accordingly, till what is Replied ad oppositum, be soundly Refuted, and their Allegations and Applications of Scripture, more convincingly and irrefragably cleared, and Withdraw ⟨p. 55⟩communion from them, after the first, second, and third Admonition; and, If any Neighbour-Churches, for this or the like cause, should Withdraw from communion with them, after the Admonition of one Church, and, after that, of other Neighbour-Churches; They should greatly sin in so doing, and act contrary to their own Doctrine in their second Proof of their 7th Proposition for Answer to this second Question, pag. 28. where they say, To refuse communion with a true Church, in lawful and pious actions, is unlawful, and justly accounted Schismatical. For, if the Church be true, Christ holdeth some communion with it; therefore so must we. Now the Churches in New-England were approved by their Neighbour-Churches to be true Churches, by their giving unto them the right hand of fellowship:
3. Though Churches may withdraw from a Church that is obstinate and impenitent in some cases, (without any such solemn sentence of Non-communion declared by a Synod) yet, not for such causes as a delinquent Brother may be Excommunicated by a Church, according to