Reply. I grant, that the Synods Directions and Determinations, so far as consonant to the Word of God, are to be received with reverence and submission. But what if the Members of Churches, to which they are sent, do not find them consonant to the Word rightly understood and applied? Are they nevertheless still bound to practise according to the Synods Directions and Determinations, because the Synod concludeth that they are consonant to the Word? I suppose, no Orthodox Synod, in these times, will arrogate to it self such infallible Assistance, as the Apostles, being assembled with the Church at Jerusalem, had, Acts 15. (though they argued and concluded only from Scripture, yet that Council could not err in their understanding and applying Scripture, having such guides as the Apostles were) but will confess that they may err in their understanding and applying the Scriptures, whereupon they seem to ground their Directions and Determinations. And if so it is the duty of every Church, and the Members thereof, to examine by the Scriptures whatsoever Direction or Determination is propounded by the Synod. If they find that they are consonant to the Word of God, they are bound by Gods Authority to receive them with reverence and submission. If otherwise, wrought to obey God, rather then man, Acts 5.29. 2. This power of the Synod (though they say it is but secondary, and that it is for their agreement with the Word, which is the principal ground thereof, and ⟨p. 63⟩without which their Directions and Determinations bind not at all, yet) they make so binding, that, if any Churches shall refuse to practise according to the Directions and Determinations of the Synod, (though they have strong grounds of dis-satisfaction about the Synods interpretation and application of the Scriptures alleged by them) they will withdraw themselves from communion with them. Whether such an authoritative urging their counsels upon Churches be warranted by Scripture, let the Reader enquire and consider: and, Whether it will agree with what themselves before declared, concerning the unlawfulness of a total Separation from a true Church: and, Whether there be need of it to cure emergent Church-difficulties and differences; seeing all that are godly will readily close with such Directions and Determinations of Synods, as are clearly consonant to the Word of God:
Reply. I grant, that the Synods Directions and Determinations, so farre as consonant to the Word of God, are to be received with reverence and submission. But what if the Members of Churches, to which they are sent, do not finde them consonant to the Word rightly understood and applied? Are they nevertheless still bound to practise according to the Synods Directions and Determinations, because the Synod coucludeth that they are consonant to the Word? I suppose, no Orthodox Synod, in these times, will arrogate to it self such infallible Assistance, as the Apostles, being assembled with the Church at Jerusalem, had, Acts 15. (though they argued and concluded onely from Scripture, yet that Council could not erre in their understanding and applying Scripture, having such guides as the Apostles were) but will confess that they may erre in their understanding and applying the Scriptures, whereupon they seem to g•ound their Directions and Determinations. And if so it is the duty of every Church, and the Members thereof, to examine by the Scriptures whatsoever Direction or Determination is propounded by the Synod. If they finde that they are consonant to the Word of God, they are bound by Gods Authority to receive them with reverence and submission. If otherwise, wrought to obey God, rather then man, Acts 5.29. 2. This power of the Synod (though they say it is but secondary, and that it is for their agreement with the Word, which is the principal ground thereof, and ⟨p. 63⟩without which their Directions and Determinations binde not at all, yet) they make so binding, that, if any Churches shall refuse to practise according to the Directions and Determinations of the Synod, (though they have strong grounds of dis-satisfaction about the Synods interpretation and application of the Scriptures alledged by them) they will withdraw themselves from communion with them. Whether such an authoritative urging their counsels upon Churches be warranted by Scripture, let the Reader enquire and consider: and, Whether it will agree with what themselves before declared, concerning the unlawfulness of a total Separation from a true Church: and, Whether there be need of it to cure emergent Church-difficulties and differences; seeing all that are godly will readily close with such Directions and Determinations of Synods, as are clearly consonant to the Word of God: