A37200:256
Another essay for investigation of the truth in answer to two questions concerning I.…
Another essay for investigation of the truth in answer to two questions concerning I. the subject of Baptism, II. the consociation of churches / by John Davenport ...
Cambridge: printed by Samuel Green and Marmaduke Johnson, 1663
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
VIII. The last Proposition seemeth to open a very wide gate in the Church, wider then God doth allow, Isa. 26.2. for though it requireth qualifications in such Members who claim right to Baptism for their children in other Churches, by virtue of Church-communion, yet it is altogether silent of the qualifications of such Churches themselves, only they must be Orthodox; that respects the Doctrine of Faith alone. There is much more to be attended: A Church may be Orthodox in matters of Faith, yet Scandalous in Practice: A whole Church may be under Scandal, as well as a particular person; and in that case another Church may withdraw from it, and have no communion either with it, or its Members. And this was, not long since, the Judgement and Practice of some of the chief Churches and Elders in the Bay.
VIII. The last Proposition seemeth to open a very wide gate in the Church, wider then God doth allow, Isa. 26.2. for though it requireth qualifications in such Members who claim right to Baptism for their children in other Churches, by virtue of Church-communion, yet it is altogether silent of the qualifications of such Churches themselves, onely they must be Orthodox; that respects the Doctrine of Faith alone. There is much more to be attended: A Church may be Orthodox in matters of Faith, yet Scandalous in Practice: A whole Church may be under Scandal, as well as a particular person; and in that case another Church may withdraw from it, and have no communion either with it, or its Members. And this was, not long since, the Judgement and Practice of some of the chief Churches and Elders in the Bay.
Again, a Church may believe the main Articles of Faith, yet be so defective in Discipline, yea, so opposite to Christs Government, as to lay aside his Laws and Institutions, and set up the Inventions and Traditions of men: And likewise may have such a corrupt Constitution, ⟨p. 71⟩