A42456:204
An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth…
An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth Mr. Wotton, besides his former foul aspersions of heresy and blasphemy, with Arianism, Mr. Gataker with Socinianism, Dr. Gouge and Mr. Downham with a false attestation, Dr. Baylie and Mr. Stock with self-condemnation, all the eight ministers employed in the business between himself and Mr. Wotton with partiality and unjust judgement : upon occasion of a relation concerning that business / written by the said Thomas Gataker and by him now again avowed, wherein the said M. Walkers vindication is in many things showed to be an untrue relation.An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth Mr. Wotton, besides his former foul aspersions of heresie and blasphemy, with Arianism, Mr. Gataker with Socinianism, Dr. Gouge and Mr. Downham with a fase attestation, Dr. Baylie and Mr. Stock with self-condemnation, all the eight ministers employed in the busines between himself and Mr. Wotton with partiality and unjust judgement : upon occasion of a relation concerning that busines / written by the said Thomas Gataker and by him now again avowed, wherein the said M. Walkers vindication is in many things shewed to be an untrue relation.
London: printed by E.G. for F. Clifton, 1642
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Let me give you but M. Wottons own words, out of M. Walkers own Parallel; and there shall need to this no further answer. gHe that believeth, (saith M. Wotton) is accounted by God to all purposes concerning ⟨p. 92⟩eternal life, to have done according to the covenant of the Gospel, as he should have been accounted to have done according to the covenant of the Law, if he had perfectly fulfilled it. For not to stand upon strict terms concerning the word Worthy: what doth M. Wotton say more here, then that which he saith else-where? objected also to him by M. Walker, as an heretical and blasphemous speech; hThe act of Faith, or believing brings justification and adoption, (which what is it other then what the Apostle saith, Rom. 3. 28. & Gal. 3. 26.) Only and merely by the place and office, which the Lord of his mercy hath assigned it, to be the condition required on our parts for the achieving of these favours and honours. thereby excluding all matter of worth in Faith. which yet, whosoever is possessed of, believing in Christ, that is relying upon him for justification and life eternal, may well be said to be accounted by God to all purposes (to wit on our parts required, and therefore to be necessarily by us performed) to have done as much according to the covenant of the Gospel, as he should have been accounted to have done according to the covenant of the Law, had he perfectly fulfilled it. But of this also enough before out of our own Writers; and by name out of M. Pemble; whom M. Walker having so highly commended, as one iby his writings most useful and powerful to confirm mens minds against the Wolves of this age, the Disciples of blasphemous Servetus and Socinus; will not now, I hope, condemn him for a Socinian and blasphemous heretic; and having kformerly made no doubt, but that he is ascended up into heaven, will not (I presume) for M. Wottons sake now damn him, and throw him down, to ⟨p. 93⟩send him packing for company with M. Wotton, to hell.
Let me give you but M. Wottons own words, out of M. Walkers own Parallel; and there shall need to this no further answer. gHe that beleeveth, (saith M. Wotton) is accounted by God to all purposes concerning ⟨p. 92⟩eternal life, to have done according to the covenant of the Gospel, as he should have been accounted to have done according to the covenant of the Law, if he had perfectly fulfilled it. For not to stand upon strict terms concerning the word Worthie: what doth M. Wotton say more here, then that which he saith else-where? objected also to him by M. Walker, as an heretical and blasphemous speech; hThe act of Faith, or beleeving brings justification and adoption, (which what is it other then what the Apostle saith, Rom. 3. 28. & Gal. 3. 26.) Onely and meerly by the place and office, which the Lord of his mercy hath assigned it, to be the condition required on our parts for the atchieving of these favours and honours. thereby excluding all matter of worth in Faith. which yet, whosoever is possessed of, beleeving in Christ, that is relying upon him for justifycation and life eternall, may wel be said to be accounted by God to all purposes (to wit on our parts required, and therefore to be necessarily by us performed) to have done as much according to the covenant of the Gospel, as he should have been accounted to have done according to the covenant of the Law, had he perfectly fulfilled it. But of this also enough before out of our own Writers; and by name out of M. Pemble; whom M. Walker having so highly commended, as one iby his writings most useful and powerful to confirm mens minds against the Wolves af this age, the Disciples of blasphemous Servetus and Socinus; wil not now, I hope, condemn him for a Socinian and blasphemous heretike; and having kformerly made no doubt, but that he is ascended up into heaven, wil not (I presume) for M. Wottons sake now damn him, and throw him down, to ⟨p. 93⟩send him packing for company with M. Wetton, to hell.
- gError. 4• Relat. p. 15.
- hError. 2. Relat. p. 13.
- iEpist. prefixed to M. Pembles Plea for grace.
- kIbid.
The fourth question is in effect the same with the two next before going; only, to make some show of variety, ushered in with a list of ltrue and orthodox tenets, wherein he saith M. Wotton professeth his dissent from Socinus; and wherein indeed M. Walker manifesteth his extreme partiality, and malignant disposition against M. Wotton; thereby showing too apparently, that his pretended zeal is not so much against Socinus and Socinianism it self, as against M. Wotton, and against the things taught by him, as coming from him. This he hath too too manifestly discovered in this interrogatory; spite and malice so blinding him, that mhe minded not what he did. For those tenets of Socinus, though unsound and containing in them rank venom, as he meaneth them, and manifesteth himself so to do, wherein M. Wotton professeth to dissent from him; these M. Walker, setting a fair gloss on them, contrary to Socinus his own intendment in them, alloweth and avoweth them for orthodox and true.
The fourth question is in effect the same with the two next before going; onely, to make some shew of variety, usherd in with a list of ltrue and orthodox te•ets, wherein he saith M. Wotton professeth his dissent from Socinus; and wherein indeed M. Walker manifesteth his extream partiality, and malignant disposition against M. Wotton; thereby shewing too apparently, that his pretended zeale is not so much against Socinus and Socinianism it self, as against M. Wotton, and against the things taught by him, as coming from him. This he hath too too manifestly discovered in this interrogatory; spite and malice so blinding him, that mhe minded not what he did. For those tenets of Socinus, though unsound and containing in them ranke venome, as he meaneth them, and manifesteth himselfe so to doe, wherein M. Wotton professeth to dissent from him; these M. Walker, setting a faire glosse on them, contrary to Socinus his own intendement in them, alloweth and avoweth them for orthodox and true.
- lPag. 28.
- m[Greek or Hebrew]. Democrit. Sto•. c: 20. [Greek or Hebrew] De Cyro Xenoph. instit. l. 1. Quâ noceat, ira videt; quâ caveat, non videt. Sen. de irâ. l. 2. c. 12.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Democrit. Sto•. c: 20. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 De Cyro Xenoph. instit. l. 1. Quâ noceat, ira videt; quâ caveat, non videt. Sen. de irâ. l. 2. c. 12.
For example, the first of them is, nthat Faith is obedience to Christs commandments; who commandeth us to believe and repent. And it is true, that Socinus, as oelsewhere I cite him, pmaintains as M. Walker here saith that he doth. But what saith Lubbertus to him for it? a man whom M. Walker would seem much to admire, and told us at our meeting, that he was by I know not whom styled Orthodoxorum ocellus. qWhereas he (to wit Socinus) saith (saith Lubbertus) ⟨p. 94⟩that Faith is to do those things that Christ hath enjoined, it is false: rto affirm it to be so, is to be stark mad. So by Lubbertus his censure, not Socinus only, but M. Walker also should be no better. Again, sHe teacheth, that to believe Christ and his words, is to obey him. We deny it. For obedience is an effect of faith. he erreth therefore, that holds Faith and Obedience to be all one. And yet again, tFirm stands that, which Beza writes, that Faith cannot signify Obedience to the Commandments. Thus Lubbertus, one of M Walkers own Oracles. And indeed what did Socinus hereby intend, but to cut off all relying by Faith on Christ, as having paid a price to God for our sins, or satisfied for them by his death? yet this is M. Walker pleased to blanch over; as if he conceived his meaning to be nothing else, but that in believing and repenting, we obey Christs commandment, who ucommandeth us to repent and believe. And so is content to let it pass for currant, as a true and orthodox tenet in Socinus, because M. Wotton dissented therein from Socinus; though condemned by Lubbertus (yea by whom not?) for a gross error, and in his intendment very dangerous.
For example, the first of them is, nthat Faith is obedience to Christs commandements; who commandeth us to beleeve and repent. And it is true, that Socinus, as oelsewhere I cite him, pmaintaines as M. Walker here saith that he doth. But what saith Lubbertus to him for it? a man whom M. Walker would seem much to admire, and told us at our meeting, that he was by I know not whom stiled Orthodoxorum ocellus. qWhereas he (to wit Socinus) saith (saith Lubbertus) ⟨p. 94⟩that Faith is to do those things that Christ hath enjoyned, it is false: rto affirme it to be so, is to be stark mad. So by Lubbertus his censure, not Socinus onely, but M. Walker also should be no better. Again, sHe teacheth, that to beleeve Christ and his words, is to obey him. We deny it. For obedience is an effect of faith. he erreth therefore, that holds Faith and Obedience to be all one. And yet again, tFirm stands that, which Beza writes, that Faith cannot signifie Obedience to the Commandements. Thus Lubbertus, one of M Walkers own Oracles. And indeed what did Socinus hereby intend, but to cut off all relying by Faith on Christ, as having paid a price to God for our sinnes, or satisfied for them by his death? yet this is M. Walker pleased to blanch over; as if he conceived his meaning to be nothing else, but that in beleeving and repenting, we obey Christs commandement, who ucommandeth us to repent and beleeve. And so is content to let it passe for currant, as a true and orthodox tenet in Socinus, because M. Wotton dissented therein from Socinus; though condemned by Lubbertus (yea by whom not?) for a grosse error, and in his intendement very dangerous.
- nPag. 28.
- oRelat. Poscr. p. 48.
- pDe Christ. Servat l. 4. c. 11.
- qQuod dicit, Fidem esse ea sacere, quae Christus praecepit, falsum est. Lubb. ad l. 4. c. 11 p. 561. col. 2.
- rDicere, fidem esse ea facere, quae Christus praecepit, est idem quod, jasanire. Ibid.Dicere, fidem esse ea facere, quae Christus praecepit, est idem quod, iasanire. Ibid.
- sDocet, Christo ejusque verbis credere idem esse quod Christo obedire: negamus. Obedientia enim est effectum sidei. errat igitur, qui contendit fidem & obedientiam idem esse. Ibid. p. 582. col. 2.
- tFirmum est, quod Beza soribit, Fidem non posse mandatorum obedientiam significare. Ib. p. 574. col. 2.
- uMark. 1. 15.
The second point, wherein M. Walker affirms M. Wotton to depart from Socinus, and which he affirms to be true and orthodox, is qthat Repentance, which comes not but by Faith, is the means to obtain forgiveness of sins, which Christ hath brought. But he deals here with Socinus, to help him out, as he is wont to do with M. Wotton, to procure prejudice to him. For he takes part out of one passage, and part out of an other, (as M. Wotton hath bcited him, not expressing how far forth in every particular he concurs with him, or dissents from him; but only showing, ⟨p. 95⟩how in general he speaks not that, that himself doth) and so pieces up a proposition, which he would have deemed sound; withal paring of, what might serve to discover Socinus his gross error, wherein M. Wotton intended to imply his departure from him. For, cIt is manifest, saith he, that God requireth nothing of us in the obtaining of salvation procured by Christ, but repentance and amendment of life. And, dWhereas Faith is sometime added to repentance; it is not because Faith in Christ is required to the obtaining of remission of sins, (directly contrary to what the Apostle eprofesseth) as working somewhat more in us besides Repentance it self, that doth hereunto appertain; but because Repentance comes not but by Faith in Christ. Thus he clips Socinus in favour to him; as he doth M. Wotton else-where to a contrary end. And yet further, because Lubbertus, Socinus his Antagonist, in refuting him, beats every where upon this, that fConversion & Repentance do not in order of nature go before, but follow remission of sin, and justification; and gare not causes, but effects of either; nor the cause of expiation, but a consequent of it: and supposing Socinus his meaning to be,h that our Repentance is the cause of the remission of our sins; iThis, saith he, we disallow, for, as hath a thousand times been showed, Remission of sins, that is justification, is in nature before repentance: and it is impossible therefore to be the cause of it. kFor ⟨p. 96⟩it is not Repentance, but Christs sacrifice, that is the true cause of the remission of our sins: lGod indeed promiseth pardon to the repentant; but we deny repentance to be the cause for which God doth pardon. Here M.
The second point, wherein M. Walker affirmes M. Wotton to depart from Socinus, and which he affirmes to be true and orthodox, is qthat Repentance, which comes not but by Faith, is the means to obtain forgivenes of sinnes, which Christ hath brought. But he deales here with Socinus, to help him out, as he is wont to do with M. Wotton, to procure prejudice to him. For he takes part out of one passage, and part out of an other, (as M. Wotton hath bcited him, not expressing how far forth in every particular he concurs with him, or dissents from him; but onely shewing, ⟨p. 95⟩how in general he speaks not that, that himself doth) and so pieces up a proposition, which he would have deemed sound; withall paring of, what might serve to discover Socinus his grosse error, wherein M. Wotton intended to imply his departure from him. For, cIt is manifest, saith he, that God requireth nothing of us in the obtaining of salvation procured by Christ, but repentance and amendment of life. And, dWhereas Faith is sometime added to repentance; it is not because Faith in Christ is required to the obtaining of remission of sins, (directly contrary to what the Apostle eprofesseth) as working somewhat more in us besides Repentance it selfe, that doth hereunto appertain; but because Repentance comes not but by Faith in Christ. Thus he clips Socinus in favour to him; as he doth M. Wotton els-where to a contrary end. And yet further, because Lubbertus, Socinus his Antagonist, in refuting him, beates every where upon this, that fConversion & Repentance do not in order of nature go before, but follow remission of sin, and justification; and gare not causes, but effects of either; nor the cause of expiation, but a consequent of it: and supposing Socinus his meaning to be,h that our Repentance is the cause of the remission of our sins; iThis, saith he, we disallow, for, as hath a thousand times been shewed, Remission of sins, that is justification, is in nature before repentance: and it is impossible therefore to be the cause of it. kFor ⟨p. 96⟩it is not Repentance, but Christs sacrifice, that is the true cause of the remission of our sins: lGod indeed promiseth pardon to the repentant; but we deny repentance to be the cause for which God doth pardon. Here M.
- qPag. 28.
- bAnswer to Error. 2. § 4. Relat. p 34. & to Error 4 p. 28.
- cManifestum est, in salute per Christum partâ, Deum nihil aliud à nobis requisivisse quam paenitentiam & vitae correctionem.
- dPoenitentiae addita alicubi est fides, non quia praeter ipsam poenitentiam fides in Christū, tanquam aliquid amplius, quod huc pertineat in nobis efficiens, ad peccatorum remissionem consequendam requiratur, sed quia non nisi per fidem in Christum ista poenitentia contingit. Socin. l. 3. c. 2. p. 321. col. 1.Poenitentiae addita alicubi est fides, non quia praeter ipsam poenitentiam fides in Christū, tanquam aliquid amplius, quod huc pertineat in nobis efficiens, ad peccatorum remissionem consequendam requiratur, sed quia non nisi per fidem in Christum ista poenitentia contingit. Socin. l. 3. c. 2. p. 321. col. 1.
- eRom. 3. 25.
- fPeccatorum veniam conversio naturae ordine sequitur, non praecedit. Lubb. ad l. 1. c. 5. p. 156. c. 2. Naturae ordine justificatio est prior. Ib p. 157. c. 1.
- gResipiscentia justificationis effectum est. Ib. p. 58. c. 2.
- hPaenitentia non est causa expiationis, sed ejus consequens. Ib. ad l. 2. c. 12. p. 213. c. 2.
- iReprobamus hanc sententiam, nam, ut jam millies osten sum est, remissio p•ccatorum, hoc est justificatio nostri, est naturâ prior poenitentiâ. quam obrem hanc ejus causam esse est simpliciter impossibile. Ib. p. 216. c. 1. & l. 3. c. 2. p. 348. c. 2. & p. 349. c. 1, 2.
- kNon nostra resipiscentia, sed ipsius sacrificium est vera causa remissionis pee•aterum. Ib. l. 2. c. 1. p. 274. c. 2.
- lDeum promittere veniam resespiscenti non negamus: tantum negamus resipiscentiam nostram esse causam, quare Deus nobis peccatorum veniam largiatur. Ib. l. 3. c. 2. p. 338. c. 2.
Walker strikes in to help Socinus at a dead lift, and telleth us, contrary to his Text, sure without any warrant at all from it, mthat by obtaining forgiveness of sins, Socinus means getting the sense and assurance of forgiveness. a gloss well-beseeming him, that professeth such a detestation of the very least sent or shadow of Socinianism in others.
Walker strikes in to help Socinus at a dead lift, and telleth us, contrary to his Text, sure without any warrant at all from it, mthat by obtaining forgivenes of sins, Socinus means getting the sense and assurance of forgivenesse. a glosse wel-beseeming him, that professeth such a detestation of the very least sent or shadow of Socinianism in others.
- mPag. 28.
The third point is, nthat faith is a believing of that which Christ taught, and an assurance of obtaining that he promised upon our repentance and obedience. Which whether it be a just definition of justifying Faith; (for of that here the question is) or do fitly express the office of it in the work of justification, I leave to be discussed by others. M. Wotton relateth it, oto show how that in laying down the nature and office of justifying faith, he goes an other way then Socinus doth; and further then Socinus either doth, or can, holding his own grounds, follow him. who indeed thus defines Faith, to bring all home to Repentance and obed•enee, as in the former point; and to exclude Christs merit, and ought done or endured by him, as satisfactory for mans sin: as appears plainly by the whole context of his discourse in that Chapter, out of which these words are alleged. And I would demand of M. Walker, how he can free himself from Socinianism, when he maintains such points as these for sound and orthodox in Socinus: and what censure himself would have past upon an other, that should have thus blanched and varnished over such ⟨p. 97⟩Assertions of Socinus. As also I would know of him, with what face he, that condemns in M. Wotton as heretical and blasphemous positions, these propositions, pTo believe in Christ, is to trust in Christ, and to rest on him; to have his heart settled, and to rely wholly and only on him; and, This trust is such a faith as makes us rest upon God for the performance of his promise; doth now pronounce Socinus his definition of faith, such as you have heard, to be true, Orthodox and sound. But hereby any party, not extremely partial, may easily judge what spirit this man is carried with throughout this whole business.
The third point is, nthat faith is a beleeving of that which Christ taught, and an assurance of obtaining that he promised upon our repentance and obedience. Which whether it be a just definition of justifying Faith; (for of that here the question is) or do fitly expresse the office of it in the worke of justification, I leave to be discussed by others. M. Wotton relateth it, oto shew how that in laying down the nature and office of justifying faith, he goes an other way then Socinus doth; and further then Socinus either doth, or can, holding his own grounds, follow him. who indeed thus defines Faith, to bring all home to Repentance and obed•enee, as in the former point; and to exclude Christs merit, and ought done or endured by him, as satisfactory for mans sin: as appeares plainly by the whole context of his discourse in that Chapter, out of which these words are alledged. And I would demand of M. Walker, how he can free himself from Socinianism, when he maintains such points as these for sound and orthodox in Socinus: and what censure himself would hape past upon an other, that should have thus blancht and vernisht over such ⟨p. 97⟩Assertions of Socinus. As also I would know of him, with what face he, that condemns in M. Wotton as hereticall and blasphemous positions, these propositions, pTo beleeve in Christ, is to trust in Christ, and to rest on him; to have his heart setled, and to rely wholy and onely on him; and, This trust is such a faith as makes us rest upon God for the performance of his promise; doth now pronounce Socinus his definition of faith, such as you have heard, to be true, Orthodox and sound. But hereby any party, not extreamly partiall, may easily judge what spirit this man is caried with throughout this whole busines.
- nIbid.
- oAnswer to Error. 2. § 5. Relat. p. 252, 6.
- pParall. Error• 5. Relat. p. 17.
For as for his twenty times sodden Coleworts, so oft served in, of qM. Wottons taking the word Faith in the Apostles words in a proper sense; Christs fulfilling the Law for us in our steed; Faith being the condition of the Gospel, &c. taking out M. Walkers fillings and glosses set upon them, which concern M. Wotton no more then himself; enough before hath been said. and, if M. Walker can prove them to be heretical opinions, many illustrious stars, besides M. Wotton, will by a blast of M. Walkers breath, as by rthe Dragons tail in the vision, be thrown out of Heaven, and not struck down to the ground only, but even hurled into Hell.
For as for his twenty times sodden Coleworts, so oft served in, of qM. Wottons taking the word Faith in the Apostles words in a proper sense; Christs fulfilling the Law for us in our steed; Faith being the condition of the Gospel, &c. taking out M. Walkers fillings and glosses set upon them, which concern M. Wotton no more then himselfe; enough before hath been said. and, if M. Walker can prove them to be heretical opinions, many illustrious stars, besides M. Wotton, will by a blast of M. VValkers breath, as by rthe Dragons tail in the vision, be thrown out of Heaven, and not struck down to the ground only, but even hurld into Hel.
- qPag. 28.
- rApoc. 12. 4.
His first question is, sWhether M. Wotton deny not the free covenant of Grace, when he holds, that God covenants not to justify and give life, but upon a condition performed on our part, equivalent for all purposes to mans fulfilling of the Law in his own person in the covenant of works.
His first question is, sWhether M. Wotton deny not the free covenant of Grace, when he holds, that God covenants not to justifie and give life, but upon a condition performed on our part, equivalent for all purposes to mans fulfilling of the Law in his own person in the covenant of works.
- sPag. 2•.
To which briefly. 1. To covenant to give a thing upon some condition may nothing impeach the freeness ⟨p. 98⟩either of the covenant, or of the gift. as to covenant with one to give him a shilling, that you have let fall, lying on the ground, if he will but stoop and take it up. And here by the way to satisfy some, who cannot endure to hear of any condition in the promises of the Gospel; which yet are tevery where so propounded: let it be considered, that a gift or a promise may be said to be free, or not free divers ways and in divers respects: 1. Free in regard both of condition and of consideration. By consideration understanding some valuable consideration, as in common speech we use to speak. and so it is absolutely, every way free. as if I promise one to bestow a book upon him and to send it home to him, and so do. Here being neither condition nor consideration interposed. 2. Free in regard neither of condition, nor of consideration, as if I promise one to give him such a book of mine, if he will give me another of his in lieu of it. for here is both condition and consideration; which both concurring destroy the freeness of it. 3. Free in regard of consideration, tho not free in regard of condition. as if I promise to give one such a book gratis, if he will but call to me at mine house for it; supposing that I dwell at next door, or near to him. Nor doth it derogate ought from the freeness of a gift, if it have been promised upon such a condition; and the promise made good upon the performance of it. no more then a Princes pardon would be deemed less free, were it granted upon condition of taking it out, and that free also for any to do, that will, of free cost, without fee. or his alms, were they propounded and published to all, that would but repair to the Court for them. Nor doth M. Wotton ⟨p. 99⟩therefore necessarily deny the freeness of Gods gracious covenant, if he hold justification and life eternal not to be promised therein but upon condition. So M. Fox answering those that might object that to him, that M. Walker here to M. Wotton. *If Gods promise be restrained to certain conditions, how shall we maintain with Paul the freeness of Gods mercy, whereby he freely justifieth a sinner? uYes, saith he, I deem and determine God's mercy to be most free in Christ. albeit this salvation by the merit of Christ be not derived unto us but upon a certain condition.
To which briefly. 1. To covenant to give a thing upon some condition may nothing impeach the freenesse ⟨p. 98⟩either of the covenant, or of the gift. as to covenant with one to give him a shilling, that you have let fall, lying on the ground, if he will but stoop and take it up. And here by the way to satisfie some, who cannot endure to heare of any condition in the promises of the Gospel; which yet are tevery where so propounded: let it be considered, that a gift or a promise may be said to be free, or not free divers waies and in divers respects: 1. Free in regard both of condition and of consideration. By consideration understanding some valuable consideration, as in common speech we use to speak. and so it is absolutely, every way free. as if I promise one to bestow a book upon him and to send it home to him, and so do. Here being neither condition nor consideration interposed. 2. Free in regard neither of condition, nor of confideration, as if I promise one to give him such a book of mine, if he will give me another of his in lieu of it. for here is both condition and consideration; which both concurring destroy the freenes of it. 3. Free in regard of consideration, tho not free in regard of condition. as if I promise to give one such a book gratis, if he wil but cal to me at mine house for it; supposing that I dwell at next dore, or neer to him. Nor doth it derogate ought from the freenes of a gift, if it have been promised upon such a condition; and the promise made good upon the performance of it. no more then a Princes pardon would be deemed lesse free, were it granted upon condition of taking it out, and that free also for any to do, that wil, of free cost, without fee. or his alms, were they propounded and published to all, that would but repaire to the Court for them. Nor doth M. Wotton ⟨p. 99⟩therefore necessarily denie the freenesse of Gods gratious covenant, if he hold justification and life eternal not to be promised therein but upon condition. So M. Fox answering those that might object that to him, that M. Walker here to M. Wotton. *If Gods promise be restrained to certain conditions, how shall we maintain with Paul the freenes of Gods mercy, whereby he freely justifyeth a sinner? uYes, saith he, I deem and determine Goas mercy to be most free in Christ. albeit this salvation by the merit of Christ be not derived unto us but upon a certaine condition.
- tMark 16. 16. John 3. 15, 16, 18. 26. Acts 16. 31. Rom. 10. 9.Marke 16. 16. John 3. 15, 16, 18. 26. Acts 16. 31. Rom. 10. 9.
- *Si ad certas conditiones restring• Dei promissio, quomodò gratuitam Dei miseri•ordiam cum Paul• constituemus, quâ gratis per gratiam justificat impium? De Christ. grat. Justif. p. 237.Si ad certas conditiones restring• Dei promissio, quomodò gratuitam Dei miseri•ordiam cum Paul• constituemus, quâ gratis per gratiam justificat impium? De Christ. grat. Iustif. p. 237.
- uImò verò quam maximè gratuitam Dei misericordiam in Christo & censeo & statuo. cum tamen salus haec per Christi meritum, non nisi sub certa quadam conditione ad nos derivetur. Ibid.
And M. Perkins before recited: wThe condition of the covenant is by grace, as well as the substance. Whereunto ad M. Pembles reason: that therefore *this covenant is a compact of freest mercy, because therein life eternal is given to that, that bears not the least proportion of worth with it.
And M. Perkins before recited: wThe condition of the covenant is by grace, as wel as the substance. Whereunto ad M. Pembles reason: that therefore *this covenant is a compact of freest mercy, because therein life eternal is given to that, that beares not the least proportion of worth with it.
- wReform. Cathol. Point. 4. of means of justif. Differ. 2. Reas. 1.
- *Plea for grace Sect. 2. chap. 1. p. 22.
2. That this condition is xFaith, the performance whereof is as available for our good, as perfect obedience at first had been, if it be an heresy; why doth not M. Walker require M. Pembles, if not bones, yet books to be burnt, as containing in them heretical and blasphemous doctrine? at least why doth he not arraign and condemn him for an heretic as well as M. Wotton? for he hath, as hath been showed, the same.
2. That this condition is xFaith, the performance whereof is as availeable for our good, as perfect obedience at first had been, if it be an heresie; why doth not M. Walker require M. Pembles, if not bones, yet books to be burnt, as containing in them hereticall and blasphemous doctrine? at least why doth he not arraign and condemn him for an heretick as wel as M. Wotton? for he hath, as hath been shewed, the same.
As for the word Equivalent here, it is not M. Wottons, but M. Walkers term. whose spite and rancour against M. Wotton is such, that nothing of his can fairly pass through his fingers. To be equivalent, that is, equal in worth, and value, is one thing; (and yet I might tell M. Walker that yChrysostom sticks not to affirm, yea stiffly maintains, that Faith in Christ is of it self a more excellent thing and of greater ⟨p. 100⟩worth, then the keeping of Gods Commandments; as I show, but disallowing, elsewhere; and yet is he not therefore deemed or condemned for an heretic:) to be reckoned or counted by God unto man in the 2covenant of grace to all purposes, in regard of ought that God requires on his part to be performed, for attaining of life eternal, as if he had in the other covenant kept the whole law, is another thing. I suppose M. Walker is not to learn a difference, and that a vast one too, between [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] in Greek.
As for the word Equivalent here, it is not M. Wottons, but M. Walkers tearm. whose spite and rancor against M. Wotton is such, that nothing of his can fairely passe through his fingers. To be equivalent, that is, equall in worth, and value, is one thing; (and yet I might tel M. Walker that yChrysostome sticks not to affirm, yea stiffly maintains, that Faith in Christ is of it self a more excellent thing and of greater ⟨p. 100⟩worth, then the keeping of Gods Commandements; as I shew, but disallowing, elsewhere; and yet is he not therefore deemed or condemned for an heretick:) to be reckoned or counted by God unto man in the 2covenant of grace to all purposes, in regard of ought that God requires on his part to be performed, for attaining of life eternal, as if he had in the other covenant kept the whole law, is another thing. I suppose M. Walker is not to learne a difference, and that a vast one too, between 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in Greek.
- yVideatur in disceptatione cum Lud. Lucio part. 1. sect. 9. Luc. script. n. 2. p. 32, 33. & T. G. Animadv. n. 7. p. 35.
- 2Luke 20. 35. & 21. 36. 2 Thes. 1. 5, 11 which places the papists abuse to build merit and worth of works upon. Bellarm, de justific. l. 5. c. 2. and Rhemists notes.Luke 20. 35. & 21. 36. 2 Thes. 1. 5, 11 which places the papists abuse to build merit and worth of works upon. Bellarm, de justific. l. 5. c. 2. and Remists notes.
The sixth question is, aWhether M. Wotton affirming, that, If we be freely pardoned, then our sins were not punished in Christ our head and surety, doth not deny Christs satisfaction for sin.
The sixt question is, aWhether M. Wotton affirming, that, If we be freely pardoned, then our sins were not punished in Christ our head and surety, doth not deny Christs satisfaction for sin.
- aPag. 28, 29.
To this I answer. he must show first, where M. Wotton so saith. For these words out of M. Wotton he never yet produced. Read bthe Parallel Error 7. & out of M. Wotton what is there alleged; and cM. Wottons Answer to what is there alleged by M. Walker out of him: and you shall soon see how M. Walker here deals with M. Wotton.
To this I answer. he must shew first, where M. Wotton so saith. For these words out of M. Wotton he never yet produced. Read bthe Parallel Error 7. & out of M. Wotton what is there alledged; and cM. Wottons Answer to what is there alledged by M. Walker out of him: and you shal soon see how M. Walker here deales with M. VVotton.
- bRelat. p. 19.
- cIbid. p. 34.
The man, you see, can not speak of M. Wotton, but he must needs spit Fire and Brimstone. Every thing is either heretical or blasphemous in him. But am I, or is any man else bound to reconcile whatsoever contradictions are, if any be, or may be found in M. Wottons writings? Or is every one that is taken in gross contradictions, of necessity thereupon to be condemned for an heretic? But in this also M. Walker ⟨p. 101⟩may as well be believed, as ewhere he pronounces the like of M. Bradshaws book. Were M. Wotton alive, he were best able to reconcile his own seeming differences. and indeed, for the most of them, if not all, he then did it himself.
The man, you see, can not speak of M. VVotton, but he must needs spit Fier and Brimstone. Every thing is either heretical or blasphemous in him. But am I, or is any man else bound to reconcile whatsoever contradictions are, if any be, or may be found in M. VVottons writings? Or is every one that is taken in grosse contradictions, of necessity thereupon to be condemned for an heretick? But in this also M. Walker ⟨p. 101⟩may as wel be beleeved, as ewhere he pronounces the like of M. Bradshaws book. Were M. VVotton alive, he were best able to reconcile his own seeming differences. and indeed, for the most of them, if not all, he then did it himselfe.
- eIn his Woolf in Sheeps clothing.