A42456:215
An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth…
An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth Mr. Wotton, besides his former foul aspersions of heresy and blasphemy, with Arianism, Mr. Gataker with Socinianism, Dr. Gouge and Mr. Downham with a false attestation, Dr. Baylie and Mr. Stock with self-condemnation, all the eight ministers employed in the business between himself and Mr. Wotton with partiality and unjust judgement : upon occasion of a relation concerning that business / written by the said Thomas Gataker and by him now again avowed, wherein the said M. Walkers vindication is in many things showed to be an untrue relation.An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth Mr. Wotton, besides his former foul aspersions of heresie and blasphemy, with Arianism, Mr. Gataker with Socinianism, Dr. Gouge and Mr. Downham with a fase attestation, Dr. Baylie and Mr. Stock with self-condemnation, all the eight ministers employed in the busines between himself and Mr. Wotton with partiality and unjust judgement : upon occasion of a relation concerning that busines / written by the said Thomas Gataker and by him now again avowed, wherein the said M. Walkers vindication is in many things shewed to be an untrue relation.
London: printed by E.G. for F. Clifton, 1642
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
As for the word Equivalent here, it is not M. Wottons, but M. Walkers term. whose spite and rancour against M. Wotton is such, that nothing of his can fairly pass through his fingers. To be equivalent, that is, equal in worth, and value, is one thing; (and yet I might tell M. Walker that yChrysostom sticks not to affirm, yea stiffly maintains, that Faith in Christ is of it self a more excellent thing and of greater ⟨p. 100⟩worth, then the keeping of Gods Commandments; as I show, but disallowing, elsewhere; and yet is he not therefore deemed or condemned for an heretic:) to be reckoned or counted by God unto man in the 2covenant of grace to all purposes, in regard of ought that God requires on his part to be performed, for attaining of life eternal, as if he had in the other covenant kept the whole law, is another thing. I suppose M. Walker is not to learn a difference, and that a vast one too, between [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] in Greek.
As for the word Equivalent here, it is not M. Wottons, but M. Walkers tearm. whose spite and rancor against M. Wotton is such, that nothing of his can fairely passe through his fingers. To be equivalent, that is, equall in worth, and value, is one thing; (and yet I might tel M. Walker that yChrysostome sticks not to affirm, yea stiffly maintains, that Faith in Christ is of it self a more excellent thing and of greater ⟨p. 100⟩worth, then the keeping of Gods Commandements; as I shew, but disallowing, elsewhere; and yet is he not therefore deemed or condemned for an heretick:) to be reckoned or counted by God unto man in the 2covenant of grace to all purposes, in regard of ought that God requires on his part to be performed, for attaining of life eternal, as if he had in the other covenant kept the whole law, is another thing. I suppose M. Walker is not to learne a difference, and that a vast one too, between 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in Greek.
- yVideatur in disceptatione cum Lud. Lucio part. 1. sect. 9. Luc. script. n. 2. p. 32, 33. & T. G. Animadv. n. 7. p. 35.
- 2Luke 20. 35. & 21. 36. 2 Thes. 1. 5, 11 which places the papists abuse to build merit and worth of works upon. Bellarm, de justific. l. 5. c. 2. and Rhemists notes.Luke 20. 35. & 21. 36. 2 Thes. 1. 5, 11 which places the papists abuse to build merit and worth of works upon. Bellarm, de justific. l. 5. c. 2. and Remists notes.
The sixth question is, aWhether M. Wotton affirming, that, If we be freely pardoned, then our sins were not punished in Christ our head and surety, doth not deny Christs satisfaction for sin.
The sixt question is, aWhether M. Wotton affirming, that, If we be freely pardoned, then our sins were not punished in Christ our head and surety, doth not deny Christs satisfaction for sin.
- aPag. 28, 29.
To this I answer. he must show first, where M. Wotton so saith. For these words out of M. Wotton he never yet produced. Read bthe Parallel Error 7. & out of M. Wotton what is there alleged; and cM. Wottons Answer to what is there alleged by M. Walker out of him: and you shall soon see how M. Walker here deals with M. Wotton.
To this I answer. he must shew first, where M. Wotton so saith. For these words out of M. Wotton he never yet produced. Read bthe Parallel Error 7. & out of M. Wotton what is there alledged; and cM. Wottons Answer to what is there alledged by M. Walker out of him: and you shal soon see how M. Walker here deales with M. VVotton.
- bRelat. p. 19.
- cIbid. p. 34.
The man, you see, can not speak of M. Wotton, but he must needs spit Fire and Brimstone. Every thing is either heretical or blasphemous in him. But am I, or is any man else bound to reconcile whatsoever contradictions are, if any be, or may be found in M. Wottons writings? Or is every one that is taken in gross contradictions, of necessity thereupon to be condemned for an heretic? But in this also M. Walker ⟨p. 101⟩may as well be believed, as ewhere he pronounces the like of M. Bradshaws book. Were M. Wotton alive, he were best able to reconcile his own seeming differences. and indeed, for the most of them, if not all, he then did it himself.
The man, you see, can not speak of M. VVotton, but he must needs spit Fier and Brimstone. Every thing is either heretical or blasphemous in him. But am I, or is any man else bound to reconcile whatsoever contradictions are, if any be, or may be found in M. VVottons writings? Or is every one that is taken in grosse contradictions, of necessity thereupon to be condemned for an heretick? But in this also M. Walker ⟨p. 101⟩may as wel be beleeved, as ewhere he pronounces the like of M. Bradshaws book. Were M. VVotton alive, he were best able to reconcile his own seeming differences. and indeed, for the most of them, if not all, he then did it himselfe.
- eIn his Woolf in Sheeps clothing.
For the first, which fhe citeth out of my Defence, as he terms it, though out of his own Parallel, and M. Wottons own defence indeed. he might, if he had but put on his spectacles, have found it gin the very same place assoiled; that his dispute being of the formal cause of justification, or that whereby we are made formally righteous, hhe denieth any end or use of Christs righteousness imputed to that purpose. but ihe denieth not the imputation of it, as the meritorious cause thereof.
For the first, which fhe citeth out of my Defence, as he tearms it, though out of his own Parallel, and M. VVottons own defence indeed. he might, if he had but put on his spectacles, have found it gin the very same place assoiled; that his dispute being of the formall cause of justification, or that whereby we are made formally righteous, hhe denieth any end or use of Christs righteousnes imputed to that purpose. but ihe denieth not the imputation of it, as the meritorious cause thereof.
- fPag. 29:
- gRelat. p. 21, 22.
- hIb. p. 22. n. 2.
- iIb. p. 21. n. 1.
Whereunto, tho sufficient to take away the seeming contradiction, I ad yet further what I touched upon out of kM. Bradshaw before, and I find in him elsewhere; that tho he deny Imputation of Christs righteousness taken in a stricter sense, as many in this argument would have it; yet taken it in a larger sense, for that which is reckoned to a man for his benefit, so far forth as it may in that kind be useful unto him, so he denies not the Imputation of Christs righteousness to mans justification. For thus I find in certain Theses of his written in Latin of this subject.
Whereunto, tho sufficient to take away the seeming contradiction, I ad yet further what I touched upon out of kM. Bradshaw before, and I find in him elswhere; that tho he deny Imputation of Christs righteousnes taken in a stricter sense, as many in this argument would have it; yet taken it in a larger sense, for that which is reckoned to a man for his benefit, so far forth as it may in that kind be useful unto him, so he denies not the Imputation of Christs righteousnesse to mans justification. For thus I find in certaine Theses of his written in Latine of this subject.
- kPreface to Treat. of justif.
1. lIf any man hold Christs Righteousness to be by way of merit the efficient cause of justification, I am wholly of his mind.
1. lIf any man hold Christs Righteousnes to be by way of merit the efficient cause of justification, I am wholly of his mind.
- lSi justificationis efficientem dicat quis justitiam Christi per modum meriti, ego planè cum eo sentio.
2. mIf any maintain not Christs Righteousness to be our formal Righteousness, I have no controversy with him.
2. mIf any maintain not Christs Righteousnes to be our formal Righteousnes, I have no controversie with him.
- mSi qui• Christi justitiā nostram formalem esse justitiam non contendat, nulla mihi cum illo de imputatione est controversia.Si qui• Christi justitiā nostram formalem esse justitiam non contendat, nulla mihi cum illo de imputatione est controversia.
3. nThe imputation of Christs Righteousness to our benefit, I acknowledge and profess.
3. nThe imputation of Christs Righteousnes to our benefit, I acknowledge and professe.
- nJustitiae Christi ad beneficium imputationem ego agnosco & prae me fero.Iustitiae Christi ad beneficium imputationem ego agnosco & prae me fero.
4. oIt never came into my mind, not so much as in dream, to deny, that we are justified for the righteousness of Christ.
4. oIt never came into my mind, not so much as in dream, to deny, that we are justified for the righteousnes of Christ.
- oNon mihi unquam in mentem ne per somnium quidem, venit neg tre, nos propter Christi justitiam justificari.
As for what M. Walker padds out of M. Wottons Essays; they were written after our meeting, as qhimself acknowledgeth; and therefore nothing concern either us or our censure; nor for my part did I ever see them, nor know what is in them. and yet what is it, that M. Walker thence here allegeth? That in Scripture there is no mention of Christs merit. Which if he speak of the word merit, who will, or can deny the truth of it? yet it will not thence follow, that M. Wotton therefore denies the thing thereby signified, (the rather since that he useth the term of meritorious cause applied unto Christ and his Righteousness so frequently himself) no more then, that Calvin denied the Doctrine of the Trinity, because rhe acknowledgeth that term not to be found in Gods Word
As for what M. Walker paddes out of M. VVottons Essaies; they were written after our meeting, as qhimself acknowledgeth; and therefore nothing concern either us or our censure; nor for my part did I ever see them, nor know what is in them. and yet what is it, that M. Walker thence here alledgeth? That in Scripture there is no mention of Christs merit. Which if he speak of the word merit, who wil, or can deny the truth of it? yet it will not thence follow, that M. VVotton therefore denies the thing thereby signified, (the rather since that he useth the tearm of meritorious cause applied unto Christ and his Righteousnes so frequently himself) no more then, that Calvin denied the Doctrine of the T•init•, because rhe acknowledgeth that tearm not to be found in Gods VVord
- pPag. 29.
- qPag. 24.
- rCalvin. Instit. lib. 1. c. 13. § 3.
To the next slikewise he might have found the like solution, in the very place twhence he had it; if he had been pleased to deal but half so kindly with M. Wotton, as he dealt with Socinus. For, why may not Faith, tho taken properly, be said to justify, not per se, or of it self; (tho Bucer, as I have showed, uso also say) albeit the word Faith be there properly taken, where it is said to be imputed for Righteousness? not for it self, as xM Wotton himself expoundeth himself, but for Christ, on whom it relies; as hath formerly been at large related.
To the next slikewise he might have found the like solution, in the very place twhence he had it; if he had been pleased to deal but half so kindly with M. VVotton, as he dealt with Socinus. For, why may not Faith, tho taken properly, be said to justifie, not per se, or of it self; (tho Bucer, as I have shewed, uso also say) albeit the word Faith be there properly taken, where it is said to be imputed for Righteousnes? not for it self, as xM VVotton himself expoundeth himself, but for Christ, on whom it relies; as hath formerly been at large related.
- sPag. 29.
- tAnswer to Error. 3. Propos. 2. Relat. p 27.
- uPrae sat. Comment. in Ep st. Paulin.
- xAd di cept. Lub. cum Bert.
For, what yis added of Imputation, is coincident to the former: but that M. Walker with his zcoal so o•t new dressed and dished in again, tires out h•s ⟨p. 103⟩Readers, and may well overturn their stoi•ck•.
For, what yis added of Imputation, is coincident to the former: but that M. Walker with his zcole so o•t new dressed and dished in again, tires out h•s ⟨p. 103⟩Readers, and may wel overturn their stoi•ck•.
- yPag. 29.
- zOcc• miseros crambe• epe• ••acc. art.
The athird consists of the bsecond and csixth Queries; (for M. Walker loves to turn round) wherein nothing is truly alleged out of M. Wotton, that any way crosseth Christs satisfaction made, or the price by him paid, for us: and shall thither therefore be returned again; least by running round in a circle after M. Walker, we grow turn-sick with him.
The athird consists of the bsecond and csixt Queres; (for M. Walker loves to turn round) wherein nothing is truely alledged out of M. VVotton, that any way crosseth Christs satisfaction made, or the price by him paid, for us: and shal thither therefore be returned again; least by running round in a circle after M. Walker, we grow turn-sick with him.
- aIbid.
- bPag. 27.
- cPag. 18.
The dfourth is not so much a contradiction found in M Wottons writings to ought of his own, as to the words of the Apostle, Rom. 5. 19. which yet unless they be understood of formal and inherent Righteousness, (however eM. Walker tax M. Bradshaw for confounding these terms) M. Wotton contradicteth not at all. And yet is it not sufficient to prove a man an heretic, because he contradicts somewhat contained in Gods Word. since that every error whatsoever in any point of Divinity must of necessity so do. and M. Walker therefore, unless he dare profess himself free from all error, must by the same ground withal granted confess himself to be an heretic.
The dfourth is not so much a contradiction found in M Wottons writings to ought of his own, as to the words of the Apostle, Rom. 5. 19. which yet unles they be understood of formal and inherent Righteousnes, (however eM. Walker tax M. Bradshaw for confounding these terms) M. VVottoh contradicteth not at all. And yet is it not sufficient to prove a man an heretick, because he contradicts somewhat conteined in Gods Word. since that every error whatsoever in any point of Divinity must of necessity so do. and M. Walker therefore, unlesse he dare professe himself free from all error, must by the same ground withall granted confesse himself to be an heretick.
- dPag. 30.
- eWoolf in sheeps clothing. chap. 1. § 23.Woolf in sheeps cloathing. chap. 1. § 23.