A42456:274
An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth…
An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth Mr. Wotton, besides his former foul aspersions of heresy and blasphemy, with Arianism, Mr. Gataker with Socinianism, Dr. Gouge and Mr. Downham with a false attestation, Dr. Baylie and Mr. Stock with self-condemnation, all the eight ministers employed in the business between himself and Mr. Wotton with partiality and unjust judgement : upon occasion of a relation concerning that business / written by the said Thomas Gataker and by him now again avowed, wherein the said M. Walkers vindication is in many things showed to be an untrue relation.An answer to Mr. George Walkers vindication, or rather, fresh accusation wherein he chargeth Mr. Wotton, besides his former foul aspersions of heresie and blasphemy, with Arianism, Mr. Gataker with Socinianism, Dr. Gouge and Mr. Downham with a fase attestation, Dr. Baylie and Mr. Stock with self-condemnation, all the eight ministers employed in the busines between himself and Mr. Wotton with partiality and unjust judgement : upon occasion of a relation concerning that busines / written by the said Thomas Gataker and by him now again avowed, wherein the said M. Walkers vindication is in many things shewed to be an untrue relation.
London: printed by E.G. for F. Clifton, 1642
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First, suppose that a denial of Christs deity might be necessarily deduced from some Positions by M. Wotton maintained. would it thence follow that M. Wotton denies the Deity of Christ? It is no good consequence. For some thing may follow truly and necessarily from what a man holds; and yet he not ⟨p. 119⟩hold it, but deny it; yea strongly and stiffly not in dispute only, but even in judgement oppose it, because he deems the consequence, whereby it is thence deduced, unsound, For example: That which the Lutherans hold concerning the corporal presence of Christs body in the Sacrament, together with the bread, doth by necessary consequence overthrow the truth of Christs humanity. Do any of our Divines therefore charge them, (tho qthey walk along with M. Walker in the way he here takes, in their writings against us) with the denial of Christs humane nature? Or will M. Walker therefore dare to pronounce Luther an heretic, as denying the truth of Christs humanity? albeit we know that every true, natural, and humane body is confined to some one certain individual place or other, and limited with such dimensions as all men we see are; which of Christs cannot be truly said, if that be admitted. Yea to turn the edge of M. Walkers argument the other way. By the same reason, from some consequences of M. Richardsons, (whose authority M. Walker I am sure, will not waive) a man may prove, that Turks, Jews and Pagans hold a Trinity of Persons in the Deity, and the Evangelical doctrine of Christs Incarnation. For what Turk, Jew, or Pagan, of any but ordinary apprehension in intellectuals, if he acknowledge a God, doth not hold, that that God doth most perfectly understand himself? Now M. Richardson in some Essays of his; wherein (directly contrary, as I take it, to what rthe Apostle avers; and yet do I not therefore account him an heretic, no more then that other Noble sLord of great note, that hath laboured in the like Argument) he endeavours to prove, that men by the very ⟨p. 120⟩light of nature and use of reason alone, may attain to the knowledge of those two main mysteries of Faith and grounds of the Gospel; and that they may thereby be demonstrated to those who never heard of or knew them before; he doth from this Position as generally granted and agreed on, by a continued chain of consequences, as so many links or roundels necessarily depending each on other, thus argu: