A42469:236
Thomas Gataker B.D. his vindication of the annotations by him published upon these words,…
Thomas Gataker B.D. his vindication of the annotations by him published upon these words, Thus saith the Lord, learn not the way of the heathen, and be not dismayed at the signs of heaven, for the heathen are dismayed at them, Jer. 10. 2 against the scurrilous aspersions of that grand impostor Mr. William Lillie : as also against the various expositions of two of his advocates, Mr. John Swan, and another by him cited, but not named : together with the annotations themselves : wherein the pretended grounds of judiciary astrology, and the Scripture-proofs produced for it are discussed and refuted.Thomas Gataker B.D. his vindication of the annotations by him published upon these words, Thus saith the Lord, learn not the way of the heathen, and be not dismayed at the signes of heaven, for the heathen are dismayed at them, Jer. 10. 2 against the scurrilous aspersions of that grand imposter Mr. William Lillie : as also against the various expositions of two of his advocates, Mr. John Swan, and another by him cited, but not named : together with the annotations themselvs : wherein the pretended grounds of judiciary astrologie, and the Scripture-proofes produced for it are discussed and refuted.
London: printed by J.L. for Richard Thrayle, 1653
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ye see how many signs here of either sort, and yet not one portending ought: and the weakness consequently of this Argument, whither as Melanchthon himself delivers it; When he calls them signs, he affirms them to portend somewhat; which reduced to a Syllogism, must thus be framed, All signs portend somewhat, but these are signs. Ergò they portend somewhat. or as Mr. Swan delivers it, In naming them signs, he declares they sometime signify or threaten great and sad things; which syllogistically conceived, must run on this wise; All signs sometimes (for if ye give it only, signs sometimes the syllogism will consist all of particulars, and be of no force or worth) signify or threaten great and sad things, but these are signs, ergò sometimes they so do. For whether way of the two we take it, the Proposition is manifestly untrue in either. It is not of the nature or property of a sign to portend ought; signs not a few do not, much less to threaten great and sad things: the contrary whereunto by the instances above given doth most evidently appear.
Ye see how many signes here of either sort, and yet not one portending ought: and the weaknesse conseqently of this Argument, whither as Melanchthon himself delivers it; When he calls them signes, he affirms them to portend somewhat; which reduced to a Syllogism, must thus be framed, All signes portend somewhat, but these are signes. Ergò they portend somewhat. or as Mr. Swan delivers it, In naming them signes, he declares they sometime signifie or threaten great and sad things; which syllogistically conceived, must run on this wise; All signes sometimes (for if ye give it onely, signes sometimes the syllogism will consist all of particulars, and be of no force or worth) signifie or threaten great and sad things, but these ar signs, ergò sometimes they so do. For whether way of the two we take it, the Proposition is manifestly untrue in either. It is not of the nature or propertie of a sign to portend ought; signes not a few do not, much lesse to threaten great and sad things: the contrarie whereunto by the instances above given doth most evidently appear.
Yea but saith Melanchthon, the Prophet doth not say, they are nothing. Yes, he doth say, they are nothing, in the same sense wherein the Apostle saith, that an idol is nothing,