A42469:253
Thomas Gataker B.D. his vindication of the annotations by him published upon these words,…
Thomas Gataker B.D. his vindication of the annotations by him published upon these words, Thus saith the Lord, learn not the way of the heathen, and be not dismayed at the signs of heaven, for the heathen are dismayed at them, Jer. 10. 2 against the scurrilous aspersions of that grand impostor Mr. William Lillie : as also against the various expositions of two of his advocates, Mr. John Swan, and another by him cited, but not named : together with the annotations themselves : wherein the pretended grounds of judiciary astrology, and the Scripture-proofs produced for it are discussed and refuted.Thomas Gataker B.D. his vindication of the annotations by him published upon these words, Thus saith the Lord, learn not the way of the heathen, and be not dismayed at the signes of heaven, for the heathen are dismayed at them, Jer. 10. 2 against the scurrilous aspersions of that grand imposter Mr. William Lillie : as also against the various expositions of two of his advocates, Mr. John Swan, and another by him cited, but not named : together with the annotations themselvs : wherein the pretended grounds of judiciary astrologie, and the Scripture-proofes produced for it are discussed and refuted.
London: printed by J.L. for Richard Thrayle, 1653
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Lastly, do not the Stars speak at all unto us, unless they speak to us in the Wizards language? This is just like to the Patrons of Popish superstitions, and of that monster more particularly of Transubstantiation; who because they find the Sacrament of Christs body and blood oft termed a Mystery, and a great Mystery in the writings of the Ancient Fathers, would thence conclude it to be a Miracle, or a miraculous Mystery, such a Mystery as they would have it to be. For so doth Mr. Swan reason, and Mr. Lily before him; The Sun, Moon and Stars are signs: therefore Fortune-telling signs, foretelling the ruin of Kingdoms and States or such signs as we Wizards will have them to be. But this is to reason a genere praedicato ad speciem statuendam, A Mystery; and therefore a miraculous Mystery? A sign; therefore a prodigious or portending sign: as if one should thus reason; A man is an animal; and therefore a brute: or, An ass is an animal: and therefore a reasonable creature. And as we therefore answer those Romish Factors, that the Sacrament of Baptism is a Mystery, and yet not a miracle; the Element of water in it is mysterious, yet no miraculous matter. no such essential change in the one, as from the word Mystery they would infer in the other. So may we justly return the like answer to these Wizards and their Factors, that the Rainbow, Circumcision, the Passover, the Sabbath, divers other were, and our Sacraments are Signs; and yet neither such prodigious or portending signs, as from this term ⟨p. 130⟩given them, or office thereby assigned them, they would conclude these to be. But we will take Mr. Swans argument, and try what use we can make of it. The Stars were not signs, if they did not speak somewhat. To which I ad, that it is sufficient to prov them Signs if they do speak some what; as it is enough to make letters and words signs, if they signify somewhat. But the Psalmist saith, they speak somewhat, and telleth us withal what somewhat it is that they say. the stars therefore may be signs, tho they speak no more then what the Psalmist saith they do; rho they speak not such a language as Mr. Swan and his Clients would have them to speak,1 and rack Moses most unreasonably to make him say that they say.
Lastly, do not the Stars speak at all unto us, unless they speak to us in the Wizards language? This is just like to the Patrones of Popish superstitions, and of that monster more particularly of Transubstantiation; who because they find the Sacrament of Christs body and blood oft termed a Mysterie, and a great Mysterie in the writings of the Ancient Fathers, would thence conclude it to be a Miracle, or a miraculous Mysterie, such a Mysterie as they would have it to be. For so doth Mr. Swan reason, and Mr. Lilie before him; The Sun, Moon and Stars ar signes: therefore Fortune-telling signs, foretelling the ruine of Kingdoms and States or such signes as we Wizards will have them to be. But this is to reason a genere praedicato ad speciem statuendam, A Mysterie; and therefore a miraculous Mysterie? A signe; therefore a prodigious or portending signe: as if one should thus reason; A man is an animal; and therefore a bruit: or, An asse is an animal: and therefore a reasonable creature. And as we therefore answer those Romish Factors, that the Sacrament of Baptisme is a Mysterie, and yet not a miracle; the Element of water in it is mysterious, yet no miraculous matter. no such essential change in the one, as from the word Mysterie they would infer in the other. So may we justly return the like answer to these Wizards and their Factors, that the Rainbow, Circumcision, the Passover, the Sabbath, divers other were, and our Sacraments ar Signes; and yet neither such prodigious or portending signes, as from this term