A44670:152
A calm and sober enquiry concerning the possibility of a Trinity in the Godhead…
A calm and sober enquiry concerning the possibility of a Trinity in the Godhead in a letter to a person of worth : occasioned by the lately published considerations on the explications of the doctrine of the Trinity by Dr. Wallis, Dr. Sherlock, Dr. S--th, Dr. Cudworth, &c. ...
London: printed by J. Astwood for Tho. Parkhurst, 1694
Postscript › LETTERS TO Dr. WALLIS, Sent in 1691. › Letter 1: LETTER I.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Therefore I most entirely agree to the two Conclusions of the Ingenious W. J. wherewith he concludes his Letter. But in the mean time (and pursuantly enough thereto) cannot but doubt the concludingness of his very acute reasonings against, at least, some of the expressions of that learned Person (Dr. Sherl.) which he animadverts upon, as, I perceive you also do p. 16. of your 7th Letter. And even W. J. himself: for with a pious modesty he tells us—concerning infinite Natures he presumes not to determine. Letter, p. 8.
Therefore I most intirely agree to the tvvo Conclusions of the Ingenious W. J. vvherevvith he concludes his Letter. But in the mean time (and pursuantly enough thereto) cannot but doubt the concludingness of his very acute reasonings against, at least, some of the expressions of that learned Person (Dr. Sherl.) vvhich he animadverts upon, as, I perceive you also do p. 16. of your 7th Letter. And even W. J. himself: for vvith a pious modesty he tells us—concerning infinite Natures he presumes not to determine. Letter, p. 8.
What he objects against that Authors having said the divine Persons are three beings really distinct (wherein I instance, not intending to run thorough that elaborate Letter) that then there must be three distinct Essences—seems to me a [Greek or Hebrew]. I doubt not the Author vvill ⟨p. 111⟩easily admit it. But what will be the consequence? That therefore there are three Deities? That cannot be his meaning, nor be consequent from it, if he only mean that the Deity comprehends in it three such essences. If indeed he think those three beings are as distinct as Peter, James, and John; what is said by W. J. against him, I think irrefragable, that then they are no otherwise one, than Peter, James and John; and by him against himself; for Peter, James and John are not mutually self-conscious, as they are asserted to be, which mutual self-consciousness, since it is supposed to make the three divine Persons one, cannot be supposed to leave them so distinct, as they are with whom it is not found.